4 ms·
Recently I've been watching a bunch of retro-computing stuff on YouTube, and the restoration projects that people embark on have made me wonder how hard it woul
by mrweasel 8y ago
Recently I've been watching a bunch of retro-computing stuff on YouTube, and the restoration projects that people embark on have made me wonder how hard it would be to reproduce the required chips?
Sure the C64 can just be emulated, and there are kit allowing you to fit a RaspberryPi in a C64 case, and use the keyboard, but it's not really the same.
- exikyut 8y agoBesides cost ($2000 per sq mm for fabrication) and design (the hardware design industry requires 6-7 figure $ software, and nothing is open source), the main problem is copyright and IP. Any venture will require sufficient funding - and (by necessity) produce sufficient volume that it creates a pile of press - that nobody will touch it unless the copyright and IP issues are 100.00% cleared by a very large pile of lawyers.
- userbinator 8y agothe main problem is copyright and IP. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Integrated_circuit_layout_design_protection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Integrated_circuit_layout_desi... The term of protection for IC layouts is only 10 years in the US --- i.e. long expired. $2000 per sq mm for fabrication That's if you want to use the newer processes; if you're reproducing old chips, something like 0.7um CMOS (already considered "old" today, those in the C64 are multiple-um) is only ~$300/mm^2: http://www.europractice-ic.com/docs/archive/171213_MPW2018-general-v2.0.pdf http://www.europractice-ic.com/docs/archive/171213_MPW2018-g...
- exikyut 8y agoWait. How do chip manufacturers protect their designs?! I'm very curious. And thanks for the notes about CMOS, I'm very interested in chip design and $300 is rather affordable for hobbyist-level tinkering. Now just to have chip design tools take off... :)
- slededit 8y agoYou make the old design obsolete and therefore worthless. Combine that with strict trade secret and contractual protections and you are fairly close. But if someone wants to reverse engineer your chip they will.
- exikyut 8y agoI suddenly understand why there are so few open design tools and so much [trade] secrecy. Wow, this is kind of sad. I'm cynical any laws implemented now would truly protect though, considering the state the world seems to be in...
- pkaye 8y agoI used to work for a chip design company. They would get samples of competitive product and do competitive analysis and also see if they might be copying your technology. Once we had licensed a technology to another company for inclusion in specific products with some royalties. At some point they terminated that relationship saying they are no longer using the technology. We found that was not true a bit later and a lawsuit was initiated.
- Graham24 8y agoTry the 8 bit guy's you tube channel.
- mrweasel 8y agoI know :-) His content is fantastic.
- classichasclass 8y agoPart of the problem with the SID particularly is its analogue components, such as the filter, which are very hard to simulate digitally. It's not just demos that depend on their behaviour. Even Commodore themselves weren't able to reproduce all of its subtleties (i.e., the 6581 vs 8580 differences). Bob Yannes did some amazing things with the chip, especially considering the limitations he had to work under: http://sid.kubarth.com/articles/interview_bob_yannes.html http://sid.kubarth.com/articles/interview_bob_yannes.html
- tibbon 8y agoI do wonder what it would take to emulate it more properly on a component level. It's definitely a "weird" filter and doesn't behave like one would assume it to.
- opencl 8y agoYou could probably emulate the analog sections with a circuit simulator like SPICE.
- 8bitsrule 8y agoAnalog is hard to emulate well. At least, I've never heard of a decent emulation of the legendary Moog filter. 'Infinite' trumps 'many'
- mrob 8y agoAnalog is hard to emulate because real components have complicated non-linear and stateful behaviors, and because real circuits are full of parasitic components, not because of "infinite" anything. Analog circuits have finite SNR and bandwidth, and the "many" of digital can easily exceed them. Analog circuits also tend to have high variation between units. You might have a perfect simulation of the average hardware, but it won't necessarily sound like your specific hardware. You'll need to measure your hardware and tune the simulation to match. People have done this for SID chips: https://bel.fi/alankila/c64-sw/yourchip.html https://bel.fi/alankila/c64-sw/yourchip.html
- szczys 8y agoDig into this forum thread which does a great job of reverse engineering the silicon design: http://forum.6502.org/viewtopic.php?f=8&t=4150 http://forum.6502.org/viewtopic.php?f=8&t=4150 Theoretically you could reproduce this with discrete components if you can figure out the entire circuit. That would be a pretty epic build that I'd love to see!