5 ms·
The Secular C.S. Lewis: Neil Postman’s Unlikely Influence on Evangelicals (2013)
- gnarbarian 8y agohere's my favorite quote from C.S. Lewis: >“Of all tyrannies, a tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victims may be the most oppressive. It would be better to live under robber barons than under omnipotent moral busybodies. The robber baron's cruelty may sometimes sleep, his cupidity may at some point be satiated; but those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they do so with the approval of their own conscience. They may be more likely to go to Heaven yet at the same time likelier to make a Hell of earth. This very kindness stings with intolerable insult. To be "cured" against one's will and cured of states which we may not regard as disease is to be put on a level of those who have not yet reached the age of reason or those who never will; to be classed with infants, imbeciles, and domestic animals.” - C.S. Lewis edit: pedantry
- acqq 8y ago"from him"? The article is not about C.S. Lewis, only about Neil Postman.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- remarkEon 8y agoLink to this?
- gnarbarian 8y agohttps://www.goodreads.com/quotes/526469-of-all-tyrannies-a-tyranny-sincerely-exercised-for-the-good https://www.goodreads.com/quotes/526469-of-all-tyrannies-a-t...
- dbatten 8y agoThe particular essay in question is "On the Humanitarian Theory of Punishment." Here's a PDF: https://biblicalstudies.org.uk/pdf/churchman/073-02_055.pdf https://biblicalstudies.org.uk/pdf/churchman/073-02_055.pdf
- Terr_ 8y agoReminds me of a later author: > She knew what she feared—to be locked up in some dark, narrow place by people who loved her. An enemy might drop his guard, weary of his task, turn his back; love would never falter. -- Paladin of Souls, by Lois McMaster Bujold
- dbatten 8y agoI suspect most readers on HN will see this as a warning against religious tyranny when it's actually a warning against attempting to rehabilitate criminals rather than simply punishing them justly for their crime... Interestingly, the former is likely a rather popular notion here, while I imagine the latter viewpoint is fairly unpopular. Here's the full essay: https://biblicalstudies.org.uk/pdf/churchman/073-02_055.pdf https://biblicalstudies.org.uk/pdf/churchman/073-02_055.pdf
- n4r9 8y agoInteresting essay. More generally it seems to be a reaction against a perceived authoritarian-Leftist tendency to view people as programmable cogs in the machine of society. Cogs that can be reprogrammed to make everything run more smoothly. In some sense it strikes at the core distinction between deontological and utilitarian ethics (as I understand those terms). I wonder what he would think of the "Bastoy" prison island in Norway: https://www.theguardian.com/society/2013/feb/25/norwegian-prison-inmates-treated-like-people https://www.theguardian.com/society/2013/feb/25/norwegian-pr...
- baldfat 8y agoRehashed Article from the same author was posted a few years later in 2015, https://secondnaturejournal.com/neil-postman-judeo-christian-worldview/ https://secondnaturejournal.com/neil-postman-judeo-christian.... In my former life I was a graduate student in Historical Theology so this was my silo of "expertise" AKA I can be a critics easier then most. Only one HUGE logical problem. C.S. Lewis wasn't a Evangelical Christian he was Anglican. Evangelicals at the time hated them with equal venom to Roman Catholics C.S. Lewis converted to Christianity by JR Tolkien (Yes the one who wrote Lord of the Rings) who was Roman Catholic. SOOOOO What is written about Postman's lectures are also true of Lewis. They both came from outside of Evangelicaldom and were respected for their thoughts. Also they stated that George Whitefield (1714-1770) was Anglican BUT he co-founded the Methodist Church with John and Charles Wesley which was the founding of Evangelical Christianity of today. They were the Martin Luther of the Anglican Church. Also Postman was not an evangelical, but a Jewish humanist. For some unknown reason Modern Atheist have hijacked the term Humanist which was actually found by the Reformation Founders. I have read Postman and his book "Amusing Ourselves to Death" especially Chapter 8 "Shuffle Off to Bethlehem" show that Postman had some positive views of religion and was at best a Agnostic with positive feelings towards religion. I believe Postman would also share in my declaration Humanism historically and fundamentally doesn't mean Atheist. Atheist is a good term why leave it to take over another term and all its historical foundations? Humanism was founded by Christians and not some academia but the leaders of the Reformation Movement of Calvin and Luther.
- pvg 8y agoOnly one HUGE logical problem. C.S. Lewis wasn't a Evangelical Christian he was Anglican What's the logical problem here? The article doesn't claim C.S. Lewis was an Evangelical (it's not about C.S. Lewis at all) nor does it claim Postman was one.
- coldtea 8y agoIt's not about what it claims, but about what it implies. That Postman was an "unlikely influence", being secular, whereas C.S Lewis is mentioned as an obvious (since Christian) influence. But, as the parent observes, C.S Lewis was also an unlikely influence to evangelicals, being an anglican.
- nwatson 8y agoFTA : Confessionalists would sympathize with these ideals since many of them believe American democracy grew out of the Reformation as much as it did the Enlightenment. American democracy grew more so out of the pragmatic commercialist negotiation of the extent of colonist autonomy in the colonial charters (see [1] though there are better supporting docs 4 sure out the). Colonists got a measure of freedom not possible in England/Europe and wanted the whole pie eventually. "Revivalism" and "materialism" were both second fiddle to "I make my living how I damn well please". [1] http://www.ushistory.org/gov/2a.asp http://www.ushistory.org/gov/2a.asp
- coldtea 8y ago>"Revivalism" and "materialism" were both second fiddle to "I make my living how I damn well please". Were they though? Because people elsewhere could have said that as well, but didn't (and in some places, did), regardless of being in similar circumstances.
- simonh 8y agoDid those other people elsewhere already have their own elected legislature and a largely autonomous commercial environment? You're not addressing the argument, only scoring points on a specific statement out of context.
- coldtea 8y ago>Did those other people elsewhere already have their own elected legislature and a largely autonomous commercial environment? Those are manifestations of "I make my living how I damn well please", so can't be its cause. In other words, the argument takes for granted what it should prove -- that "Revivalism" and "materialism" were both second fiddle".
- DanielBMarkham 8y agoYes and no. It's not that you're wrong, it's just incomplete. I completely agree that eventually they wanted the entire pie, but that happened in a context based on European history for those people in-country. We can look at other areas, like Central and South America, and find that it didn't work out so well. Religious freedom was a huge motivating factor for the initial wave of migration, and part of that freedom involved a heritage of things like the 30 Year's War. This was the basis and background of what played out later, even if what played out later was more commercial and deist in nature. I think it's a mistake to look at the American Revolution in terms of what happened in 2-4 decades around 1776. There was a lot more going on. ADD: You don't get the wording and reasoning of the DOI and the fact that multiple states had state religions at the founding of the country from purely commercial interests.