3 ms·
> It boils down to "the second amendment gives me the right to own/buy/manufacture any weapon I need to defend myself against tyranny." At the time the amendme
by pdonis 8y ago
> It boils down to "the second amendment gives me the right to own/buy/manufacture any weapon I need to defend myself against tyranny."
At the time the amendment was passed, privately owned warships, comparable in power to those available to governments, were common. In fact the use of such warships as privateers was a key component of the United States' strategy in both the War of Independence and the War of 1812.
The current situation, where governments have a level of force available to them that is much, much greater than that available to any private entity, is a large change from the situation throughout most of human history. That might indeed make it a good idea to talk about a further amendment to balance the right to keep and bear arms with the realities of current weaponry; but unless and until that happens, the second amendment says what it says and you can't just ignore that because you don't like the implications.
- pas 8y ago> but unless and until that happens, the second amendment says what it says and you can't just ignore that because you don't like the implications. People are not ignoring it. And a lot of people think that the SC has the duty and responsibility to [re]interpret the Constitution every time they consult it. Therefore there might not be a need for a new Amendment. Of course, cleaning up the mess would be great with a new Constitution. But the time is not right for that, reason is not hip enough nowadays.