3 ms·
As an industry employee the IP of your work belongs to your employer, I don't think it's a given that it should necessarily be different in research/academia. I
by pc86 8y ago
As an industry employee the IP of your work belongs to your employer, I don't think it's a given that it should necessarily be different in research/academia. It is, obviously, and I think overall that's good, but we shouldn't take it for granted. There's nothing wrong with questioning the status quo.
- __jal 8y agoAs you note, there have been different norms in different institutions, and if you're a used to working for for-profit entities, I'm sure the norms you're used to seem, well, normal. But sure, there's no harm in thought experiments. And we have a lot of different behaviors over time to look at from a range of institutions. You might start asking what changes when incentives are restructured to encourage short-term profit over discovery, and how that might change teaching and research universities. For starters, an easy one: if revenue production becomes the primary measure of the value of a field, how does historical research pay its way while avoiding capture by particular interests? Also, if you want to _really_ be daring, ask questions about what might happen if employees weren't forced by default into work-for-hire arrangements. What if corps were a bit more like academia?
- a-dub 8y agoEmployer-employee relationships are very different from PI-institution relationships. PIs operate like little businesses within an institution. They write their own grants for their own funding. Sometimes the institution coughs up some corn, but usually it goes the other way. The institution extracts overheads from grant funds to pay for infrastructure. When it comes to matters of research, it's rare in the American system that PIs take orders from the institution.