6 ms·
Why is Google being big a problem? Who are they hurting by being big at this time? [edit]: to elaborate, I was under the impression that the whole point of ant
by ur-whale 8y ago
Why is Google being big a problem? Who are they hurting by being big at this time?
[edit]: to elaborate, I was under the impression that the whole point of anti-monopoly regulations was to protect consumers from monopolistic predatory practices, not to prevent monopolies from actually existing per se.
Hence my question: is there anyone actually being hurt by the currently limited choice of search engines or phone operating systems?
Also, what prevents someone from trying to build a much better one?
If Google starts to misbehave as a monopoly, fine, let the USG (themselves a monopoly, btw) do their thing go after them.
But as long as they provide a superior service for free (yeah, I know, you're the product, blah, blah), I'm not sure I'm seeing the problem.
- adrianN 8y agoTheir competitors?
- ebikelaw 8y agoThis is irrelevant to American anti-trust law. Europe will move to protect competitors, but America will only act to protect the consumer.
- stuckinarut 8y agoAmerica only moves to protect the money.
- ionised 8y agoWhen does the US act in the interest of the consumer?
- aglavine 8y agoIt is already happening that some (old) sites or blogs aren't popping up in their search results.
- hellllllllooo 8y agoOne example: By preventing phone manufacturers who use Android and Google services from also selling phones with other operating systems they are killing the opportunity for another phone OS from gaining traction. We could have missed out on the opportunity for something better than Android being developed and we'll never know. It's called dumping; flooding the market with something free to kill competition and make sure Google is in the majority of hands in Europe.
- trishume 8y agoIf I'm not mistaken, they contractually limited manufacturers from selling devices with Android forks, according to Google to avoid experience fragmentation. AFAIK the terms didn't limit any other operating systems not based on Android.
- maym86 8y agoYep actually I retact part of my original comment. Thanks for the correction. The dumping part is still valid because any OS that isn't free and relies on licencing can't complete with an OS that makes it money from a secondary business like search and advertising. Google gave away Android to make sure it dominated mobile advertising. Any OS reliying on profits directly from licencing the OS cannot complete.
- sievebrain 8y agoYour comment is still false. Google allows Android forks with their services installed. You just can't break the API, which makes sense, otherwise apps from the store wouldn't reliably work.
- maym86 8y agoNo, the dumping part is valid. Free OS with free services to kill competition.
- 8y ago
- zjaffee 8y agoIt's not so much they are hurting anyone, since they have made it virtually impossible to compete with them. Say you do a search for a particular location, the first thing that pops up to the the top of the page is a box with some information pulled from wikipedia and a link/image of it on google maps. Search for a band, and you see the same with links to youtube and google music. Search for online storage and you see the same thing. While google has been audited time and time again to prove that their search engine totally allows competitors to make an impact against some of these sorts of things. Even without the box, the builder of the worlds most used search engine is certainly very good at search engine optimization for their own products.
- booleandilemma 8y agoCouldn’t people just stop using Google search though? There’s Bing, Duckduckgo, Ask.com (are they still around?)
- zjaffee 8y agoThe problem isn't google search as much as it is the fact that google search and their ad products allows them to promote their own products at a cost far less than their competitors.
- mrep 8y agoGoogle advertises their products using their own ad network. And yes, they does cost them in opportunity cost because instead of making money selling that ad spot, they are claiming that space themselves depriving themselves of the revenue.
- whoahnoway 8y agoThere shouldn't be a problem. If I offer two services and I advertise service 2 on the website for service 1 I'm just doing what makes sense.
- booleandilemma 8y ago
- stuckinarut 8y agoIn the US that's true. It's a really awful system.
- ur-whale 8y agoAlso the place where something like Google - massively useful to the whole world - was born. Awful indeed.
- stuckinarut 8y agoand was allowed to grow into a behemoth capable of perverting democracy and engaging in essentially any behaviour it desires, from a business standpoint.