6 ms·
IBM's Watson recommended 'unsafe and incorrect' cancer treatments
- billwill 8y agoTo Err is Human. Thus IBM Watson with all the Random Clock work has to work on Human Error.
- spike021 8y agoOut of something from science fiction.. would an "issue" like this ever be the type of problem where the AI can "understand" the cancer better than we can and see where a certain treatment might be more beneficial than we've thought of? Or is this just a plain old failure?
- notfromhere 8y ago"Watson" is a marketing term for a bunch of slap-dash and half-assed analytics products that don't work. It was never more than a cool Jeopardy robot and some sweet Bob Dylan ads
- frgtpsswrdlame 8y ago>Out of something from science fiction.. would an "issue" like this ever be the type of problem where the AI can "understand" the cancer better Ever? I don't see why not. In our lifetime? Probably not and especially not with current technology.
- framebit 8y agoNot to mention that even if the AI technology here was decent (which it doesn't appear to be) it suffered greatly from a dearth of samples. Machine learning requires big data, and cancer treatment data is, in many instances, just not big enough. An AI solution would need millions of well-labeled, perfectly formatted cases to learn from; there may be thousands of those for a particular subtype of cancer, but there's not millions.
- xyhopguy 8y agoNot if you understand mechanism. In reality the breakthrough will be biologists applying ML/AI, not the other way around. Domain and mechanistic knowledge are king.
- chris_mc 8y agoThe example in the article given was that Watson recommended giving a blood thinning agent to someone with "severe bleeding", so I think, at least in this example, that there's a long way to go until Watson is ready for diagnosing without a doctor's consent and review.
- deviationblue 8y agoWe're putting a lot of faith in tools that can best be described as immature. I don't think it's out of the question to get A.I. (not speaking of Watson, which is A.I. adjacent) to the point where it can perform perfectly at human intelligence tasks. The point is to have these systems perform better than their human counterparts (at least, I think that should be aim for something like Watson for Health). The people who built these things are learning themselves. As we make more progress in technology and AI, I don't doubt that we could break that barrier. There may be an upper limit because maybe the human brain is incapable of solving some problems, but even there I think it's not difficult to imagine workarounds. Simply put, I don't think the answer is to think these problems could never be solved. Additionally, human-assisted A.I. is not the solution, it's a non-answer to the problem of creating systems that can think and perform at human levels of intelligence. It's okay to admit if we don't have the ability to make these things, but its disingenuous to believe that human involvement in helping computers get to the right answer is the right answer. Though yes, we need this right now to move things along where they otherwise might stand still.
- binarymax 8y agoTotally agree. Applying existing ML/"AI" to treating cancer is extremely misguided, and IMO dangerous and unethical. ML performs very well for specific well defined tasks that have an obvious outcome and are highly narrow in scope. Cancer is a disease that we can't even treat ourselves in many cases. It requires a great deal of creativity and critical thinking to reach solutions on a case by case basis. Who is so arrogant they thought this should be replaced by a bunch of overhyped software?
- ballenf 8y agoThere has long been a calculus of using more risky or long shot treatments for the more deadly or hopeless diseases. Certain types of cancer are essentially death sentences. Maybe it's counterintuitive, but it makes a lot more sense to use ML for cancer than say a broken arm. There are so many systems interacting in cancer that affect its progression that humans really are at there limits in trying to understand them. And as others have said, no one is letting Baymax loose in the oncology ward and firing all the doctors. This is just one more tool in a doc's tool belt -- and far from the only that will give misleading results.
- fatjokes 8y agoHonest question: how much top-tier ML research comes out of IBM Research? I feel like they get what they paid for---and they pay shit from what I hear.
- framebit 8y agoI'd be very interested in other's opinions, but my observation is that high quality research != good products. There's a major disconnect between the labs and those building/selling the products.
- lawrenceyan 8y agoShould have partnered with Google if you actually wanted something that works. IBM had its heyday, but the brain drain of talent and knowledge has already happened and it likely will never recover.
- _verandaguy 8y agoIs that also true of their quantum computing researchers? It does look like they put out some pretty decent research in that area.
- lawrenceyan 8y agoThe quality level of publications coming out from Google far surpasses IBM both in terms novelty and content in my opinion. Why not look through the papers each company has released though and decide for yourself? https://ai.google/research/teams/applied-science/quantum-ai/ https://ai.google/research/teams/applied-science/quantum-ai/ https://www.ibm.com/blogs/research/category/quantcomp/ https://www.ibm.com/blogs/research/category/quantcomp/
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ma2rten 8y agoI don't think that top-tier research is necessarily equal to top pay. Otherwise universities would not stand any chance. That said, I don't think IBM Watson has published much top-tier research.
