3 ms·
> That's why, for instance, I'm very critical of mainsteam journalism and media platforms - all they seem to be doing these days is to sow discord, burning peop
by mindslight 8y ago
> That's why, for instance, I'm very critical of mainsteam journalism and media platforms - all they seem to be doing these days is to sow discord, burning people's trust in institutions to get their eyeballs
And yet here you are, sowing distrust in the media!
This isn't an indictment - I do agree with you on both fronts. I'm pointing out that it's decay-turtles all the way down.
The issue with trust is that it doesn't scale. Or really, as soon as people start trusting symbols (eg institutions), concentrated value is created, which then is profitable to arbitrage away. With the overall trend of increasing communications, we are better able to observe this behind-the-scenes selling out, and thus our trust is eroded.
If we wish to restore faith in our institutions (ie make them trustable again), we need to move their philosophy and governance from "trust" towards "trust but verify".
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> And yet here you are, sowing distrust in the media! Touché. > Or really, as soon as people start trusting symbols (eg institutions), concentrated value is created, which then is profitable to arbitrage away. That is the most succinct way of expressing this that I've ever seen. Thanks! It also explains the problem in terms of the same forces that also drive markets, which sounds very plausible (due to simplicity).
- civilitty 8y agoIt's a great way to frame the current political climate and several crucial periods in American history. The author didn't exactly phrase it that way (he is a historian not an economist) but I'd recommend The Republic for Which It Stands by Richard White from the Oxford History of the United States series. He starts out the acknowledgments "I have written a book about a time of rapid and disorienting change and failed politics, and now I finish it in a parallel universe" and goes into great lengths about the failure of institutions as they tried to rebuild during the hyper polarized post-Civil War Reconstruction era. Reading it is quite unsettling at times because the later years look almost exactly what is happening now with privatization and erosion of government - symbols that were rapidly arbitraged to the highest bidder.
- mindslight 8y agoBeware that I haven't gotten much utility out of it beyond unbridled cynicism. Amazon making bank by coasting on a shared hallucination that their prices are competitive isn't really a big deal, societally. The popping of that bubble won't be a big deal either. Having people view peace officers akin to an occupying military force is a problem (but so was the routine criminality of police before the median person became aware). The troubling bit is that rather than these institutions attempting to self-reform (eg just start prosecuting uniformed criminals), they seem to be digging their heels in - aiming to preserve their power rather than aiming to preserve their justification. Of course this is the same model-precessing modus operandi common to all established organizations, which is why they die so hard. I think the ethos of creative destruction is so baked into our society that we really don't know how to deal with these organizations that have been adopted as institutions and will not simply be left to fail in isolation.