3 ms·
One thing I don't understand is why are apps like authy or google authenticator not using push notifications to allow you to directly auth via unlocking or touc
by baby 8y ago
One thing I don't understand is why are apps like authy or google authenticator not using push notifications to allow you to directly auth via unlocking or touchID instead of having to go through the app. If you really want the user to type something then you can still use push notitication for easy app access
- jrowley 8y agoAuthy used to have push notification support for LastPass but it has stopped working for me.
- cube2222 8y agoLogging in to Google works exactly like this at the moment. It's probably because setting this up is more involved for the backend, setting up that key which you have to type in is fairly simple technically.
- brightball 8y agoSome do. A lot of companies that use Duo will set that up for their internals. The problem is that those push solutions require that the company have some means of communicating with the app that you're using to trigger the push and the confirmation (as far as I can tell). This technology works around that by letting the browser talk to the plugged in device, circumventing all of the network/api bits.
- spacehunt 8y agoTOTP is designed to be usable even while offline.
- Klathmon 8y agoBut is that trade off worth it? Is the ability to work offline worth giving up a simple prevention of phishing attacks?
- klodolph 8y agoFull circle here, since FIDO U2F has phishing-resistance like push notifications and lets you work offline like TOTP. "Offline" in the sense that everything besides whatever you're authenticating against can be offline.
- closeparen 8y agoPush notifications offer no phishing resistance. The attacker can present a fake login experience and conduct a real login behind the scenes at the same time. If you think you’re logging in, you’ll approve the push for them.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- gowld 8y agoIf you are offline, how do you transmit the TOTP value-of-the-moment to the location where the protected resource is?
- guipsp 8y agoThat's the 'T' in 'TOTP': it's Time-Based (if the clocks aren't synced it doesn't work)
- baby 8y agoA push notification to help you open the app doesn't prevent the app being usable offline though.
- xhzkdnzhzjdkri 8y agoLord, I hope there aren't apps trying to use TOTP offline. TOTP works by using a shared secret between user and service. This secret and the current time are used to generate a code. All parties involved must have the secret (this isn't public key crypto). That means an app that can accept TOTP offline has the secret stored locally where it can be extracted.
- judge2020 8y agoIt's mainly an issue with infrastructure and syncing a 2fa code to a specific phone or app. Sending a push notification requires GA to register for push notifications with a server that has the Apple APNS certificate or firebase key. Google would likely have to run this central server and provide a portal/cloud console API for developers to register for sending these push notifications. Authy already does this, providing both the TOTP and the ability to send "is this you signing in? yes/no" push notifications, however, charges for it: https://www.twilio.com/authy/pricing https://www.twilio.com/authy/pricing which is likely why not many providers actually use Authy and just generate a standard GA-compatible TOTP token.
- baby 8y agoAh! Thanks for this answer. Makes sense.
- monocularvision 8y agoOkta provides this capability.
- 394549 8y ago> One thing I don't understand is why are apps like authy or google authenticator not using push notifications to allow you to directly auth via unlocking or touchID instead of having to go through the app. If you really want the user to type something then you can still use push notitication for easy app access My company has something like that, through Symantec. When you need to authenticate, it sends a notification to your phone over the network for you to acknowledge. It's terrible though: cell signal is horrible in our building, so the people who use it are constantly dealing with delays and timeouts. I opted for a hard token that has no extra network dependencies, and I'm happy with my decision.
- bubblethink 8y agoThank god they don't. I had to recently extract the keys from Duo's store for precisely this reason. All the notification crap is proprietary and uses GCM. It won't work on AOSP.
- SSLy 8y agoMS authenticator does that