3 ms·
We've seen so many issues with certificate authorities, that validating ownership of certificates based on that system is completely pointless if you're looking
by ocdtrekkie 8y ago
We've seen so many issues with certificate authorities, that validating ownership of certificates based on that system is completely pointless if you're looking for trust.
Like, remember Trustico, the guys who emailed 20,000 of their customer's private keys? They're both still in business, and working with one of the largest registrars: https://www.trustico.com/ https://www.trustico.com/
- tialaramex 8y agoNote that Trustico isn't a CA, just a reseller. Also it is much easier to avoid having your reseller (or your CA, or the guy who cleans your pool) email out your private key if you pick your own key and you know, keep it private, rather than letting them choose it and just hoping they deleted their copy. I actually think we've been doing a fairly good job of cleaning up the Web PKI in recent years and I note that other trusted institutions like major banks and newspapers haven't got spotless records either.
- ocdtrekkie 8y agoTrustico is "just" a reseller, but one working with Comodo, an extremely trusted CA. Which calls a lot into question: If we can't trust Trustico (we can't), but they're able to issue Comodo certs, we really can't trust Comodo either. (Beyond the fact that really, if Comodo is still willing to work with Trustico, it's clear Comodo is also not a trustworthy entity.) And even if you or I don't trust Comodo, our web browsers do, because Google and Mozilla have decided Comodo is trustworthy. I don't understand how anyone can suggest that web PKI isn't totally broken as long as this remains the case. And banks don't have perfect records, but I'm not being forced to use a bank. If Google wants to use it's monopoly to force us all to use PKI, maybe it should fix PKI first.
- tialaramex 8y ago> If we can't trust Trustico (we can't), but they're able to issue Comodo certs, we really can't trust Comodo either. I can't fault this logic, which is why I'm happy to tell you that this isn't how resellers work and hasn't been for many years. They can't "issue Comodo certs", they're just a middleman taking a cut. A reseller isn't trusted by the CA at all in Web PKI terms. They handle some customer service stuff and (like an airline discounter) they allow the headline prices to stay high so that the "real" prices seem cheaper. You don't need to trust Trustico at all, as a Relying Party you're depending on Comodo to do their job, independent of Trustico. If you are a Trustico customer, you needn't trust them beyond the fact that you'll be sending them money, and of course any outfit might take the money and run. If you're very naive and you allow Trustico to have your private key (an arrangement Comodo told them to stop when it signed them up as a reseller) then they have your private key. So, never do that, not with Trustico, not with Comodo, not with anybody. The entire point of a private key is that it's private, we can't make it any clearer than that.