5 ms·
The article does a good job of revealing the degree of superstition in that very poorly educated and isolated area. (I am referring, for example, to the claims
by tokenadult 16y ago
The article does a good job of revealing the degree of superstition in that very poorly educated and isolated area. (I am referring, for example, to the claims that drones leave behind "poisonous dust," not a very likely payload at all.) If that superstition turns into hatred of America, that can't be good for United States foreign policy. Regions that are safe havens for the Taliban and Al-Qaeda include so many people who think so differently from people in the developed world that it may be very difficult to find a way to gain support for shutting down the terrorist networks. This is a bad situation all around.
- Retric 16y agoBeing a first responder to a bomb site means you’re dealing with more than just the bomb payload. You are also breathing flecks of paint and other substances suddenly liberated into the air. IMO, they are simply describing what happens when you show up to a bombed out building and assuming the effects are from the bomb. causes a variety of ailments, from diarrhea to skin disease PS: The dust around a non explosive building demolition is also reasonably toxic.
- m0th87 16y agoIt's not just the poor and isolated areas. Islamabad is rife with conspiracy theorists who think every mishap in Pakistan has a CIA agent involved somehow.
- run4yourlives 16y agoThis is the great issue that the US - over and over again - fails to grasp: You cannot use technology to bring a mind into agreement with your objectives. The only way to win the hearts and minds of the people in that region is to meet them face to face where they live. Talk to them, argue with them, protect them and if required kill them. They need to see you as real, your objectives as firm statements - even if they disagree - and your resolve complete. They respect the strong and the committed, they deride the weak and conflicted. This is a human war, and the only thing accomplished by flying drones around is a further separation from the people subject to their actions from the values of the people flying them. All everyone ever really wants is to have a better life for themselves and their family. Maslow's hierarchy of needs suggests that if you can address or improve the base of the pyramid, you can restructure the entire pyramid. You can see easily how perverse religion warps the perception by manipulating these base needs; pretending that they aren't required, or even rejecting them outright as evil. What we should be doing in Pakistan is essentially ignoring the fundamentalist nature of the region and showering them with things to address the bottom two levels of the pyramid. Yes this is a massive short term investment and yes this will cost lives. Be sure though that it is the only way for the west to win this war over the long term. Every drone bringing faceless death from the sky only prolongs it.
- krschultz 16y agoThis is a very popular opinion these days, but since when do we have to win the hearts and minds to win the war? What if the US just nukes every country with terrorists in it? There would hypothetically be no terrorists left, and everyone would work very hard not to be grouped in with those countires, otherwise they're going to get nuked too. It sounds crazy (and I certainly don't condone that strategy), but realize that is one of the other options. For the vast majority of history winning wars didn't rely on winning the hearts and minds of anyone, it relied on the complete destruction and subjugation of the other faction. You could say "this war is different", but it really is not. It is different than the West on West wars of the last 3 centuries, but it is no different than a lot of guerilla wars in the past. The Native Americans tried really hard to stop Americans from expanding into their land - and the US won that guerilla war by just excersizing extreme cruelty. Trying to win hearts and minds is a losing strategy against an opponent who doesn't care about that at all. The terrorists are not trying to win our hearts and minds, they are trying to kill as many Americans as possible. That makes their goals a lot easier to achieve. Can we really invade every single country that holds some people that want us dead and "meet them face to face". Hell no, that would require conquering the whole world, which is impossible even for the US. The other option is making an example of a country and dissuading every other country from allowing terrorists to exist inside their borders, lest they end up like country X or Y that was conquered by the US. Unfortunately by bungling in Iraq and forgetting about Afghanistan, the US ends up just looking weak. The reality is that the biggest obstacle to total victory is the lack of support for the level of violence required to win a war like this. The American people just won't stomach anywhere near the level of damage inflicted on the opponent in World War 1 or 2. Thus with "total domination" off of the play book, we have "ignore borders and start dropping hellfire missiles on people no matter where they are" as a the current method for dealing with people. Overall, I'd consider it far more humanitarian than the other options.
