3 ms·
The headline is, as popular articles on QM often are, misleading. One of the central mysteries of QM has always been: how does the classical world with its arr
by lisper 8y ago
The headline is, as popular articles on QM often are, misleading. One of the central mysteries of QM has always been: how does the classical world with its arrow of time emerge from the quantum world where the governing equation is time-symmetric? And the answer is: the classical world emerges by a process of decoherence, which is to say, by the creation of large (O(10^23)) networks of entanglements which (it can be shown mathematically) have behavior that is indistinguishable from classical systems. It is very similar to how thermodynamics and the time-irreversibility of the second law emerge from time-reversible Newtonian mechanics (except that the time-asymmetry that emerges from QM is even more fundamental).
Time-reversibility is part-and-parcel of quantum computation because the whole point of quantum computation is to keep the system operating in the regime where its behavior is distinguishable from classical. As soon as you lose coherence, you simultaneously lose all of the quantum behavior, including time-reversibility. Time-reversibility isn't anything special in this regard. It's all part of the same weirdness.
It's all very interesting, but none of it is news.
- shry4ns 8y agoWell put. QM allowing retrocausality has been long known.
- lisper 8y agoThanks. But I would actually not say that QM "allows retrocausality." Instead I would say that the whole concept of "causality" simply meaningless in a time-symmetric system, just as the concept of (say) "up" is meaningless in a spatially symmetric system.
- jchook 8y agoIt’s so funny that quantum physicists chose the term “retrocausality” because the literal meaning of its parts (“ex post facto”) can only be understood in the context of the “arrow of time”. Perhaps wordsmithing that alludes to a superordinate context (beyond time) would be more appropriate..
- posix_me_less 8y ago> And the answer is: the classical world emerges by a process of decoherence, which is to say, by the creation of large (O(10^23)) networks of entanglements which (it can be shown mathematically) have behavior that is indistinguishable from classical systems. This is the motivation for decoherence and for the Everettian view where the psi function is "the only real thing" and everything else is derived. It is often talked about as if actually accomplished. But it was not; the behaviour of quantum systems, even with decoherence, was not yet shown to be indistinguishable from the classical systems. Neither the fact that measurements have one outcome, nor Born's rules for probability were derived from this decoherence idea yet. One thing that follows from decoherence hypothesis is decay of coherence elements in density matrices, but this is not enough to get explanation for single outcomes or for Born's rules.
- lisper 8y agoIronically, I am just in the process of preparing a talk on the history of the atomic theory. Even as late as 1905 when Einstein published his work on brownian motion it was still highly controversial whether atoms were "really real" or just a mathematical contrivance. Some people are able to maintain skepticism even in the face of overwhelming evidence. > Neither the fact that measurements have one outcome, nor Born's rules for probability were derived from this decoherence idea yet. That is because it is not the case that measurements have one outcome. Measurements appear to have one outcome from the perspective of a given classical observer, and the outcome observed by any given observer will be classically consistent with all the other observations that observer makes [1]. The Born rule (which, it must be stressed, is not fundamental, but only apparent from the point of view of any given observer) follows from that, not mathematically but logically [2]. [1] https://arxiv.org/pdf/quant-ph/9605002.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/quant-ph/9605002.pdf [2] https://www.scottaaronson.com/papers/island.pdf https://www.scottaaronson.com/papers/island.pdf
- posix_me_less 8y agoThanks for the links. > "That is because it is not the case that measurements have one outcome. Measurements appear to have one outcome from the perspective of a given classical observer [but actually have none]" is a big claim, but it lacks "overwhelming evidence". Quantum theory self-consistency is a problem worthy of investigation, but achieving self-consistency is only one of the many possible valid results. This result is not needed as much as many people seem to think; certainly not as much as to reify psi function above objective results of measurements and claim the quoted part. It is a methodological error; instead of shaping the theory around the measurement results, it is rejecting the fact that those measurement results exist. > The Born rule (which, it must be stressed, is not fundamental, but only apparent from the point of view of any given observer) follows from that, not mathematically but logically I skimmed the paper [2] but found no such thing there. Could you locate it in more precisely or elaborate on the idea? All these kinds of proofs from algebraic formalism seem to achieve is something like "if Born's rule would not be true, we would have problems with the theory" which is not very interesting; we have some big problems with the theory even without decoherence.