5 ms·
I can see two counter arguments. One, you don't want to go with Twitter, or any large corporation for that matter, to court. They have a legion of lawyers and y
by elorant 8y ago
I can see two counter arguments. One, you don't want to go with Twitter, or any large corporation for that matter, to court. They have a legion of lawyers and you don't. They have budgets for these kind of cases, you don't. Even if any dispute you have with them won't make it to a court you'll lose precious time and resources consulting with lawyers in order to answer their C&D demands, which I guess at some point will escalate if you keep ignoring them.
Then you have the practical part. Would you really base your project on reverse engineering and hacking a third party service? It will end up being an arms race. Everytime they change something you'll race to hack it again. In the meantime your service will be inoperable. If your user base is in the tens of thousands that will kill you. I can't think of any reliable service that every couple of months or so would go offline even for a few hours until the developer finds a way to circumvent whatever countermeasure Twitter came up with.
So you play nice and follow their rules. Even if they suck, which by the way is the main reason why Twitter lost all the love of developers and has stagnated for the last years.
- gluelogic 8y ago> Would you really base your project on reverse engineering and hacking a third party service? It will end up being an arms race. Everytime they change something you'll race to hack it again. In the meantime your service will be inoperable. If your user base is in the tens of thousands that will kill you. Depends on what the service is. youtube-dl faces this issue but is some of the best software I have ever used.
- roryisok 8y ago> some of the best software I have ever used That's some hefty praise, do you mind explaining why it's so great?
- ballenf 8y ago> It will end up being an arms race. Everytime they change something you'll race to hack it again. In the meantime your service will be inoperable. They (any service with a large user base across many devices) are at a serious disadvantage of not being 100% in control of app upgrades across the legion of devices and app versions supported. They are just as likely to break a legitimate user's app as yours (even higher, imo). I don't think the technical war is nearly as difficult as you imagine. On the legal side, you might be right depending on the geographical location of the dev. In regard to the original question, I think we'll begin to see a shift in that direction as these services tighten the screws. Like youtube-dl, Youtube++ app is a relief to anyone who watches much YT on a phone/tablet. It's easily sideloadable even on iOS and actually puts the user first with regard to permanently settable playback speed and ability to hide algorithmic suggestions among many other tweaks. It's based on a year+ old version of the official app and is still working fine even after being DMCAd. So you know they got Google's attention, but haven't had to update the app in almost a year. I also see these gray area tools as an important check on the power of the platforms to not abuse their dominance. Like jailbreaking was before Apple started incorporating many of the more popular tweaks into iOS itself.
- roryisok 8y agoI've never even heard of YouTube++ but it sounds like I need it in my life
- jhall1468 8y ago> They (any service with a large user base across many devices) are at a serious disadvantage of not being 100% in control of app upgrades across the legion of devices and app versions supported. They are just as likely to break a legitimate user's app as yours (even higher, imo). Yes they are? Alternative apps use the official API, their internal services use their internal API's, which are also likely versioned. So if the internal DM API has an upgrade, the website can change to the new version while the mobile app is using the previous version. youtube-dl and Youtube++ are already solved problems. The fact that you have to sideload it means the user market is tiny and at this point I highly doubt YT even cares anymore. > I also see these gray area tools as an important check on the power of the platforms to not abuse their dominance. This is the weirdest thing you've said in a whole lot of weird things. YT proved how powerful it was via demonetization of so many creators videos. Nobody could do anything about it, primarily because the real power behind YT is that creators don't have an alternative, not users.