8 ms·
Time lost by driving fast
- eggoa 16y agoI like the assumption implicit in this study: time spent driving is equivalent to the time spent dead.
- zeteo 16y agoThe assumption is actually that you'd prefer to spend extra time driving than to correspondingly lower your life expectancy.
- lukifer 16y agoNot necessarily; I often listen to audiobooks and the like while driving, or sometimes I value it as time to think. I've even consumed several dozen college lectures via MIT and UC Berkeley podcasts.
- gregwebs 16y agoI find when an audio-book is truly engaging that I don't realize I just drove 20 miles which probably means I wasn't paying as much attention to the road as I should have.
- dmclain 16y agoThey may have taken this into account, but the worse equivalency in my mind is that a second saved today is equivalent to a second decades from now at the end of my life expectancy. It seems like even a conservative discount rate would completely eliminate any perceived time loss. Computing the discount rate in light of the probability of the singularity or skynet is left as an exercise for the reader.
- timmaah 16y agoWhat about the extra time I get to live because I got to my destination faster? All evens out in the end, right?
- kscaldef 16y agoUh, no, the article is saying precisely that it doesn't all even out in the end: "A approximately 1-km/h (0.6-mph) increase in speed for the average driver yielded a approximately 26-second approximate increase (not decrease) in total expected lost time because the savings from reduced travel time were more than offset by the increased prospect of a crash."
- jerf 16y agoI pretty much stopped caring after "computer model". I find it very hard to believe the putative results are above the noise threshold of errors in the model. In fact the cynic in me finds itself a little surprised that that's the best result they managed to gussy up after fiddling with their model's parameters. I also can't help but think that they could kiss further funding goodbye if they reported that driving faster is better.
- nlavezzo 16y ago>>I also can't help but think that they could kiss further funding goodbye if they reported that driving faster is better. So true...
- danparsonson 16y agoAh, one of my favourite correlation/causation mix-ups. Proving that increased speed is associated with an increased accident rate is not the same as proving that accidents are caused by speeding (and therefore 'accident rate could be reduced by slowing down'). Personally, I'm more inclined to think that dangerous drivers tend to speed more than safe drivers, hence the correlation, but in any case I'd love to see some evidence either way.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- sprout 16y agoWell, it's a simplification of a very complex system. I can think of at least one intersection where even going 40mph in a 35 zone will at least double your risk of a crash. I can think of other situations, for example highway driving, where going 80mph in a 65mph zone probably has an only minor effect compared to going 65mph, and depending on traffic could be safer.
- CWuestefeld 16y agoYes, particularly in light of recent articles I've read describing improved safety as a result of increasing potential confusion (removing lane markers, etc.). The theory is that forcing people to pay attention, well, makes them pay more attention. I'd like to add another possibility beyond what you've noted. Might it be that speed isn't itself more dangerous in that it "causes" accidents, but when an accident occurs and higher velocity is involved, that means more kinetic energy is to be dissipated, and with all that energy in play, the results may be more dire? I'd also like to see more variables factored out of the data. I'd like to know about someone (like me) who observes other safety rules like seatbelts, proper lane discipline including signaling, safe following distances, etc.
- nitrogen 16y agoThe theory is that forcing people to pay attention, well, makes them pay more attention. It seems to me that faster speeds may also force people to pay more attention, as each driving decision occurs in a shorter timespan. As for urban/suburban speeding, the risk factors (pedestrians, children, intersections) are completely different, and increased speeds would clearly increase risk, as well as slow overall traffic flow as fewer cars could successfully turn onto fast-moving streets.
- chasingsparks 16y agoMy problem was the conclusion: "As a nation, drivers in the United States travel slightly too fast and could improve overall life expectancy by decreasing their average speed slightly." As a nation, drivers in the United States travel at pretty much the average speed. (See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speed_limits_by_country http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Speed_limits_by_country) The national comparison seems like a rhetorical device, suggesting American's do something inferior to other countries, therefore we should change to keep up. Instead, you should only conclude that a decrease in speed could increase life expectancy.
- houseabsolute 16y ago> suggesting American's do something inferior to other countries No, it very clearly is only suggesting that Americans are doing something inferior compared to the ideal.
- chasingsparks 16y agoPerhaps you're right regarding what the comparison is inviting. It might not be suggesting cross-country comparisons, but it's still making a normative statement concerning the ideal. My contention is that it should not do that; it should only focus on the decreased probability of death by reducing speed. Weighting the trade-offs is too objective. (Edit: Also, it's a Canadian paper.)
- fleitz 16y agoA Canadian paper on US data, not enough people actually live in Canada for cars to approach each other on average. (I'm Canadian, but also making fun of the abuse of averages to describe this data).
- anthonyb 16y agoTry this article: http://ajph.aphapublications.org/cgi/content/full/93/9/1384 http://ajph.aphapublications.org/cgi/content/full/93/9/1384 Money quote: "While traffic fatalities from 1979 to 2000 declined by 50% in Canada, 46% in Britain, and 48% in Australia, the decline in the United States was only 18%."
- lhnn 16y agoIf -I- didn't crash, I lost no time. Someone else getting in a crash doesn't increase my travelling average.
