4 ms·
Which vague term? The problem in The Ship of Theseus is one of identity: do objects have historical properties (i.e., do they undergo change but remain "the th
by woodruffw 8y ago
Which vague term?
The problem in The Ship of Theseus is one of identity: do objects have historical properties (i.e., do they undergo change but remain "the thing"), or do they become new objects when change occurs? Taking either horn leads to radical conclusions about the objects we interact with on a daily basis, and so we have a paradox.
There are plenty of examples of vague and ambiguous language in philosophy, but I think that the SoT remains problematic without them.
- dooglius 8y agoThis is just moving to vagueness in the definition of "object". >Taking either horn leads to radical conclusions about the objects we interact with on a daily basis How would someone deal with objects in the real world differently based on a solution to this supposed problem? In what context is the distinction important?
- woodruffw 8y agoBy "object," I just mean "a thing in the world." We can talk in particulars: a candle, a ship, whatever. I don't disagree that there's plenty of room for vagueness there, but I don't think that either of us has particularly vague definitions of "object" in mind. > How would someone deal with objects in the real world differently based on a solution to this supposed problem? The simplest example is in the second case: if we were to conclude that objects don't contain historical properties, then we would be hard pressed to accept any sort of continuity. Am I the same person as I was a moment ago? Am I responsible for "my" future actions, even if it's not "me"? The first case also has problems: if objects encapsulate their historical properties, then how did we end up with two objects? Which one of them is the "real" one, i.e. the one with the name "Theseus's Ship"?
- ucaetano 8y ago> By "object," I just mean "a thing in the world." We can talk in particulars: a candle, a ship, whatever. That is still a vague definition. Are you talking about the set of matter (atoms, etc.) in their certain relative positions and interactions? Are you talking about the general usefulness? Defining object in this sense (as in the object "ship of Theseus") will solve the problem of SoT.
- andrepd 8y agoThat is exactly the question. When, in your daily life, or in law, or in your dealings, you talk about an "object", which do you mean?
- dooglius 8y agoWhat would it mean if objects didn't "contain historical properties"? What would it mean if they did? What would be different if you were "responsible" for your future actions versus if you weren't? Let me give some examples of where the distinction could actually be meaningful: Logistically, the museum can only put one of the ships up for display. Which one should it choose? The museum hires you to compile a database of all its historical items that can be browsed online. Should you put the "Ships of Theseus" in a single row, or two rows, one for each ship? A rich and extravagant museum visitor, after seeing the ship on display (whichever one that is), offers the museum a generous sum to purchase it. Later, when he learns of the second ship, he is outraged and demands his money back. Should the museum reverse the deal? Prior to the second ship being reconstructed, the museum had taken out an insurance policy on the "Ship of Theseus". Later, when there are two ships in existence, the second ship burns down in an unfortunate fire. Should the insurance company compensate the museum? Would it matter if the other ship burned instead? After finding and deciphering ancient journals from the Theseus crew, the museum learns that treasure may be hidden within the wood of the ship. Which ship should be searched? The museum trades one of the ships to a neighboring museum in exchange for other historical items. Later, both museums begin advertising that they have the original Ship of Theseus on display. Should both be allowed to advertise this? These examples give, I think, differing and nuanced notions of what the "Ship of Theseus", and even an "object" is. There is no reason why there should be a singular "right answer" that applies universally, without a sense of what question is being asked or what problem needs to be solved.
- ucaetano 8y ago> Which vague term? "the same", as in "is it the same ship?".
- Felz 8y agoIdentity is not a concept the universe recognizes. The basic building blocks of the universe provably have no identity; all atoms composed the same are interchangeable. Of course a philosopher would never realize that, because they'd never bother looking hard enough to get to quantum mechanics. There is no Ship of Theseusness that gets transferred at any point. You just built a leaky abstraction over how things really work, and surprise: it's leaky.
- andrepd 8y agoIf we reduced the world to only fundamental concepts and discarded everything else... Well basic physics would survive, and not much else. Nonetheless there is knowledge beyond fundamental physics, meaningful knowledge.
- c3534l 8y agoI'm afraid you're actually engaging in the Ship of Theseus problem there. Your conclusion about why the Ship of Theseus is not actually a paradox is the very point of the parable. Another person might suggest that objects really are things. In fact, I would. If you replaced every atom in my body with a different atom of the same type, would I still be me? I would argue yes, that you've not made an identical copy of me. You're clearly taking a philosophical position on the meaning of the parable, yet pretending you're not doing philosophy in the process. It seems that's what a lot of people in this thread chain are doing, assuming their interpretation is the correct one and that philosophy is therefor BS to even ask the question. Everyone does philosophy all the time, but some people do it completely uninformed of the thousands of years of debate we've had on it.
- Felz 8y ago> If you replaced every atom in my body with a different atom of the same type, would I still be me? I would argue yes, that you've not made an identical copy of me. I don't agree with everything Yudkowsky says, but he makes my point here: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/Bp8vnEciPA5TXSy6f/can-you-prove-two-particles-are-identical https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/Bp8vnEciPA5TXSy6f/can-you-pr... There is no "if you replaced every atom in your body". That's not even describable with what we know of the universe's fundamentals. It's an abstraction we layer on top so we can make sense of it. There is no useful debate about whether it's true or not, because it's just something we choose. I'm not taking a position. I'm dissolving the question. I don't care if that's secretly "doing philosophy" or not. If it upsets you that I think there's no value in "thousands of years of debate" and things that most people would consider philosophy, prove me wrong.