- run4yourlives 16y agoWhat if the US just nukes every country with terrorists in it? Well, you'll get the war you're looking for that's for sure. Unfortunately, you might actually be fighting a war that looks more like the downfall of the Roman empire than the liberation you seem to think you'll achieve. This isn't really a winnable strategy, even if you win the actual conflict. For the vast majority of history winning wars didn't rely on winning the hearts and minds of anyone, it relied on the complete destruction and subjugation of the other faction. History shows that wars without a clear decisive outcome tend to drag on for generations. "Most wars" did exactly that. The fact that WWII did have such an clear outcome does not make it the norm, even with the idea of "total domination". Wars of ideas(opposed to those over resources and/or land) don't end until one of the ideas goes out of fashion. The cold war is a perfect example of this. That stalemate ended because the communists didn't think their ideas would work. It had little to do with how many nukes the west could muster. In the same light, radical Islam - I could argue Islam/religion itself - can only be "defeated" when the Islamics themselves decide that the particular path that they are on isn't worth the struggle. People turn to religion - any religion - when their needs are not being met. This is true even in the West - the Catholic church was the supreme authority during the dark ages, when Europe was suffering, and the Muslim world was enjoying a much less religious but more established existence a few miles away. Fulfill the needs of the person to a basic level and religion offers nothing. You cannot win a war of ideas until you kill the idea, not the person.
- spot 16y agoIt's not the superstition that turns into hatred, it's the civilian casualties. This is part of a positive feedback loop: http://seminal.firedoglake.com/diary/74916 http://seminal.firedoglake.com/diary/74916 Even those who "think differently" understand food, medicine, education, etc. It would be quite easy to wage peace instead of war, but Obama made his choice.
- krschultz 16y agoThat is a false choice. If we decided tomorrow to just up and leave in a week, would you describe the aftermath in Iraq and Afghanistan "peace"? Is "peace" when Americans aren't getting killed? Because the US would suffer far fewer casualities if we just bailed entirely and let the sects in Iraq duke it out amongst themselves and we let the Taliban run over Afghanistan again, but the people in those countries would suffer more. Now that we're trying to get out of these countries, further US troops are basically trading their lives for some multiple of that number in civilians lives that would be lost if we just let the countries collaspe. Take your pick, it seems to me that Obama (and Bush at the end) was choosing to lose US lives to prevent the anarchy and loss of foreign civilian lives that would result of an irresponsible exit. Arguing that we shouldn't have gone in the first place (which I think is the case) doesn't change the fact that today we are already there.
- spot 16y agoAh yes, the old "we are bombing them for their own good" argument. To answer your question directly, yes it would be more peaceful (it was more peaceful in both cases before we invaded and i expect things would settle down pretty soon after we left). More importantly, the blood would not be on our hands. And (I'll say it again) if we waged peace by providing food, medicine, education, etc we could save a lot of lives, instead of stoking the cycle of violence.
- ansible 16y agoWhen an A-10 Warthog shoots a tank with depleted uranium (DU) rounds, it definitely leaves behind poisonous dust. Sure, they're 100% wrong that the Predator weapons systems don't do that. Are we really expecting these people (who don't have Internet access and aren't War Nerd fans) to understand the differences? I'm actually a little impressed that these people even are aware of issues like that. In the old days, you'd know when the war is coming towards you. And a guy shooting someone with a gun is an easily understood event to even the most uneducated. However, in this new kind of war, you hear the buzzing of the drones, but you have no idea how far away they are (they are supposed to be hard to see). And then, occasionally (which is worse than regularly) something blows up, almost as if by magic. The Hellfire missle tops out at mach 1.3, so you're not going to hear it coming. Those people are suffering the classic stress symptoms of people living in a war zone.