- frisco 16y agoNot how statistics work...
- deadmansshoes 16y agoIt does if you are stuck in traffic waiting for the accident to be cleared.
- gregable 16y agoMany (hard to say how many) drivers will drive too fast because they are late for something. If you assume that their only goal is to either be on time, not be less late, then speeding makes sense, even in a simulation. Said driver has nothing to lose - they would be late if they didn't speed, crashes also make them late, but at least sometimes they won't crash and will indeed arrive on time.
- fleitz 16y agoInterestingly, most accidents occur below the speed limit and increasing speed limits decrease accidents, because limits are artificially low and thus almost no one heeds them, except for a few people who do who cause accidents because accidents happen when the variability of speed is greatest. http://sense.bc.ca/disc/disc-09.htm http://sense.bc.ca/disc/disc-09.htm What speeding does generally is increase the severity of accidents and alarmingly fast (Thanks, Newton!). Energy levels follow square law and the human body has a rather low ceiling for the amount of energy it can absorb. It makes perfect sense that you're going to see large "averages" especially when the people going most excessively over the limit are the youngest and most inexperienced. Now consider that young people also want to live in dense urban environments where there are a lot of other cars travelling at variable speeds, what you have is a recipe for high statistical impact accidents with energy levels following a square law with a low ceiling for death. Lets look at a rather typical case: Young family, two kids, ages (28,28,2,3) they are travelling 10 over rushing to daycare and jobs, they run into an 85 year old grandpa driving 20 under. Everyone dies, so you have 10 over associated with (75-28+75-28+75-2+75-2) or 240 years of life expectancy, now on the other hand you have 20 under associated with -10 years of life expectancy. Lets not even get into who caused the accident according to anyone but a prosecutor. Do this study on people over 75 and you'll find that old people should drastically increase the speed of their driving. Do this study on 0-10 year olds and you'll find that we shouldn't even be driving at all. The only thing this study says is that young people speed and when they die they have a disproportionate affect on average life span. The rest of it is just asinine statistical interpretations on data that have nothing to with speeding, and everything to do with the fact that the faster you are travelling the more likely you are to die when you crash. If they wanted to make this scientifically valid they should publish a chart showing at what age you should be speeding by how much, because once you're past 2/3rd life expectancy it's advantageous to speed according to this study, but this isn't about science, it's about speed = bad, so they can tax (err.. fine) you for doing it. It's absolutely idiotic to add those numbers given the age and driving preferences and think that speeding is counter productive. This study is as stupid as a study that says that if Bill Gates moves onto your block that everyone on your block becomes a billionaire. Yes, it works on "average" but everyone knows that you still have to go to work (you may even have to speed to get there on time) in the morning if bill gates moves to your block. I'd much rather get in an accident going 10 over a 50 zone than 5 under in a 100 zone (especially if it's on coming traffic). Also, in Montana after a Judge invalidated their speeding laws as unconstitutional the number of accidents dropped. http://www.hwysafety.com/hwy_montana.htm http://www.hwysafety.com/hwy_montana.htm I'll take real world data over a computer model any day of the week.
- omarqureshi 16y agoI'm sure simple things like not looking in mirrors to just being completely stupid and pulling asshat manoeuvres cause more accidents than speeding In my time driving, I have never seen accidents caused by excessive speed but all the time by silliness which would have still resulted in an accident if people drove slower. Methods of speed prevention such as cameras probably cause even more accidents due to last second braking. What is needed is more education in safety on the road and how to control a vehicle or even in multi-tasking such as being told to navigate by yourself to a destination without being told where it as whilst the driver is still a learner.
- mthreat 16y agoTheir conclusion seems incomplete, or maybe they came up with the conclusion before the study. Other possible solutions include: increasing driving skill, paying more attention while driving (no sending text messages), etc
- xenonite 16y agoOh yes, by reducing speed, we could maybe reduce the number of accidents and thus reduce the travel time. BUT - after few years, the drivers will adjust! they will still drive slower, but a little more risky. All the savings will vanish.
- CountHackulus 16y agoIt seems that the authors of the paper are implicitly suggesting that speed limit should be lowered across the board. How about we use that time and money and use it towards better driver education. Something more than a 20 questions test and 10 minutes in the car with a tester would be a good start. Maybe some sort of forced driving school? Then, when everyone's better educated, we can raise the speed limits to reasonable levels and still have less accidents.
- tmsh 16y agoI've actually been thinking about this a lot (recently started commuting from the East Bay to San Mateo). So it's awesome that others are too. Personally, I did a back of the envelope calculation for speeds. Was trying to estimate the time improvements of 65mph over 55mph v. the likelihood of accident. Suffice it to say, you all can do the math. But that's not why I comment. I was actually thinking of a startup idea re: driving and accidents. Specifically, a site attached to Google Maps, etc., where people can register comments about where and how they got involved in an accident. If there were a way to feed in police report data, that would be awesome too. But like the San Mateo bridge. I can see it from my desk. And I can see when it gets slow, and sometimes I'll check sigalert and note that there's been an accident (it seems to me usually at the top of the bridge where it's kind of windy and the furthest left lane has like no shoulder). Or otherwise I've gotten to know where accidents occur on my commute. So my point is that all the information should be readily available so that people can figure out what are the high risk locations of their commute or trip. I think if you had a simple enough interface that integrated with Google Maps, people would voluntarily start using it. To my knowledge, there doesn't exist such a service. Perhaps I'm overly cautious, but I'd use it.
