3 ms·
For air travel, yes. Large ships are large, and, unlike aircraft, have sufficient room and carrying capacity to install reasonably efficient carbon-capturing
by nine_k 8y ago
For air travel, yes.
Large ships are large, and, unlike aircraft, have sufficient room and carrying capacity to install reasonably efficient carbon-capturing devices.
It will cost a lot, of course.
- WalterBright 8y agoThere was a push to add computer-operated sails to cargo ships in the 80s. I don't know what happened to it - likely the cost of fuel dropped.
- larkeith 8y agoThere's a company that makes kite sails for cargo ships, which have proven effective [1]. However, as the fuel costs are payed by the shipper, there is a lack of economic incentive for ship owners to purchase them. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SkySails https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SkySails
- unBrainSurgeon 8y agoHmmm, so what's a good mechanism for routing around moral hazards like just making the customer pay for the fuel? We see lots of models for corporate raiders using loss leaders to attack bloated industries, but not much else. Also, with technology, the actual cost of development is extremely murky and variable. The only things that seem to motivate loss leader tactics is the end game of cornering a market. In the case of SkySails, ship owners are averse to the up front cost, even if it means leaving money on the table, long term, by keeping their prices the same, but saving the fuel money with the sail, and pocketing the difference. So, push to integrate with newly built ships, and then what? Offer freebie/rebate deals? But then they never get used because crew are lazy, and bored, but not that bored, and lazy wins. Plus dealing with tangled lines means the kite is all but ruined without a rigger available. So does that mean training at least one crew member to rig the kite? It seems like maybe SkySails would need to operate a consultancy, where they supply a crew member who operates the kite on commission, collecting a cut of the savings in fuel costs. Then it becomes not unlike the vending machine model. Companies permit vending machines on the premises, because they know employees want snacks, so they let a coin-op company install soda and candy machines, and they get a cut of whatever the machine pulls in. So now, if that works, and then SkySails attacks the ship building angle, they've grown an ecosystem of consultant experts, and some of them can operate as free agents, once ship builders normalize SkySail integration as a common well-known add-on to maritime operations. Sounds like a business odyssey, thinking it over, but with decades of quiet patience and dedication, maybe it'd work.
- larkeith 8y agoThere's also currently a lack of incentives for ship owners to invest in emissions-reducing technologies, even if the cost per voyage is reduced - see SkySail's troubles [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SkySails https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SkySails
- Reason077 8y agoThe real issue that fuel oil is so cheap. If customers are paying for the fuel, and fuel was a significant cost, then they'd certainly be interested in shopping around for a ship that can offer lower fuel consumption. But fuel oil is really just a byproduct of refining crude. It's the muck left over when you've extracted everything else that's useful. And of course, it is not taxed, so prices don't account for it's environmental externalities. If we can reduce overall demand for petroleum products, this should eventually cause fuel oil prices to rise because there'll be less crude being refined, and thus reduced supply.