4 ms·
>The article doesn't spend 1 second explaining the answer promised Actually it does, it's one of the first things in the article: >Whenever a task is automate
by mrweasel 8y ago
>The article doesn't spend 1 second explaining the answer promised
Actually it does, it's one of the first things in the article:
>Whenever a task is automated, the employee who performed it is trained for another one worth equivalent pay.
The issue is that this only covers one small way an employee could be made redundant. You could apply the idea of retraining to other companies and other layoff scenarios, but it doesn't help if your entire industry is falling part or the company simply isn't viable.
- vortico 8y agoFor Zildjian, it's a no-brainer to re-train an existing employee to use a new pressing tool than to lay them off, hire another employee, and then train them to use the new tool that the original employee could have just learned in the first place. It's not a company secret that CNBC managed to pry from the Zildjian CEO, it's just common sense. This is why I say that the article's reason is hardly a reason for Zildjian's no-layoff practices, because this sort of common sense is applied in many companies where layoffs are still present. The most significant reason (among other contributing factors) is the "increasing workload during recessions" practice that I described.
- toyg 8y ago> it's a no-brainer to re-train an existing employee to use a new pressing tool than to lay them off, hire another employee, and then train them to use the new tool If this was so self-evident, though, everyone would do it. In practice, a lot of companies don't even try to "teach new tricks to an old dog", preferring to go through the layoff/hiring churn instead. That's probably got more to do with the traditional link between pay and seniority, than to anything really related to skills: a relatively small disruption in productivity is handsomely offset by a big net cut in salary expenses, as the younger employee will likely command a much lower wage.
- vortico 8y agoCan you give an example of a situation where a company has laid off, hired, and trained, when re-training would have been equal or less effort?
- toyg 8y agoJust pick any big company that announced large-scale layoffs in the last 20 years. They start re-hiring almost immediately. In some cases they even announce hiring plans while they announce layoffs - and the percentage of workers being retrained or moved internally during these events is usually pretty low. It's difficult to believe that tens of thousands of workers cannot be retrained, when corporate roles are increasingly described as "bullshit jobs" anyway. > when re-training would have been equal or less effort That's the issue, isn't it? You cannot meaningfully measure that effort at scale[1], and even if you could, it's an effort that product/line managers would likely have to make. Whereas firing and hiring is basically zero effort, because most of the donkeywork is done by HR. So as a line manager, you take the hit of a short disruption in operations, cash in a lower wage bill, and your job is done. [1] if we could meaningfully measure training effort vs results, we wouldn't have a market full of e-learning products that are invariably terrible but super-expensive.
- vortico 8y agoI don't believe your experience that big companies almost immediately re-hire after layoffs, for jobs that require training from square one (after firing square-one employees). In the tech field, I've seen plenty of re-hires right after layoffs, but the companies are always replacing them with engineers/developers/factory workers who possess an entirely different skill set that is well beyond the scope of what the company is responsible for training them for. E.g. firing your jQueryers to bring in a team with 2+ years of modern web framework experience, laying off data analysts to bring in machine learning experts, letting your financial team go and bringing in a diverse team of accountants with experience in international finance. I've never seen a direct example of a company removing their electricians because they don't have "Acme high voltage" certification and hiring other electricians with the plan to give them Acme high voltage certification. Outside of tech, you've got me. I have no idea. If this is specifically what you're talking about, I'll have to take your word for it. >You cannot meaningfully measure that effort at scale Sure you can. "Do you have experience with our aluminum hydraulic press tool? No? What about you, potential hire? No?" Then the probabilistic expected value of time/money to train would be equal.
- philipodonnell 8y ago> That's probably got more to do with the traditional link between pay and seniority, than to anything really related to skills: a relatively small disruption in productivity is handsomely offset by a big net cut in salary expenses, as the younger employee will likely command a much lower wage. Not really. Large scale layoffs are way more disruptive and expensive than the savings by rotating into lower seniority people. Every company we work with aggressively hires from its transitioning employee pool to save institutional knowledge and severance costs. Some even provide a multi-month working period to give them time to find something internally. A surprisingly high percentage get rehired. But the simple fact is that most companies don't employ a workforce that can be "trained on a new machine" and be just as productive as someone who has years of experience with it. Its not like learning another programming language. Skills gaps are real. Source: I work for a company who helps people who lose their jobs to layoffs
- convolvatron 8y agoit looks like cymbals are spun, meaning rolled over a mandrel spinning on a lathe by manual force. its not rocket science, but spinners do have a craft and you wouldn't trade an old hand for a pimply faced youth without good reason. one of the real tricks here is having a knack for distributing the material so that you end up with an even thickness.