3 ms·
I have mixed feelings on this. On the one hand, I feel there is some fear mongering in it. The equating of transshipping with standing in a dark alley waiting
by salawat 8y ago
I have mixed feelings on this.
On the one hand, I feel there is some fear mongering in it. The equating of transshipping with standing in a dark alley waiting for someone to conduct an illegal transaction is disingenuous. It is what it is.
The concept of International waters recognizes that there is no one claimant with authority over the high seas. It isn't a case of a lack of political will. It's that any overt political will by one actor alone would be perceived as aggression by other major nations. International cooperation is essential difficult to build, and easy to have fall apart with the ebb and flow of popular sentiment.
Trying to reason from satellite and AIS data alone only illustrates operational patterns. Not whether the operation going on at the time is illegal or not unless the illegality is provable by geographic presence alone.
Anything that incentivizes non-participation in broadcasting a navigational aid is more than "appeal to possibility". It is a certainty that someone will eventually end up smacking into a shit running dark. It"s just like the Big Sky Fallacy. Yes there is a lot of sea out there, but there are a lot of vessels as well.
This is good exploratory work, but I would look at getting boots on the ground in terms of joining up with fishing crews to weed out illegal fishing behavior before doing anything drastic that may jeopardize the integrity of an incredibly valuable navigational aid.
- logfromblammo 8y agoThis is just showing the areas on the map where the dark alleys might be, because that's also where all the streets and boulevards are. Red spots are where two AIS transponders got close enough for a transfer between their vessels. Black spots are where one AIS transponder slowed or stopped long enough for a transfer with a non-transponder vessel. A lot of the spots can be explained by completely legitimate floating factory ships, or cargo-ferrying vessels that bring the fish back to port while the fishing boats stay where the fish are. You would need a second data set, containing known-legitimate transfers, to filter out results from the first. As it is now, it's just a map of where fishing activity typically happens. Of course there will be shady transactions somewhere in there, using the massive amount of above-board activity as cover. It's about as useful as saying that one of the fast-food employees at a gigantic food court might also be selling marijuana.