4 ms·
> According to the lawsuit, in June 2018 Everest determined both the 2016 and 2017 breaches were covered exclusively by the debit card rider, and not the $8 mil
by dmix 8y ago
> According to the lawsuit, in June 2018 Everest determined both the 2016 and 2017 breaches were covered exclusively by the debit card rider, and not the $8 million C&E (“computer and electronic crime”) rider
Jeez, insurance companies are all the same. Regardless if you're an individual or a bank with millions on the line... you get treated with the same slight of hands and nonsense interpretations of reality.
> those exclusions rules out coverage for any loss “resulting directly or indirectly from the use or purported use of credit, debit, charge, access, convenience, or other cards . .
How could a spear phishing campaign using malware that hijacked critical parts of the banks infrastructure not be part of the C&E coverage, and merely 'debit and credit'. The last part was merely how the money was exfiltrated. But the entire crime was the result of the intrusion.
This seems like an easy to win case to me. But who knows.
- kennxfl 8y agoThe incumbents in the insurance/banking industry will have to invest heavily in security and in some cases overhaul entire systems. Personally I think its more cost effective long-term than hiring a bunch of lobby groups and lawyers to find loopholes. I mean the Equifax security was laughable and no one got in trouble. I wouldn't be surprised if this case takes a complete 180 from common sense.
- javiramos 8y agoAre there objective audits or rankings where financial institutions are assessed for their cyber-security measures/infrastructure? How do I even know whether my bank has good security? Cyber-security being such a major threat, I would be willing to change banks if my bank is proven to have crappy online security.
- kennxfl 8y agoIf any exists, its by third parties who have no insight from the inside. Central banks wouldn't disclose 'cyber-security index' in stress tests due to the risk of scaring customers off or causing a bank run.
- jdironman 8y agoOr risk inviting attacks.
- AmericanChopper 8y agoEven well written standards are not objectively audited. There’s a huge variety in the quality of external auditing, and a fair amount of pay-to-play. A lot of people will tell you that every PCI certified company to ever be involved in a breach was non-compliant at the time of the breach. Is that because the PCI DSS is such a remarkable standard that complying with it will protect you from 100% of breaches? Or is it because you can retroactively find some type of issue with 100% of PCI audits?
- CPLX 8y agoThis is how legal arguments work when actual money is at stake. If there's a non-insane point of view that says you could interpret a clause in either direction one side takes one position and the other side takes the other position. It's usually something similar to this, for example a policy with a clause saying we always cover if X and another clause saying we never cover if Y, when both X and Y are true. That kind of thing. My favorite example along these lines is the insurance for the World Trade Center disaster, which hinged on a question of if the 9/11 attacks were one event, or two, since of course it was two separate planes taking off at different airports piloted by different terrorists. No matter how much you plan ahead and try to use definitive language it's usually possible to end up in a spot where it's still a matter of debate. In this case it's a lot of discussion of proximate cause (the phrase "but for" is the tell there) which is a standard feature of insurance claim arguments after some sort of major loss. Typically what happens is each side assesses how close the other's argument is to compelling and then based on that both sides come to a settlement agreement.
- duxup 8y ago'no consumer could reasonably be misled into thinking vitaminwater was a healthy beverage' People will argue anything.
- umanwizard 8y agoIs that really the exact language they used in their briefs?
- avip 8y ago"Our policy covers everything except your specific case".