5 ms·
And he is right. Time dilation means it's impossible for them to form. (From the POV of me, here on earth.)
by ars 8y ago
And he is right. Time dilation means it's impossible for them to form. (From the POV of me, here on earth.)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- opportune 8y agoyeah, and Zeno's ship never reaches its destination
- oldandtired 8y agoInteresting you bring that up. "Black hole" formation is based on a similar idea. An inversion is used for sure. But the argument used is similar. How about that. I haven't considered that example as a logical means of ruling against "black holes".
- codethief 8y agoConsidering astrophysical evidence to the contrary as well as multiple simplifications(∆) underlying your argument, I'd say he was probably wrong. ∆) (Some of) the assumptions underlying your argument are the following: Assumption 1: We're observers at infinity, observing time as given by the usual Schwarzschild/Kerr coordinate t (let's focus on Schwarzschild for simplicity). Yes, the argument in favor of this is that such observers observe Schwarzschild spacetime to be flat at infinity (which is more or less what we see) but there are certainly other[1] asymptotically flat foliations of Schwarzschild spacetime which don't have a coordinate singularity at the horizon and thus don't exhibit the behavior you describe. I have yet to see a convincing argument for why we, as observers, couldn't perceive any of these other foliations of Schwarzschild spacetime and for why we definitely wouldn't live to see someone else cross the event horizon. (I mean, the fact that this doesn't work in the usual Schwarzschild coordinates is really a consequence of their singular behavior at the horizon, so should be resolved by any smooth/non-singular choice of coordinates—of which there are infinitely many.) Assumption 2: You're talking about a static black hole solution (or a simple spherical shell collapsing) while realistic scenarios of black hole formation are an entirely different beast. Assumption 3: You cannot superpose / easily glue together solutions of Einstein's field equations. So I'd be at least careful making a statement about us, here on Earth, when it comes to a distant black hole. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gullstrand–Painlevé_coordinates https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gullstrand–Painlevé_coordina...
- ars 8y ago> Considering astrophysical evidence to the contrary There is none. The only things that has been observed are supermassive objects. No event horizon or black hole has been seen. Every observation so far is also consistent with Neutron stars. In fact some observations attributed to black holes are actually more consistent with neutron stars because of the same time dilation issues. i.e. we observe the event occurring in finite time. > I have yet to see a convincing argument for why we, as observers, couldn't perceive any of these other foliations of Schwarzschild spacetime For the simple reason that we are not free falling into a black hole. > I mean, the fact that this doesn't work in the usual Schwarzschild coordinates is really a consequence of their singular behavior at the horizon, so should be resolved by any smooth/non-singular choice of coordinates—of which there are infinitely many. Forget mathematical coordinateness. Use the real world. In the real world you can not see a black hole form (or something fall into one) because time dilates to infinity. The fact that there are solutions where it doesn't, hardly matters when none of those solutions are physical. > You're talking about a static black hole solution while a black hole forming is an entirely different matter. That's even worse. The matter falls inward so fast that every atom is massively time dilated (due to velocity) relative to the others, and it perceives them as taking infinite time to reach the center. > So I'd be at least careful making a statement about us, here on Earth, when it comes to a distant black hole. I said that because last time I raised this object people told me "But yah, there are solutions where you do see the black hole form", so I figured I'd preempt that by specifying a POV. It didn't help - you did the exact same thing, told me there are other solutions.
- pdonis 8y ago> Every observation so far is also consistent with Neutron stars. This is not correct. Neutron stars have a maximum mass limit which is somewhere between 1.5 and 3 solar masses. Any compact object over that limit must be a black hole. The hole at the center of our galaxy, which is the subject of the article, is a million or so solar masses, way over the limit. > some observations attributed to black holes are actually more consistent with neutron stars because of the same time dilation issues. i.e. we observe the event occurring in finite time. This is not correct either. Events that happen outside the event horizons of black holes will also emit light signals that reach us in a finite time. > The matter falls inward so fast that every atom is massively time dilated (due to velocity) relative to the others, and it perceives them as taking infinite time to reach the center. This is not correct. You have a flawed understanding of time dilation. Relative to each other, the atoms in an object falling into a black hole are moving very slowly, and the time dilation they see each other to have due to relative motion is negligible.
- pdonis 8y ago> Time dilation means it's impossible for them to form. (From the POV of me, here on earth.) This is not correct. If a black hole forms, it forms regardless of anyone's "POV". All you can say from the "POV" of us on Earth is that we will never be able to see any light signals from at or below the hole's event horizon, since light signals can't escape from there.