4 ms·
They do happen to have the advantage of being somewhat of a niche product with inelastic demand and (to my knowledge) no good automated substitute. I'm sure th
by nerdponx 8y ago
They do happen to have the advantage of being somewhat of a niche product with inelastic demand and (to my knowledge) no good automated substitute. I'm sure that if somebody figured out a way to make cymbals as good as these on an automated line, they'd do so.
That aside, this was an interesting quote:
The Greek immigrant has been retrained seven times in 40 years
- vinceguidry 8y agoIf anyone is going to figure out how, it'll be Zildjian.
- anigbrowl 8y agoIt's not like there aren't other firms in this space or that cymbals are unique to one culture.
- puranjay 8y agoMusicians tend to be extremely particular about the tone of their instruments and will be very brand loyal. To get people to adopt new cymbals would mean getting millions of drum teachers to adopt new cymbals, then their pupils.
- userbinator 8y agoThe placebo effect is also very strong: http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/notrocketscience/2012/01/02/violinists-cant-tell-the-difference-between-stradivarius-violins-and-new-ones/ http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/notrocketscience/2012/01/0... ...and as general audiophilia shows, this is true in general: if you think it sounds better or distinctive, it will. Unfortunately it doesn't seem anyone has done a similar study with cymbals yet.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoOnce a company has a 'owned' a category in such a thing they're almost impossible to displace because the sound would have to be considerably better. With symbols ... well ... that's not going to happen. So it's a nice niche.
- Spooky23 8y agoPeople are truly a great asset for a company. It’s amazing to me that so few people realize this.
- greglindahl 8y agoYou might take a look at the movie industry for an example: it's all people, but the companies don't employ them for very long. Yet people make lucrative careers out of a zillion short-term gigs.
- dogma1138 8y agoThe movie industry is a per-project industry where there is going to big shift in employment as productions ramp on and ramp off. Companies that provide services to the industry and core studios do retain staff especially those which are not part of the guild/union structure. It’s also important to note that many unions in the movie industry push for contracts rather than full time employment as it gives them more power.
- Spooky23 8y agoDon't movie people basically work for the union?
- cyberferret 8y agoSabian is another cymbal company that was started off by a former employee or family member from Zildjian IIRC. They are almost as well known as each other in the music world. A bit like Fender and Gibson are to guitarists.
- sonnyblarney 8y agoI would add 'brand' as one of their most unassailable competitive advantages.
- carlmr 8y agoAlso musicians will often deride something that's new. Just look at transistor amplifiers. They're technically better, but won't excite most guitarists. A lot of the "better" for musicians is imperfection.
- sonnyblarney 8y ago"Just look at transistor amplifiers" If you mean solid state transistors, yes musicians don't like them, but there is good reason - tube amps absolutely sound better than solid state, there's really no debate there. But they are a huge pain in the rear and if solid state sounded identical, musicians would have no problem. Also, they're not that new :). But yes, a lot of musicians don't like new, which is funny :)
- ssharp 8y ago> But yes, a lot of musicians don't like new, which is funny :) A lot of musicians are also highly technical artists who need and expect things to work a certain way and have practiced hours and hours within that certain way. And that's taken to the hundredth degree when you're talking about a working musician who performs for a living. Just think of Spinal Tap and the wireless guitar system as an example of the exact type of situation a musician doesn't want. A recent example are the automated tuners Gibson started putting on some of their guitars. That sounds amazing in practice -- I can hit my strings and bend them as hard as I want to and they'll just magically get back in tune! The reality (I didn't personally own one, so I can't share my experiences), was much worse, with many accounts of musicians playing on stage, only to have their Gibson manage to automatically detune itself. In regards to amps, guitarists are also notably attached to whatever tone they spent years dialing in. There is a tremendous difference in sound between any two amp models, especially with tube amps.
- 8y ago
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- garagemc2 8y agoThe biggest threat to Zildjian is a shift to electric drums and thus electric cymbals.
- nerdponx 8y agoThat's a long way off. Electric drums or nothing new, and until you can accurately replicate the sound of live drums with electric drums, good luc that's a long way off. Electric drums or nothing new, and until you can accurately replicate the sound of live drums in a concert venue with electric drums, there's no risk.
- jdbernard 8y agoNot just the sound, but the expressiveness. Electric kits do not create noise directly from the performance of the drummer. There is a layer of interpretation and mapping to sound. So they can only reproduce sounds pre-programmed into them according to variation that their senors are designed to respond to. Acoustic kits are making noise because of the physical properties of the kit itself. So you will always be able to find sounds on an acoustic kit you cannot reproduce on an electric kit. And the range of expression present on an acoustic kit will always be infinitely greater than an electric kit. Full disclosure: I own an electric kit.
- ssharp 8y agoZildjian also makes electronic cymbals, so they are staying with these industry trends.
- davexunit 8y agoElectric drums are cool in their own way but... they will never replace the acoustic drum kit. They are two very different instruments.