4 ms·
"Half plant, half animal" seems incorrect: it's an animal that has borrowed some DNA and cell parts from algae.
by davidw 16y ago
"Half plant, half animal" seems incorrect: it's an animal that has borrowed some DNA and cell parts from algae.
- eru 16y agoOr vice versa: It's plant DNA that has infected an animal and uses it for reproduction. The algae's chloroplasts haven't figured out how to survive the step into the next generation, yet, though.
- crayz 16y agoRight. If the genes were giving the snail sores, we'd call it a virus. Perception is reality
- davidw 16y agoWhat I would call reality is the percentage of the genome from the original snails and from the algae.
- eru 16y agoThat's probably a good way to look at the issue.
- 8ren 16y agoOutcome is reality. I recall a definition of mental illness that requires it to have a negative impact on the person. A mutation may be adaptive or maladaptive. It depends on the creature as a whole - and also the current environment. That environment is analogous to the market part of "product+market" for a startup: the identical technology/product can be a winner or a loser, depending on extra-product factors.
- eru 16y agoYes, outcome is reality. But the words we use, plant taking over snail or snail stealing plant genes, are shaped by perception.
- 8ren 16y agoI see that your reply to davidw was about actor/object; but I was replying to crayz, who was talking about "borrowing some DNA"/"being infected" ie. whether the effect was good or bad. hmmm... at least that's how I read him, anyway; but maybe he was also focusing on actor/object... regardless, I still say I have a valid point! :-) Good day, sir!
- nollidge 16y agoBut the plant DNA is encoded into its genome. "Half" is stretching it, but it's certainly partly plant since it received the plant genes via horizontal gene transfer from the algae.