3 ms·
Do you think the NSA is going to reveal to foreign governments that they've broken AES by going after some guy with child porn on his laptop? I personally doub
by jrockway 16y ago
Do you think the NSA is going to reveal to foreign governments that they've broken AES by going after some guy with child porn on his laptop? I personally doubt it.
Could the NSA cooperate with the FBI? Yes. Will they? Not if it means they can't spy on Russia anymore.
- alextgordon 16y ago"Breaking AES" is not at all necessary. All it takes is one implementation hole, or some plaintext unknowingly cached by a program. The NSA don't merely employ scores of cryptanalysts to sit around all day to try to break ciphers (though I expect they do this too). Exploiting mistakes is their bread and butter.
- jrockway 16y agoAnd "hey guys, stop using that broken software" is not what they want to tell the people they are spying on. Can anyone name one case where the NSA has ever testified for the prosecution?
- pilom 16y agoIt has nothing to do with holes in AES, NSA just has better brute force capabilities than the FBI or any other law enforcement. And while you sit in jail awaiting trial, they take the months it takes to brute force a key.
- rdtsc 16y agoThey could just provide the password without divulging how they did it. The best way would be for them to get the drive, if they crack the password, and the password looks like it could have been guessed or generated from some contextual info about the subject or the case, then they return it the police. If they do crack it but the password is actually a random string and disclosing it would betray NSA's abilities, they they simply refuse to disclose it. On the other hand maybe it would be better to create disinformation that they have cracked all kinds of ciphers or at least their popular implementations? Maybe it will lead enemies to try to implement their own or use alternate implementations that are actually less secure. This will be similar to Airforce's disinformation related to captured UFO tech in the 50s and 60s...