5 ms·
I would think that the more straightforward paraphrase is even better: "The greatest trick the Super-Elite ever pulled was convincing the world that they didn'
by nostrademons 8y ago
I would think that the more straightforward paraphrase is even better:
"The greatest trick the Super-Elite ever pulled was convincing the world that they didn't exist."
I doubt you'd find many people who actually agree that inequality is a desired outcome of a properly functioning economy (even if it's true). However, the Super-Elite have been remarkably successful at disappearing into the background and making the world forget about them. Look at the headlines today: they're about ICE & undocumented immigrants, or Nazis in Charlottesville, or Russian interference, or antifa protesters. You see very few news stories about private jet vacations or the real-estate holdings of the super-wealthy.
- swframe2 8y agoI agree. The super wealthy prefer seclusion but it is hard to hide a 10 bedroom mansion and a superyacht. It is better to provide a strong "foxnews education" so there is no need to hide. Honestly, I wonder if a symbolic model would work better for our society. Ask the rich to set aside 20% of their wealth to provide low interest rate (~1% to 2%) loans to the poor to be used specifically on self-improvement (housing, infrastructure, education, policing, healthcare, childcare, etc). The loans start small and increase with good payment history.
- prolikewh0a 8y ago>Ask the rich to set aside 20% of their wealth to provide low interest rate (~1% to 2%) loans to the poor to be used specifically on self-improvement (housing, infrastructure, education, policing, healthcare, childcare, etc). The loans start small and increase with good payment history. What you're suggesting would create more wealth for the elite. It's a loan, so they retain the same amount of money (since it's a loan, the assumption is that it's paid back), while gaining more money in interest. I am lower end of the spectrum when it comes to my wealth, and I probably can't even claim any sort of middle class "label" in the USA. I avoid debt (because I can't afford to pay it back) and wouldn't even consider something like this.
- hakfoo 8y agoIf the interest rate in the loan was pegged to track inflation, it should be roughly zero-practical-gain. But it's still clunky. There's no reason we can't say "people earning more than a few million dollars a year can afford to pay a 97% tax rate." We just need to have it wired together into a comprehensive plan. Hold passports if you have outstanding tax debt. Orchestrate "regime change" in Carribean tax shelters and Luxembourg instead of the Middle East for a change.
- RhysU 8y ago> There's no reason we can't say "people earning more than a few million dollars a year can afford to pay a 97% tax rate." Sure there is. They won't bother creating any value if their marginal take is effectively zero. How hard would you work if someone said you couldn't take home more than $10K?
- prolikewh0a 8y agoIdeally there would be tax brackets so people making $150,000/year aren't taking home poverty wages, but people making $1,000,000,000/year are taking home maybe a couple tens of millions, which is still perfectly comfortable to live on for an entire lifetime.
- darawk 8y agoI think you're missing his point. Say your hypothetical person is making $10,000,000/year already. He has the opportunity to work 40% harder to 10x his income up to $100M/year. However, at this point, his marginal tax rate under your scheme is already 97%, which means that on that extra $90M in theoretical income, he will only take home an extra $2.7M. Now, it's not worth it for him to make that extra effort, to only increase his realized income by 27%. The next question is: Why should you, someone presumably not making $10m/year, care? We care because when someone increases their earnings from $10M to $100M, in theory, they are doing so by creating value for society. In fact the people at the highest ends of the income distribution should be the ones creating the most value. So we really do want them to be incentivized to earn more. To ensure that they are, we need a top marginal rate that strikes a balance between unnecessary super wealth, and incentivizing the value creation that drives the tremendous prosperity of the modern economy. This is a delicate balancing act, to be sure. But it is extremely important to understand that it is a balancing act.
- xg15 8y ago> Ask the rich to set aside 20% of their wealth to provide low interest rate (~1% to 2%) loans... Instead of or in addition to taxes?
- edanm 8y ago> I doubt you'd find many people who actually agree that inequality is a desired outcome of a properly functioning economy (even if it's true). I don't agree (with your statement). I mean, I don't think most people actively begrudge people having a better situation than them - just like they don't sit around getting angry that Rachmaninoff is a better composer than them, or that Michael Jordan is a better basketball player. I think people do sometimes instinctively feel that one person having more wealth is somehow depriving them - but that's not universal, and only comes up in certain situations. > "The greatest trick the Super-Elite ever pulled was convincing the world that they didn't exist." > You see very few news stories about private jet vacations or the real-estate holdings of the super-wealthy. Like, I don't think you're actually claiming that there's any conspiracy here of the super-elite, despite the wording. But I don't get your point. You think it takes active work to make it so that there are no news stories about the super elite? I mean, I don't expect the newspapers in poorer countries to be filled with stories about how much better everyone in America has it. I don't think it's because Americans did anything special - it just doesn't really interest people. And again, I don't think everyone in Africa feels that the fact that most Americans are better off than them is necessarily so terrible. I think this sentiment tends to come up in certain situations (especially when explicitly talking about economic inequality), but not in general.