6 ms·
So, let me get this straight: you seriously believe that Twitter is going to randomly select a handful of users and try to throw the book directly at them (as t
by saurik 8y ago
So, let me get this straight: you seriously believe that Twitter is going to randomly select a handful of users and try to throw the book directly at them (as the person who made the client is not subject to the service's terms of service). Generally the only tort expressabale against someone who violates terms of service is "the service can be revoked" (or like, at worse, the "damages" involved... good luck demonstrating those against an individual user ;P), and so far as we have seen there is no reasonable civil argument (the DMCA certainly doesn't apply and the CFAA is rapidly being determined to not apply); but let's say that this was an option: you feel like some massive hefty fine or maybe a jail sentence for some random user (as again: the person who wrote the client isn't doing anything wrong) is going to serve Twitter's interests here?
- tptacek 8y agoI'm not sure I understand how you're using the word "tort". A tort is an action that causes damage. Obviously, Twitter can suspend service for a user violating their agreements, or, if the user is causing damage and circumventing Twitter's controls, they can go further and sue. Fines and jail sentences are things only the government can impose. I'm not talking about what the government might do to someone violating Twitter's user agreements (I doubt they'd do much). The overall gist of your argument is really hard to understand. Twitter makes a service available conditioned on an agreement they have with their users. That agreement is binding. The legal issues here seem pretty straightforward. It's possible that we're talking about different actors in this story. You might be thinking I'm saying Twitter is likely to sue individual users who use third-party clients. I don't think that will ever happen. On the other hand, if you're the kind of organization Twitter is describing in this bulletin, making potentially millions of dollars by abusing the Twitter APIs to spam or deceive users, I have no problem at all seeing how Twitter might seek recourse in civil court. It's their site, and access is conditioned on their rules.
- cestith 8y agoHave you heard of Aaron Swartz?
- aptwebapps 8y agoHe's suggesting developers extract the keys from the official Twitter client and use those, bypassing the usual developer agreement.