3 ms·

This may come across as argumentative, but it's still a valid question - What's the harm to you?

ggg9990 8y ago
The harm is that 1) data which seems anonymized can be de-anonymized due to carelessness or advances in analytical techniques, and 2) it’s mine. I have laptops in my house for example that I’ve not used in years and will never use again. That doesn’t give you the right to steal them even if there’s no explicit “harm” to me.
another-one-off 8y ago
The point of consent is that it isn't your (or Dropbox's) opinion on what constitutes harm that matters. It is the person who gives consent.
jeffwass 8y ago
Maybe the parent was performing a research project on Dropbox collaboration techniques and got scooped? But seriously, as an example, I know people that share sensitive personal information with their accountants at tax time using Dropbox. Would suck for any of that to be made available to any third parties.
nl 8y ago
Given it was from universities, then prior disclosure of IP for patent applications could be a "harm". Even the directory names and structures could be key information in some applications.
ggg9990 8y ago
Imagine you have a folder in your Dropbox with 237 subfolders, and each of those subfolders has a certain number of files in it. The largest folder has 1,132 files, for example, the second largest has 916, the third-largest has 771, etc. Then imagine you have a second folder with 117 subfolders with another pattern like above. Now imagine that the first folder structure matches a torrent of embarrassing pornography and the second appears to be a superset of a project published to GitHub under your name (i.e. with some directories being gitignored)
avs733 8y ago
Not the op but I'll answer for myself. I've stored non anoynmized data on Dropbox as part of my own research. IRB gave me permission to keep that data and my consent form explained it to participants. We were all working under the assumption this type of sharing by Dropbox was impossible. My school's IRB does not allow the use of Google drive for nonanonymized data storage based on just this type of concern.

The harm is that 1) data which seems anonymized can be de-anonymized due to carelessness or advances in analytical techniques, and 2) it’s mine. I have laptops in my house for example that I’ve not used in years and will never use again. That doesn’t give you the right to steal them even if there’s no explicit “harm” to me.

another-one-off 8y ago

The point of consent is that it isn't your (or Dropbox's) opinion on what constitutes harm that matters. It is the person who gives consent.

jeffwass 8y ago

Maybe the parent was performing a research project on Dropbox collaboration techniques and got scooped? But seriously, as an example, I know people that share sensitive personal information with their accountants at tax time using Dropbox. Would suck for any of that to be made available to any third parties.

nl 8y ago

Given it was from universities, then prior disclosure of IP for patent applications could be a "harm". Even the directory names and structures could be key information in some applications.

ggg9990 8y ago

Imagine you have a folder in your Dropbox with 237 subfolders, and each of those subfolders has a certain number of files in it. The largest folder has 1,132 files, for example, the second largest has 916, the third-largest has 771, etc. Then imagine you have a second folder with 117 subfolders with another pattern like above. Now imagine that the first folder structure matches a torrent of embarrassing pornography and the second appears to be a superset of a project published to GitHub under your name (i.e. with some directories being gitignored)

avs733 8y ago

Not the op but I'll answer for myself. I've stored non anoynmized data on Dropbox as part of my own research. IRB gave me permission to keep that data and my consent form explained it to participants. We were all working under the assumption this type of sharing by Dropbox was impossible. My school's IRB does not allow the use of Google drive for nonanonymized data storage based on just this type of concern.