3 ms·
"The point in contention isn't that infinities can be imagined, it is whether they are useful - specifically in the context of cosmology." Going the other way
by jerf 8y ago
"The point in contention isn't that infinities can be imagined, it is whether they are useful - specifically in the context of cosmology."
Going the other way may be more useful; is it possible to create a correct model of reality that does not at any point use infinities? You could have alternate correct models that do, but if you can create one without them you'd have a reasonable basis to call the infinities in the other models unnecessary and nonexistent.
(I would suggest before anyone rush to correct me that they read what I said carefully. For instance, "reasonable basis" != "undeniable proof", which experience leads me to believe is a difference a hypothetical replier might, in their rush to reply, overlook. Also note the two clauses in the question; if it is simply impossible to create a correct model of reality at all, we may never get to the "infinity" portion of the question.)
- simonh 8y agoIf you could do that - create a correct model of reality - at all infinities or not, there's a Nobel Prize with your name on it. :)