3 ms·
> the fact checkers conveniently ignore controversies that are open and shut bad behaviour on the left Could be true, I guess. Everyone has "perspective" abou
by ajross 8y ago
> the fact checkers conveniently ignore controversies that are open and shut bad behaviour on the left
Could be true, I guess. Everyone has "perspective" about what is important. That still doesn't seem to be a reason to disbelieve a fact checker when they tell you that, say, POTUS is lying, though.
> Though I have to say the whole concept of a single self-appointed authoritative source troubles me, what with its Ministry of Truth overtones.
There are literally multiple competing fact checking organizations. How exactly does that have overtones of centrally enforced authority? How in particular given that the actual central authority in this country has made a habit about calling correct but unflattering coverage "lies"?
- wu-ikkyu 8y ago>Could be true, I guess. Everyone has "perspective" about what is important. That still doesn't seem to be a reason to disbelieve a fact checker It gives reason to doubt based on a known political bias. >How exactly does that have overtones of centrally enforced authority? Because it implies one is unable to determine truths and falsehoods for themselves
- growlist 8y agoThe problem I see is that unless these organisations are beyond criticism they can always be accused of bias and all their work dismissed, and then consider the context: 'It is impossible to overstate the degree of daily vituperation visited upon the president in the media. Comics and actors use their non-political programs to attack him, often to the implicit applause of the press. Virtually all coverage outside the conservative Fox News and isolated conservative outlets is negative, often couched in highly hostile terms. Virtually all of the columnists at the New York Times and the Washington Post, America’s two most respected dailies, despise Trump – and that includes nearly all of the conservative, libertarian and Republican columnists too. Trump supporters who follow news at all cannot escape the daily blast of negativity. This has, predictably, hardened the attitudes of many Trump supporters.' https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/jul/23/liberals-donald-trump-support https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/jul/23/libera...
- ajross 8y agoYou're conflating fact checkers with "the media", and sort of changing the subject. Can you explain again why exactly you don't trust answers you get from Snopes or Politifact? Don't tell me what "many Trump supporters" think. Tell me why you don't trust them.
- growlist 8y agoThat's a fairly aggressive tone of yours. I'm not going to respond.
- knightofmars 8y agogrowlist, as someone who just stumbled upon this thread. There was nothing aggressive about the "tone" of this comment.
- growlist 8y agoIn the first place the post puts words in my mouth, and second it then directs me to answer questions in a not particularly civil manner. And you are borderline gaslighting me by questioning my response!
- growlist 8y agoCan you tell me why I should trust them? Shouldn't we approach these organisations that purport to be the single source of truth with extreme scepticism? Apart from that in my observation these organisations are not impartial, and I think in the context of the universal anti-Trump media they are easily dismissed as just another group suffering from Trump Derangement Syndrome. I should make clear I don't live in the US and so have no direct stake in this and follow it more out of curiosity/amusement than anything else. I'm not going to try to argue Trump doesn't lie, but I think CNN etc are becoming hysterical.