4 ms·
The caseloads of public defense attorneys (particularly in historically segregated states) are significantly more burdensome than that of prosecutors. Furthermo
by wahern 8y ago
The caseloads of public defense attorneys (particularly in historically segregated states) are significantly more burdensome than that of prosecutors. Furthermore, prosecutors have access to free investigation services--the cops--whereas defense attorneys, particularly the overloaded ones, don't have much if any budget for that kind of work. Sometimes they'll pay out-out-pocket to track down witnesses using private investigators, but for obvious reasons that doesn't scale.
Some cities like San Francisco have laws that enforce rough parity in budgeting and caseload, but even then public defenders are at a huge disadvantage (e.g. prosecutors benefit from the police budget).
For practical reasons there's no way to address this adequately. The underclass is too numerous, and disparity in wealth too great, to think we can fix this administratively. The best first step is to make the stakes less severe by lowering penalties. Not everything needs to be a 1st degree felony. The next step is to be more consistent--pursue misdemeanor charges and lesser felonies more vigorously so that outcomes are more consistent, regardless of the wealth or stature of the client. Tweak the system so that it will tend toward more equal outcomes, rather than trying to brute force it.