3 ms·
The definition of lying generally involves intent. Do you think these journalists generally are intending to mislead with statements they know are untrue in th
by slg 8y ago
The definition of lying generally involves intent. Do you think these journalists generally are intending to mislead with statements they know are untrue in the same way the producers of fake news do?
- function_seven 8y agoNobody in this thread suggested that the journalists were lying, just that they were terrible at their jobs. They repeated the official line, without questioning the source.
- slg 8y agoThe title of this article and post presents a question. The first comment in this thread appears to be answering that question by blaming it on the NYT.
- function_seven 8y agoRight. By blindly parroting the government's line. By failing to do due diligence, or be skeptical of the sources, etc. Those are all different things than lying. They're lapses in professional care, or shortcomings in ability. Straight up lying could also be involved, sure. But lying isn't necessary for blame to be assigned.
- creaghpatr 8y agoI would go so far to say they willingly participated by trading away scrutiny for access.
- eksu 8y agoSaying the NYTimes spread lies (answering the question in the post title) in a context WMD's or other contexts is not the same thing as saying the NYTimes or journalists were/are lying (with intent).
- cam_l 8y agoI tend to think intent is an outmoded system of morality. It can be faked easily, even to oneself. It is always better to judge outcomes. Actions, not words.. Lying, then, should be judged not on level of intent, but on severity. And on this metric, all those reporters involved should feel, and be judged, personally responsible for the deaths in the iraq war and aftermath.
- igivanov 8y agoThis behaviour covers the whole spectrum from deliberate misinformation to honest belief in the lies they were fed. In between you can find journalists that don't care about the truth but are ready to write anything that pays or ones that would lie for the sake of (in their opinion) a greater good, or ones that would spread lies out of sloppiness or ignorance. This applies to producers of fake news too. I am not sure anyone should bother finding a proper label for each shade of those lies.