9 ms·
There is no point of having a private blockchain or distributed ledger. Full stop. Nothing there was no possible before Bitcoin and what they are trying to ach
by wslh 8y ago
There is no point of having a private blockchain or distributed ledger. Full stop.
Nothing there was no possible before Bitcoin and what they are trying to achieve is some kind of API 2.0 where different companies can integrate within the same technology. This problem is political rather than technical and the blockchain is not a solution by itself.
- drcode 8y agoI wouldn't go quite that far, I think in terms of simplifying your architecture and for providing sandboxing of third party code in a mission critical system there could be some modest benefits in a private blockchain. However, these are not the reasons why people are usually interested in private blockchains, which as you say revolve mainly around political problems where blockchains can't help much.
- codebje 8y agoI'd be horrified to discover an architecture that could be simplified by adding a blockchain to it.
- tuesdayrain 8y agoI think some day this comment will be equivalent to "I'd be horrified to discover an architecture that could br simplified by adding a linked list to it".
- drcode 8y agoI agree that for MOST use cases adding blockchain tech just makes things more complicated
- luckycharms810 8y agoThis seems to be a popular opinion amongst a lot of ethereum developers I have met. I definitely don’t have as much experience in the field so honest question here. If a permissioned blockchain has nodes running across multiple organizations and third party auditing institutions, can that not solve real world problems?
- wslh 8y agoGood question. There are more than one argument but I will use the security one: in a public blockchain, the blockchain is the truth and if a transaction happens it is immutable under certain assumptions. The connection between a public blockchain and the real world is through oracles which are the weakest chain since no matter the blockchain security it could trigger transactions beyond it. Now, what happens in a private blockchain? In this context there are a lot of outside the blockhain organizational systems that if they are being attacked all the blockchain security does not matter.