3 ms·
> Charities actually know what to do with it and are far more effective than clumsily trying to do it directly. What gives you so much faith in charities? Wha
by chrisseaton 8y ago
> Charities actually know what to do with it and are far more effective than clumsily trying to do it directly.
What gives you so much faith in charities?
What do charities know about being efficient that other people don't? Why would they be the only ones with good ideas?
Being a charity is just a way to set up an organisation. Having that status doesn't inherently make you a force for good.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- wcarron 8y agoNot OP; just thought I'd chip in organizations like GiveWell. They're a non-profit dedicated to reviewing and researching charities to find the "best", most efficient, cost-effective ones in need of funds. Their website explains better: https://www.givewell.org/ https://www.givewell.org/ Seems like the charities they've selected are well versed in the issues they attempted to address and have done a lot of work finding the best way to address them. After all, the employees of these charities are dedicating their lives and careers to solving a specific problem. Note: I am not affiliated with GiveWell or their charities in any way besides having used them to donate.
- js2 8y agoGiveWell was discussed a bit on HN a couple years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13243780 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13243780
- maym86 8y agoBelieve it or not people actually assess the effectiveness of charities and you can choose good ones. https://www.givewell.org/charities/top-charities https://www.givewell.org/charities/top-charities Some charities are more effective than others and obviously some are used for other reasons (like avoiding tax which silicon valley knows all about). There are good charities that do good work and if you want to help people they already exist. It's not about "good ideas" but actually having the infrastructure and staff to do something that is known to work (e.g. vaccinating people, educating people, housing people, clean water etc.). Your focus on "good ideas" is the problem with Silicon Valley style thinking in this area. It's not the case that if only charities had better ideas they'd be more effective. The ideas and organisations are there. What they need is money and resources. That's where people with money, like Elon Musk, can really help. He could also publicize some charities and not just focus on himself.
- s73v3r_ 8y ago"What gives you so much faith in charities?" What gives you so much faith in a random person who happens to have money? "What do charities know about being efficient that other people don't?" Most of those people have been working with the problem that the charity is tackling a lot longer than some random rich person. Seriously, this statement sounds so much like the, "What makes you think that people who have actually studied the issues know about those issues" sentiment that is going around in the political sphere, and not in a good way. "Having that status doesn't inherently make you a force for good." Neither does being a billionaire.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- chrisseaton 8y agoI'm not claiming to have faith in anyone. I'm saying if I was the billionaire and someone criticised me for using my money directly rather than giving to the charity I'd ask how does that person know the charity is better than me. It seems like people are just seeing the label 'charity' and are thinking it's undeniable that the charity have any idea what they're doing themselves. What causes do you support? If I set up a charity for those causes, took a cut for my salary and distributed the rest of the money as I saw fit, would you give your money to me instead of carrying on as you see fit? But I'm a charity and you're not!
- maym86 8y agoThis was answered in the other replys to your comment. > It seems like people are just seeing the label 'charity' and are thinking it's undeniable that the charity have any idea what they're doing themselves. It seems like you are seeing 'charity' and assuming a lot about peoples level of understanding. > If I set up a charity for those causes, took a cut for my salary and distributed the rest of the money as I saw fit, would you give your money to me instead of carrying on as you see fit? Yes if you were a qualified skilled professional with more experience and dedicated time to do a better job than me at solving difficult problems. It would be much more effective than me doing it part time while I run another business.
- drb91 8y agoBeing a charity is, from my perspective, the only way to organize an organization for collective good. Yes it doesn't imply anything about how your ethics are organized, but if you want to give money to be managed in a way that aligns with your ethics, charities are the most natural solution. You wouldn't give money you hope gets into the hands of a family to a hedge fund, for example--their interests are aligned with financial returns, not giving. A charity is explicitly organized to spend your money in a way that aligns with your values of efficiency. On top of that, as other posters note, there are well-defined metrics for how well money is spent on administration vs on the charity goal.