2 ms·
Good points, all. It is important to keep in mind the difference between the Georgist position that: 1) "LVT is a positive good and governments should try to
by SilasX 8y ago
Good points, all. It is important to keep in mind the difference between the Georgist position that:
1) "LVT is a positive good and governments should try to collect the entire site value of every property."
vs the more moderate one that:
2) "LVT is the least bad tax and much preferable to taxing positive economic activity like labor, investment, and exchanges."
I think Birch makes a good point that LVT, like all other taxes, will cause horrible distortions once it's high enough. I agree that it's hard to dispute 2), but that's a long way from the 1) promoted in Progress and Poverty.
His other good point, I think, was that you don't actually want to tax the site value, but the site value's net contribution from the other sites (i.e. subtract off the positive externalities the site throws onto others), which in practice is hard to calculate, since you only observe O(n) values (land and structure prices) but need to observe a data point for every pair of properties, O(n^2), to calculate the net improvement.