4 ms·
> So of course, with this uninfringed right, you have people killing their spouse, children accidentally killing their family members, people seeking help after
by pdonis 8y ago
> So of course, with this uninfringed right, you have people killing their spouse, children accidentally killing their family members, people seeking help after a car crash getting shot [1], increased rates of suicide, etc. etc. That's not to mention otherwise lawful firearms owners shooting up schools, churches, and theaters.
You're leaving out some key factors.
First, firearm violence in the US (like violence in general) is highly locality dependent. It's not a coincidence that the incident you linked to of a woman getting shot while seeking help after a car accident happened in Detroit. Most of the US has
a rate of violence (firearm and otherwise) than is at or below the norm in European countries like Switzerland. The statistics you see don't show this because they average over the entire country instead of separating out the particular areas where almost all of the violence actually happens.
Second, the localities in the US that have high rates of violence, including firearm violence, are all inner cities that have been run for decades by liberal governments that have imposed strict controls on firearm ownership. The rest of the US, which, as above, looks like Switzerland as far as violence is concerned, has much more reasonable policies on firearm ownership. So at least in the US, the data does not support the common claim that gun control reduces firearm violence; it supports the opposite claim.
Third, the mass shootings that make the news are most often not perpetrated using firearms that were legally owned by the shooters. Either they were legally owned by someone else and the shooter got access to them (illegally), or they were illegally obtained by the shooter in the first place.
- acjohnson55 8y agoYou don't even attempt to cite any stats that would show that non-urban America is as safe as Europe. And it's a stretch to believe because Europe doesn't have semi-regular gun massacres, which aren't actually happening in inner cities. Guns are widely available in high crime areas because it's trivial to travel to a jurisdiction where buying them is legal. We also have very little liability for what happens with a gun you own or sale when it's not in your possession. If this weren't the case, you'd see much fewer firearms getting into the hands of criminals.
- pdonis 8y ago> Europe doesn't have semi-regular gun massacres https://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2015/jun/22/barack-obama/barack-obama-correct-mass-killings-dont-happen-oth/ https://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2015/jun... > semi-regular gun massacres, which aren't actually happening in inner cities. You're right, "inner cities" was too narrow. "Urban areas" would be better. The point is that the localities are isolated; they aren't evenly spread across the US, they're concentrated in certain places, and those places all have a common factor that I described.
- pdonis 8y ago> We also have very little liability for what happens with a gun you own or sale when it's not in your possession For "own", yes, you're right; greater accountability for gun owners who let others use their guns would be a good idea. For "sale", not so much; selling something means transferring ownership, which means once you've sold it, you aren't responsible any more because you aren't the owner. The new owner is the one who should be held responsible.
- pdonis 8y ago> You don't even attempt to cite any stats Neither did the post I responded to. See here for some stats on US gun violence in 2018 (the site also has data for past years): http://www.gunviolencearchive.org/charts-and-maps http://www.gunviolencearchive.org/charts-and-maps