3 ms·
In the case of free will I don't see any intuitive implausibility. It's intuitively plausible that someone/something could exhibit human-like behavior without a
by foldr 8y ago
In the case of free will I don't see any intuitive implausibility. It's intuitively plausible that someone/something could exhibit human-like behavior without actually having free will. After all, some people think that regular humans fall into this category!
- Drakim 8y agoThe issue is that a lot of people look at humans and say "This kind of behavior requires and proves free will", which would mean that exhibiting human-like behavior without free will ought to be impossible.
- foldr 8y agoI don't think anyone concludes that humans have free will on the basis of their behavior. At least, that's a pretty unusual line of argument.
- Drakim 8y agoMaybe not with the wording I used, but I'd say it's actually THE most common argument around. The whole "machines can't love" line. Most people who argue for free will do so on the basis that it appears that we are free, not because there is some physical mechanic of the universe that implies free will.
- bloak 8y agoThe difficultly in deciding whether humans have "free will" suggests that the concept of "free will" might be silly sophistry.
- foldr 8y agoSimilarly, the difficulty in deciding whether or not Goldbach's conjecture holds shows that the concept of "prime number" might be silly sophistry.
- bloak 8y agoHardly worth replying, but I don't see the similarity. A 6-year-old understands perfectly well what a prime number is, and you can write a program to test for primality in half a line of Haskell (though the performance will not be good). Now what's a "free will"?
- foldr 8y agoI was responding to your original claim, which appeared to rest on the assumption that problems which are difficult to solve are likely to be psuedoproblems. I deliberately chose a difficult problem based on a concept that has a clear definition (prime number) in order to show how silly this line of argument is. If you are just saying that it's difficult to come up with a generally agreed upon definition of "free will", then that's of course true. But that doesn't mean that there aren't any genuine philosophical problems relating to free will. By way of analogy, it's also difficult to define terms like "property", "freedom" and "constitution", but that doesn't mean that all of political philosophy is sophistry.