4 ms·
I like Mastodon and ActivityPub, and I like that they're seeing relatively broad adoption. That said, I'm not hopeful for the future. If it ever actually sees b
by Vinnl 8y ago
I like Mastodon and ActivityPub, and I like that they're seeing relatively broad adoption. That said, I'm not hopeful for the future. If it ever actually sees broad adoption beyond the tech community, all Facebook or whatever comes next has to do is incorporate ActivityPub posts into Facebook, perhaps even send back Facebook comments to those posts, but not publish Facebook-originated content. At that point, you can either be on Facebook and follow all your Facebook and ActivityPub friends, or use Mastodon or whatever and only follow your ActivityPub friends.
And even if Facebook does not do that, if a particular ActivityPub client becomes wildly popular, it could do the same, much like how Google Talk started out as interoperable with XMPP, only to ditch it when Google Talk was popular.
- seibelj 8y agoIf a major player like Facebook adopted ActivityPub it would be enormous validation and success, and I seriously doubt they would ever do that.
- tambourine_man 8y agoYeah, if they did, we’d know the had already lost
- wastedhours 8y agoWithout wanting to fall back on an old trope, but: "Embrace, Extend, Extinguish" feels pretty apt here.
- Semaphor 8y agoIt's what they both did with xmpp
- librexpr 8y agoI think that most instances would block Facebook if they tried to do something like that. They'd have nothing to gain and everything to lose by allowing FB to get away with it. As for your other point, it's also possible it will go the way of GMail, which is still compatible with other email providers. I think a large part of it depends on how big ActivityPub gets before a GMastodon appears. Email is pervasive and decently well diversified on the web, with multiple email providers, and many businesses and users not being on GMail, partially due to inertia (they already had an email before GMail became big). Maybe GMail could afford to cut off emails from external providers, but it would be a big risk, and it would definitely break a large part of the web. If ActivityPub does the same, with websites integrating it into their user experience, and news organizations and businesses self-hosting or joining various instances, I expect it would gain the same kind of resilience as email for when a GMastodon shows up. So I'm not too pessimistic about this. The more pressing concern is increasing adoption, IMO.
- NoGravitas 8y agoGMail is starting to close off compatibility with other email providers, in small ways. AMP for email[0], and GMail's Confidential Mode[1]. [0]: https://techcrunch.com/2018/02/13/amp-for-email-is-a-terrible-idea/ https://techcrunch.com/2018/02/13/amp-for-email-is-a-terribl... [1]: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2018/07/between-you-me-and-google-problems-gmails-confidential-mode https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2018/07/between-you-me-and-goo...
- mtgx 8y agoInbox was another attempt at that. If Google wanted true lock-in they could implement a Gmail-only end-to-end encrypted protocol. Ironically, that's the only thing they don't want to do.
- throwaway2048 8y agoAlso its virtually impossible to be smaller than a few hundred mails to gmail a day as a server and not have your mails instantly spamboxed. Yes, i have gone through the laundry lists of things it could be, and stuff i should set up. It does not help.
- s73v3r_ 8y ago"I think that most instances would block Facebook if they tried to do something like that." I don't think so. Doing so would mean that their users wouldn't be able to get events from the biggest network; the one where most people are on. While today, most users of ActivityPub are likely to be people who are against Facebook and not wanting to interact with it, if ActivityPub becomes huge, then more people would be using it that are ambivalent about FB or even users of it. Blocking FB would mean that those people leave the instances, because they're no longer able to get a significant amount of their messages.
- rhizome 8y agoWell, what would probably happen is that Facebook interactivity would be some kind of plugin, which instance runners would have to enable (and possibly configure). Convincing them to do so may not be easy.
- AJ007 8y agoThe big challenge for publishers right now is censorship. Platform censorship happens in many ways: - Visibility hidden because an algorithm in a non-chronological news feed thinks your content won't get enough engagement - Visibility hidden because you aren't buying advertising - Account banning or throttling because of grey area content (everything from nipples to politics) - "De-monetization" (Youtube specific) Most people using the internet are now aware of these problems. It used to be a fringe issue that like people doing SEO and spammers thought about. Will it be easy for a platform to convince content publishers to return after it has chased them off the platform? Facebook's usage exploded just as Myspace's was struggling to keep their servers up and was users were being hammered by very invasive ads. Once those users started logging on to Facebook instead, they never looked back. May be it was inevitable, but there was a very clear value proposition to users and it benefited Facebook immensely. The users were literally chased off of Myspace, by Myspace, and went to Facebook. My hope is that we will get open protocol adaptation instead of startups building another walled garden to replace Facebook/Twitter/Instagram/Youtube. Open protocols are better for everyone, including startups. (and few things scare me more than a startup that is going to "fix email" by creating a new walled platform.)
- guelo 8y agoCensorship is not the root problem. The root problem is spam. For example, the main reason that we all choose one of the giant tech corps to host our email is because of spam. Spam defenses are why it's so difficult to run your own mail server these days. Thus spam causes email provider centralization even though though there is no network effect lock in. Then with centralization you get the secondary problems such as censorship.
- crtasm 8y agoI thought for most people it was because it's free and well known enough they've heard of the service already. Spam filtering is a bonus.
- dan_hawkins 8y agoI host my own mail server and spam is non-existent issue. Especially when you can integrate it with various free antispam info providers.
- eeZah7Ux 8y ago> Google Talk started out as interoperable with XMPP, only to ditch it when Google Talk was popular This behavior is so common it needs a name. Embrace and Switch? Embrace, grow and switch?