3 ms·
Isn't this just wishful thinking? Everybody hates labels, and so wishes them dead (and for the record, so do I). But just because everyone wants them to die doe
by bambax 16y ago
Isn't this just wishful thinking? Everybody hates labels, and so wishes them dead (and for the record, so do I). But just because everyone wants them to die doesn't mean they will die.
Labels sit on content, and their monopoly is protected by the full force of the law. The number of startups in the field or the evilness of label people does seem a little bit irrelevant.
There is only one way labels can die: if they cease to have a monopoly on music content -- which means, either the world gets rid of copyright, or (young, new and aspiring) artists stop signing with labels.
None of this is happening anytime soon. (It may happen, but in a rather distant future.)
- ethank 16y agoA question, honestly: have you ever visited or spoken to anyone at a label?
- bambax 16y agoI have never visited, no. I know people from school who work at labels, but I can't say I meet with them often. Why the question? EDIT: oh, I understand the question, you work at a label. Well, I live in France, where "Hadopi" just went live. It's a government agency that monitors Internet traffic for copyright infringement and that can then cut off the Internet access of alleged offenders -- not because they themselves are convicted of copyright infringement, but because their Internet connection was used in this manner and they failed to prevent it. This law was inspired by and received the heavy support of professional organisations such as SACEM, etc. When an industry is instrumental in creating such legal monsters, I think it deserves the hate and contempt of the public, and more. Now, none of this has much to do with the subject of the article which was about the "digital future" of the industry. I just wanted to elaborate a little on the "hate" part of my initial post.
- olalonde 16y agoThe article never said labels were going to die. It just pointed out how they screwed their digital future.
- ethank 16y agoI wager it's a bit more complicated than that.
- bambax 16y agoYou're right, but it was largely implied. My point is that the industry is right not to care much about its digital future, and to care more about what matters, ie, their monopoly on content. For as long as this monopoly stands, they will be strong and prosperous. That doesn't make them likable, but that does not make them stupid, either, as the article implies ("They killed competition. Brillant."). Besides, here's what PG writes in one of his essays: If you can figure out a way to turn a billion dollar industry into a fifty million dollar industry, so much the better, if all fifty million go to you. (http://www.paulgraham.com/web20.html http://www.paulgraham.com/web20.html) So maybe the "dream" of a "digital future" is just self-preservation, and maybe, yes, it IS brillant...
- bad_user 16y agoThe irony of the matter is people care: for their music, for their favorite artists, for their lives and moral values. So instead of making people be grateful for their services, the record labels are doing everything in their power to alienate their customers, bullying them into paying: and in the meantime piracy gets stronger and more accepted, since it's a lot more comfortable to just download a torrent (and no matter how much legislation they're lobbying for, the genie is out of the bottle and millions of people are doing it). Not only that, but they've been promoting crappy music for a while now, since it is cheaper to produce and such artists are expendable. I'm not a hater, but as long as they are selling crap, then I'm not buying.