- dang 8y agoUrl changed from https://gizmodo.com/ibm-watson-reportedly-recommended-cancer-treatments-tha-1827868882 https://gizmodo.com/ibm-watson-reportedly-recommended-cancer..., which points to this.
- otakucode 8y agoThe headline, and conclusion of the article, feel incomplete. A complete line would read "IBM Watson Reportedly Recommended 'Unsafe and Incorrect' Cancer Treatments At A Rate X% Higher Than Doctors." Doctors make mistake. Machine-based intelligences will make mistakes too. If you throw out a system that errs in 1 in every 100,000 cases so that you can stick with a system that errs in 1 in every 250 cases, you're not going to get anywhere.
- scarejunba 8y agoThat's okay, though, right? We're not talking about fully automating diagnosis and treatment. We're talking about using a tool to help doctors diagnose and treat more effectively. i.e. it's more like predictive text input than anything. If it makes it faster for you to diagnose, makes harder to diagnose stuff easier, and recommends the right treatment most of the time then it saves the doctor some time and energy. The only question is whether it does that.
- jobigoud 8y agoThe other question is how does it compare to human doctors, they also sometimes recommend unsafe or wrong treatment.
- OscarTheGrinch 8y agoThe some other other questions: how much does it cost, compared to training a human? Does it actually save any time / resources if it's outputs must always be scrutinized?
- throwaway5752 8y agoThat may be a question someone outside of an FDA approval process might asked. But if you have been, you understand the importance of "safety and effectiveness", and you will note there is nothing there about "cost effective" or "marketable".
- setr 8y agoOne way I tend to view ML is that, when its wrong, its catastrophically wrong. Because it doesn't actually understand anything its doing, and simply looking at a probability model and picking based off it, you end up with the issue that a few carefully selected pixel changes in a picture of a cat takes the model from a cat to an ostrich. The model does not see a significant difference between the cat/ostrich, or cancer/cold, whereas we do; this implies that, when the model is wrong, it is likely to not just provide an incorrect treatment, but a catastrophically incorrect treatment. Where the human sees a cat-like creature, and if not guess a cat, then something similar to a cat (4 legged, furry, etc), the ML model is willing to jump anywhere, in the worst case. So its not just rate of misdiagnosis, but by how much as well.
- ummonk 8y agoSounds like they prepared limited and bad training data for it. As usual, garbage in, garbage out.
- xyhopguy 8y agoI work in this space. The breakthrough will most likely come from computational biologists, not an external ML group. Liquid biopsy is close and that's the domain that reeeallly needs ML/AI in additional to strong mechanistic models.
- azinman2 8y agoWhat’s liquid biopsy?
- xyhopguy 8y agoHere's a nice review: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/28233803/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/28233803/ a biopsy from your peripheral plasma, opposed to solid tumor. A big issue in cancer medicine is it's super fucking hard to get any kind of noninvasive measurement. Typically it's done with surgery or with CAT scans, which have extremely low precision. Research in the last few years has been pointing to the idea that we can detect tumor derived DNA fragments in plasma. The challenge being, healthy dna makes up 99.9% of it, this means that currently the methods only work when the tumor burden (metastatic for instance) is high. Not ideal for early detection or treatment monitoring. But if the computational tools improve (rn none assume such a low mixture), you could see sensitivity and precision increase to the point that it's useful for predicting therapeutic outcomes and for early detection.
- skynetv2 8y agoremember there was an article about how Watson was recommending treatments that doctors were never considering and that they were more effective. i guess no, they were not even relevant, which is why doctors were not recommending them
- rosser 8y agoBoth that story and this one can be true. It can recommend unconsidered, more effective treatments just as readily as it can recommend unconsidered, dangerous ones — particularly if the system was as extensively trained using MSK's physicians' preferred treatments, instead of (or even additionally to) actual clinical data as The Fine Article suggests.
- ricanontherun 8y agoReally makes me wonder if AI will every be able to model the heuristics which domain experts uses on a daily basis.
- transfire 8y agoWatson was probably right but it didn't fall in line with BigPharma's $$$ plans.
- Gatsky 8y agoWatson is medical AI's Theranos. That IBM would actually try and sell something like this doesn't bode well for their future.
- m0rphy99 8y agoAnyone who has done their research would have known IBM Watson is a scam. IBM has become a complete different company the moment they discovered that they could make far more money just by providing extended consulting service to many governments.