- JeffL 16y agoWould also be useful for people to register where they get their speeding and traffic tickets. As a long time Bay Area resident, I know what stretch of 280 the smokies like to hang out at a lot, and I bet that could be useful information to others, or even others with a satellite navigation program. Would be awesome if your GPS always had a threat level indicator based on accident and ticket likelihoods.
- tmsh 16y agoThat would be awesome. You could even go the next step and include a HUD projected on a portion of your windshield...
- firebones 16y agoIntegrate it with your speedometer, look ahead on your GPS route, factor in time of day vs. likelihood of presence of law enforcement, take into account accident data and risk based on location and time of day, and rather than a HUD, simply have an ambient dash light that boils it all down and glows related to your risk. Integrate GPS+radar detector+Whispernet (real-time wardriving for speed traps). I'm sure with the radar detector this would already break laws in about 30 states, but the core idea still would be viable if all you did was integrate crash data to alert people to risks in areas where their perception of risk was off. If they remake the movie "The Gumball Rally" again in a few years, I'd expect to see this device featured by one of the teams.
- countersignaler 16y agoummm, you can't use observational data to draw conclusions like these. period. you can use them to hint at causations and effects of changes, but you absolutely cannot make conclusive statements like those made in this paper. REALLY bad science.
- sdh 16y agoI have a crazy idea ... I'd like to see all drivers tested and graded for driving competency. Just because you can purchase a car and turn a key doesn't mean you aren't a vehicular homicide waiting to happen. Next, require all drivers to display their current driver "grade" on their car like a license plate. Depending on your driver grade you are allowed to do different things in a vehicle: Lowest Grade - can't drive on the highway (probably eliminating most fatal highway accidents) - can't drive vehicles over a certain weight (hopefully ruling out most minivans and SUVs) - can't drive high-performance vehicles (hopefully eliminating a lot of machismo stupidity) - can't drive above 65 mph - can't ride motorcycles on public roads (reducing harley and sportbike sales by about a million percent) Middle Grade - can't enter the fast lane of a highway - can't drive above 75 mph Highest Grade - can do pretty much whatever the fuck they want etc
- toolate 16y agoAnd of course everyone agreeing with you would be in the highest grade.
- jdavid 16y agoarguments like this are put together for political reasons. someone is looking for more revenue.
- Sukotto 16y agoThis seems akin to economists claiming that a 10% chance at $10,000,000 is just as good as a guaranteed $1,000,000 because on average you end up with the same amount of money. Although it's technically true, any given person is better off choosing the more certain result. that's my initial gut reaction. Though I should add that my gut reaction has a fairly low success ratio when it comes to statistics.
- mildweed 16y agoAnd here I was worried that due to special relativity's time dilation, I was blurring by important moments outside my car. Thank goodness they were only talking about getting into crashes.
- cheald 16y agoThat was my first thought, too. I was hoping for a mathematical analysis in the difference in speed of aging between fast and slow drivers. The real paper was far more useful and mundane.
- code_duck 16y agoThis doesn't include the time you can lose by being pulled over and sitting around for at least 20 minutes? You could especially lose a lot of time eventually if you have to go to traffic court, or are arrested on an unrelated charge (i.e. drugs, half the reason police actually are interested in stopping people for speeding).
- nitrogen 16y agoI wonder if drug users compose a higher proportion of speeders than general members of the population. It seems that random stops should be just as successful at finding illicit substances.
- code_duck 16y agoI've heard police say that they're suspicious of people driving exactly the speed limit, since it appears they may be trying to be extra careful about getting pulled over.
- alphaoverlord 16y agoMed Decis Making has a Impact Factor of 2.597 while, top journals have Impact Factors >30 Although it is hard to compare impact values across disciplines, I would venture to guess this is not the best journal in the world. http://www.sagepub.com/journalsProdDesc.nav?prodId=Journal201430 http://www.sagepub.com/journalsProdDesc.nav?prodId=Journal20... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impact_factor http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impact_factor
- loewenskind 16y agoJust invest more in cars that drive themselves and we can forget all of this stuff. Our grandchildren (hopefully) are going to think we must have been terrified driving around in these big metal beasts surrounded by others doing the same.
- protomyth 16y agoWhen the speed limit was 55 and you happened to be driving in a rural state (ND perhaps), fatigue was a greater danger than anything else. The roads are long and straight and you don't have a huge traffic load. If you covered the driver's speedometer, the driver would naturally be going 75 - 85 on these roads (had several incidents with a couple of friends that demonstrated this). That extra 20 - 30 mph does save quite a lot of time. I do wonder if the results and conclusions of this study are broken out by rural / urban roads. Or, like many studies I see, do they lump everything together or just not study rural areas.
- karlzt 16y agooff topic: how this submission got into the 100 points feed?