4 ms·
> Wow, what a money line. It's like a Rosetta Stone for a whole family of naive political ideas. I would rather say that it is extremely naive to believe that
by ekianjo 8y ago
> Wow, what a money line. It's like a Rosetta Stone for a whole family of naive political ideas.
I would rather say that it is extremely naive to believe that the systems we have inherited are optimal in any way.
- dcposch 8y agoNobody's saying the systems we've inherited are optimal. What we (all four--me, the comment I'm replying to, the Tyranny of Structureless essay, and the article about Valve) -- what we're saying is that "no system" is not an improvement.
- humanrebar 8y agoSystems, institutions, and cultures evolve to fit their environments better than alternatives. That's not to say any are perfect or fully optimized. There is room for innovation. As problems are solved, remining problems start getting more attention. And environments change over time. But established approaches are more optimal in at least some respects than failed experiments of the past.
- fsloth 8y agoI think it goes both ways. You cannot develop new systems by designing them around fantasy psychology that you implicitly presume will take over everyone in the new scheme. New schemes are certainly a good idea if they actually improve on the current models and are based on reality and not fantasy or malfeasant popularism.
- wpietri 8y agoThat's a false dichotomy. There's enough naivety out there to fuel both pro- and anti-status-quo positions.