3 ms·
Not a lawyer, but I'd summarize: In Google's view, their use of the parts of the Harmony code as is allowed as the Harmony code is a clean room implementation a
by acqq 16y ago
Not a lawyer, but I'd summarize: In Google's view, their use of the parts of the Harmony code as is allowed as the Harmony code is a clean room implementation and Android doesn't use that code to run Java, so there was no need to get licenses from Sun/Oracle. Regarding patents, they simply claim they don't infringe, I don't see that they claim why -- maybe because they don't actually use any code, but the device makers who install them on their hardware?
- rulereric 16y agoClean room design would be a defense against the copyright charge. They broke clean room design by hiring engineers from sun, jvm engineers etc. Even google's ceo came from sun and he lead java at sun. The patents are integral to the JVM. Google should have bought Palm and Sun for the patents. .NET can step on the JVM patents: http://www.itworld.com/040409microsoftlegal http://www.itworld.com/040409microsoftlegal They got lucky with yahoo: http://news.cnet.com/Google,-Yahoo-bury-the-legal-hatchet/2100-1024_3-5302421.html http://news.cnet.com/Google,-Yahoo-bury-the-legal-hatchet/21... They could have been pushed out of the space. They are use to getting sweet deals in stomping on others patents, copyrights, etc.
- acqq 16y ago> They broke clean room design by hiring engineers from sun, jvm engineers etc. AFAIK not unless Oracle proves that exactly these engineers were involved. And a lot more must be first proved to establish even "involved in what." > The patents are integral to the JVM. Google doesn't use JVM in Android.