6 ms·
Role-playing game theory
- lainga 8y agoThe "threefold model" just begs an RPG about DMing a tabletop game, where DMs fall into a class system between Game, Drama or Simulation (replacing Warrior, Rogue, and Wizard).
- AnthonBerg 8y ago... which begs a trading card game on how to crowdfund a tabletop game about DMing, right?
- lainga 8y agoI place my Kickstarter Bonus card into defense to add a new reward tier to roll d20 to ask my Mom to order pizza for the party, and end my turn.
- _raoulcousins 8y agoSomewhat related: Millenium Blades, a board game that simulates the game and metagame of trading card games, had a Kickstarter.
- digi_owl 8y agooh, dear. Not this tar pit...
- sovok_x 8y agoI see all those hypotheses but are those verifiable? Did they result in some solid explanations that allowed useful predictions to be made? Or do they play "my idea is better" game? (edit: yeah, silently downvote people asking questions... people shouldn't ask things. Or is it some sore I stepped on unknowingly?)
- __jal 8y agoThink of them more as a variation of literary criticism. I can't prove with p<.05 that my review of _Schoolhouse Rock_ is 'correct', either.
- sovok_x 8y agoBut can't you verify a good theory of RPG by creating a novel game that will be much appreciated or fixing some existing games making them more interesting? Like how music theory improved musicians' work and resulted in a better music, musician communication and even got used for creative AIs while music is very subjective too?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- whatshisface 8y ago"Literary theory," as it is called, is actually not theory. It's the production of commentaries that are designed to make you say, "ah, yes." In other words it's a derivative art form like collage or remixing. You can tell the difference because there is no way to tell if a paper is right or not other than by deciding if it sounds right to you, which is no less subjective than anything else in art. In contrast, music theory is put to the test every day when musicians become successful with its help, and scientific theories are, well, you already know.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- forapurpose 8y ago> You can tell the difference because there is no way to tell if a paper is right or not other than by deciding if it sounds right to you, which is no less subjective than anything else in art. It's true that there is no way to logically prove the value of a work of art (and who says art has or needs "value"?), but lack of proof doesn't mean something doesn't exit; it means it's harder to think about. There is no proof what will happen tomorrow, but we make judgments without it, as we do about most things: Should I take this job? Should I marry this person? Do they love me? Do I love them? Should I ask out the new neighbor? Ubuntu or Fedora? There's no algorithm to understanding art; there are tools, but there is no certainty. Without a logic map, it can be very challenging - in the best way, IMHO, because it brings forth and develops my deepest thinking and compels me to challenge myself and my perspective. I can't prove a Miro is better than your neighbor's kid's drawing ... and I guess I don't really care to; I'm going to study the Miro.
- tomkat0789 8y agoThis made me wonder: what parts of our pop culture will be studied as rigorously as historical literature? Where will RPGs and video games fit in? Will some odd history professor in 2100 awkwardly DM a game for bored future college student equivalents?
- gallerdude 8y agoI'm under the belief that the original Star Wars will be studied alongside epics like The Iliad and The Odyssey. It was hugely impactful when released, reinterpreted the hero's journey for the 20th century, and even has its own holiday.
- andrepd 8y agoI strongly beg to disagree. It is massively popular, sure. In the end, however, it's just a mediocre story full of holes and inconsistencies, among shoddy worldbuilding. Cannot be put on the same level as a classical epic.
- forapurpose 8y ago> full of holes and inconsistencies, among shoddy worldbuilding I'm not sure that is the reason for the difference. The Odyssey has plenty of gaping holes and shoddy worldbuilding, plus some inconsistencies. For example, the plot of the very end flops IMHO (and less humbly opinionated people agree); you have to strain to give it much credit. What I think separates it from Star Wars and most other stories ever created is its reflection of humanity. The characters and social interactions are so true and so rich - not at the superficial layer, where there are gods and magic, but at the core of anger, pride, love, compromise, fear, uncertainty, joy, power, etc. - you can look at it and deep into it forever and will never run dry. If I can run on a bit, Dante wrote, nature takes her course from the divine mind and its art ... your art, as far as it can, follows nature as the pupil the master, so that your art is to God, as it were, a grandchild.[0] The Odyssey fulfills that, IMHO; a wonder of mortal creation. Tangentially, Odysseus is one of the most unpleasant characters in all of literature, in deed and personality. Even on Game of Thrones he would be at the bottom of the barrel. [0] About himself! It's in Inferno; Dante conveniently put those lines in the mouth of another character speaking to the author. EDIT: Major edits
- peterashford 8y agoI've always felt that analysis of art is the surest way to kill it. Obviously, other people differ in this regard.
- muzani 8y agoI've always loved analyzing art. Something about art tugs at the heartstrings. The search on what exactly tugs the heartstrings often teaches me a lot about myself.
- leoc 8y agoThe original Threefold Model/GDS theory FAQ is engagingly written, very persuasive and well worth anyone's time http://www.darkshire.net/~jhkim/rpg/theory/threefold/ http://www.darkshire.net/~jhkim/rpg/theory/threefold/ . I feel you start to hit diminishing returns after that.
- esoteric_wombat 8y agoIf you're interested in a more detailed survey of rpg theory I highly recommend the recently published "Role-Playing Game Studies: A Transmedia Approach" and specifically the chapter "RPG Theorizing by Designers and Players". For a much broader historical work there's also Playing at the World by Jon Peterson. For something more bite sized (and free) check out http://analoggamestudies.org/ http://analoggamestudies.org/
- Fnoord 8y agoLadan's raiding research blog, about World of Warcraft raiding phenomenon [1] [1] http://www.raidingresearch.co.uk/ http://www.raidingresearch.co.uk/
- erickhill 8y agoNot one single mention of Dungeons & Dragons? Yet Magic and World of Warcraft? Really. Hm.
- mireofthedeep 8y agoGygax and Arneson are quite like synonyms for D&D.