5 ms·
>1) its too godamn slow. I have 32 cores, 64 gigs of ram and a massive graphics card, yet draging windows about has lag, pressing the meta key has lag. Its just
by jchw 8y ago
>1) its too godamn slow. I have 32 cores, 64 gigs of ram and a massive graphics card, yet draging windows about has lag, pressing the meta key has lag. Its just not fast like mate or lxde.
I am going to say this is probably only partly GNOME 3's fault. I have only lukewarm feelings about GNOME 3 but was blown away when I ran a distro on a very old Intel NUC only to see GNOME 3 running buttery smooth.
My guess for why is due to the high quality of the open source Intel graphics accelerator drivers on Linux. NVIDIA and AMD do not offer this at all, and at best performance can be tricky depending on what extensions and features your driver supports (and how well your card is supported if using open source drivers.)
Basically, I don't think GNOME 3 is bloated or slow. I think it uses relatively reasonable CPU, but compositing in Linux is complicated due to second-class graphics driver support, and that causes a lot of the lagginess/glitchiness/general wonkiness that you get with the desktop experience. (edit: An example is that I've had issues with resizing Windows that I have found to be NVIDIA-specific.)
(Of course, you can get around this by not using compositing at all, but I think the case for compositing is more than solid at this juncture.)
- bgorman 8y agoAMD and Nvidia both have better drivers than Intel, although admittedly Nvidia only offers proprietary drivers.
- zaarn 8y agoThere is a open source NV driver which is usually the default that gets installed and it really really sucks a lot.
- KaiserPro 8y agoIts the first thing I banish on any image I create.
- franga2000 8y agoIn my experience, the Intel drivers are always the most stable and the closest to their Windows performance. Although I haven't tried the new AMDGPU yet.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- devxpy 8y agoGnome IS slow. Have you used unity 7? It has more animations and effects but still performs way better than gnome3. Gnome3 isn't bloated, it's just written with js. Plain and simple. It's known that driver support is bad. But I think the main problem with gnome is that it uses js. Its runs a whole damn browser (firefox). It's js that owes to the numerous memory leaks that end up hogging extreme amounts of memory.
- yellowapple 8y agoTo build on this: even KDE tends to feel snappier than GNOME3. That's even if I'm going crazy with transparency and wobbly windows and 3D-cube-virtual-desktop-switchers and desktop widgets and all that.
- Klover 8y agoTransparency, wobbly windows, 3D-cube-virtual-desktop-switcher and desktop widgets shouldn't make any impact on any computer with hardware made since like 2007. Windows Vista did it in 2006, and it's 2018 now. We have phones with better hardware than we had at the time.
- jchw 8y agoGnome 3 isn't "written with JS." I am aware that a large amount of gnome shell is written in JS and I have my opinions about that, but they have their reasons. Either way, the bulk of important code (Gtk, Mutter, etc.) is written in C. Also, I don't think it's unlikely you found different desktops that perform better. I still find KDE on proprietary NVIDIA to be lackluster. Does it show it's possible to do better compositing on some setups? Yes. I am guessing GNOME relies on the existence of certain GL extensions to composite efficiently. Still: if it can perform well on super low end systems and poorly on high end ones, I doubt it has to do with JS.
- devxpy 8y agoI was not necessarily talking about performance when mentioning JS. It was the memory leak. Gnome performs "fine?" at bootup, but starts becoming sluggish as you use it because their JS interpreter doesn't automatically have GC. This kind of behaviour is fine for websites since nobody really uses it for an extended period. But for a desktop (which I for once, use for quite long stretches) is unacceptable. I've had cases where I had to forcefully reboot the machine because gnome froze. Even if you ignore the memory leak (and say that it's being fixed) I would argue that the overall latency of the desktop is just not there. I have used xfce, gnome3, unity7, kde, mate and budgie (daily driver) on the same machine, with the same Intel iGPU Mesa driver; gnome3 is the most sluggish. The time it takes for stuff to happen on the screen from when I press a button is quite high for my taste. P.S. I usually disable animations. The design of the desktop is definitely unique and admittedly refreshing to see (except the hamburger menus). However, the sluggishness just makes it impossible for me to use.
- de_watcher 8y ago> NVIDIA and AMD do not offer this at all, and at best performance can be tricky depending on what extensions and features your driver supports Desktop environments usually rely on the most basic features. Games or Unity desktop somehow manage to perform well with their animations with the same drivers.
- KaiserPro 8y agoI'm using the closed nVidia drivers because everything else is an act of madness. (why else would you buy a powerful graphics card if you're not going to use the drivers!?) As a comparison, using kivy (https://kivy.org/ https://kivy.org/) I'm getting constant 60 fps at 4k (I have vsync on and full compositing pipeline to avoid tearing) Compositing in gnome2 was never a problem (once it was stable, back in late 2009) I don't see why its should be a problem with gnome. Now I'm willing to admin that compared to a web app, its snappy. But thats still not fast enough.
- johnny22 8y agoI use the nvidia card for games, but intel for the desktop. It's much better.
- franga2000 8y agoCould you please elaborate a bit on your setup? I don't even know how to check which card is doing the rendering, let alone how to switch it.
- majewsky 8y ago> My guess for why is due to the high quality of the open source Intel graphics accelerator drivers on Linux. NVIDIA and AMD do not offer this at all Serious question: Is your opinion of AMD based on the old radeon driver, the old Catalyst driver, or the new amdgpu driver? Those are three entirely separate and vastly different experiences. I'm using amdgpu at home and have not experienced any performance issues with it at all.
- jchw 8y agoI've been using amdgpu for a year or so (though I just recently stopped, due to computer changes) and it's better yeah. I had a bit of stability issues but it might've been the card.
- HeadsUpHigh 8y ago>I am going to say this is probably only partly GNOME 3's fault. I have only lukewarm feelings about GNOME 3 but was blown away when I ran a distro on a very old Intel NUC only to see GNOME 3 running buttery smooth. Not true. It is 100% gnome's fault. I've used gnome 3( fedora) and I have played a ton of games on the same intel laptop and I have noticed gnome lagging a lot more than any other environment I have ever used. There is a reason for that: Everything is in one thread, including plugins and the js engine and runs on the cpu( no kidding). https://anholt.github.io/twivc4/2018/05/30/twiv/ https://anholt.github.io/twivc4/2018/05/30/twiv/
- chris_wot 8y agoI believe that’s something that is being seriously considered, see https://wiki.gnome.org/Initiatives/Wayland/GnomeShell/GnomeShell4 https://wiki.gnome.org/Initiatives/Wayland/GnomeShell/GnomeS...