3 ms·
Basically make the state hire lawyers and mandate any lawyer can't work one side or the other more than 2/3 of the time per year (or some such)
by colechristensen 8y ago
Basically make the state hire lawyers and mandate any lawyer can't work one side or the other more than 2/3 of the time per year (or some such)
- dragonwriter 8y agoDo you really want your criminal defense to be handled by someone for whom up to 2/3 of their job may require close cooperation and good working relationships with the police?
- aonet23sntaoe 8y agoTo me, it's kind of like, "know thy enemy." If you've worked with them, you know their dirty tricks. If they know they're going to be up against you, they may be less inclined to use them because they know that you know what they're up to.
- rhizome 8y agoYes. Former prosecutors make good defense lawyers because they more-intimately know how the other side thinks.
- dragonwriter 8y agoThere is a difference between former prosecutors (who have knowledge of a prosecutor but not the political and institutional incentives of a prosecutor) and someone who much of their current workload is as a public prosecutor. Yes, a former prosecutor is a great person to get as a defense attorney. That's not the question I asked.
- rhizome 8y agoYou asked a question about a hypothetical, but I don't know why a relationship with police should necessarily inhibit good representation. That said, it's not like the defense/prosecutor caseload would be the only thing to change if this hypo came to be. It wouldn't happen in a vacuum, no "suppose everything was the same tomorrow except everybody's calendar got mixed up!"
- dragonwriter 8y agoWell, sure, if we enter a world where criminal convictions aren't politically useful stepping stones in the way successful criminal defenses aren't, the plan is great.