3 ms·
Gargac’s videos fit into the newer “IRL,” or “In Real Life,” section that encourages users to stream their life outside of games. Gargac says he’s earned about
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
Gargac’s videos fit into the newer “IRL,” or “In Real Life,” section that encourages users to stream their life outside of games.
Gargac says he’s earned about $3,500 off Twitch users so far, including subscriptions, donations and tips called “bits.” That’s on top of about $150 to $300 he earns from fares on an average night. He typically drives on weekend nights because, he says, the bar crowd makes for the most entertaining rides.
So, the Gig Economy, where so many workers are underpaid and have no benefits, etc, mated with the Internet version of Reality TV and this is their bastard child.
I find it disturbing, but I think the conversation here should really be about "What can the average person realistically do who doesn't want to be a wage slave anymore?" I mean, if we want people to not whore out their passengers' lives in a grotesque modern version of Candid Camera for cash, maybe we should, like, create jobs with adequate pay and benefits.
Bizarre concept, I know, that treating all your citizens like they deserve a living wage, medical care and basic, decent housing might promote ethical behavior. But I'm putting it out there anyway.
- writepub 8y agoNo. You cannot rationalize someone's malicious intent to exploit and profit off of trust people place in you by getting into your cab on the gig economy, or anything else. That's a slippery slope where bad actors place blame on non causal issues for their actions
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI am neither rationalizing it, nor justifying it. However, having spent several years homeless and found that classism, sexism and other societal crap were huge barriers to me getting my life back, I think it is unrealistic and cruel to not criticize the sick system that helps foster such bad choices. If you make it hard enough to make good choices that you approve of, don't be shocked when some people's moral fiber fails the test and they get on with meeting survival needs instead of ethically and high-mindedly starving.
- jeffdavis 8y agoI don't see how any of what you said applies to the current story. We don't know whether the driver has financial problems or not. On the surface, it seems likely that the driver is simply an unethical person who is abusing his customers' trust for money and/or fame.
- michelledepeil 8y agoI feel some very valid assumptions about an uber driver were made in the initial comment, that might explain this behaviour. These comments were made with regards to his income situation. I agree with you though that it might not be for making money, but just because the driver is a morally bad individual. A much more likely scenario than him being a bad actor is that he might've thought he had found a hole in the market that would bring him 15 minutes of fame, and that's where his rational and moral thoughts went out the window.
- DoreenMichele 8y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17583690 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17583690 My dad was a veteran with shrapnel in one eye that made him unable to purchase additional life insurance and it caused blind spells that left him intermittently unemployed for months at a time. I've had a class on Homelessness and Public Policy. I know something about both veterans and homelessness. (For those not bothering to click on the link above, veterans are over-represented amongst the homeless.) Veterans tend to be proud people. They may not tell you how maimed their military career left them and it may not be obvious why they can't get a better job. I also don't see where the article made any effort whatsoever to understand why he has chosen to do such a thing. So perhaps you don't see how my remark applies to the current story because the current story would like to vilify him while glossing over the context in which this is occurring.
- DanBC 8y ago> it seems likely that the driver is simply an unethical person See also the Conjunction fallacy / Linda Problem: https://www.psychologytoday.com/gb/blog/the-superhuman-mind/201611/linda-the-bank-teller-case-revisited https://www.psychologytoday.com/gb/blog/the-superhuman-mind/...
- PhasmaFelis 8y agoIt doesn't have to be either/or between "malicious and greedy" and "poor person desperate to make ends meet." The truth often lies somewhere in between.
- finnthehuman 8y ago>You cannot rationalize someone's malicious intent to exploit and profit off of trust people place in you What? That's Hacker News' favorite thing to do. >by getting into your cab on the gig economy OH. Right. Yeah. They're doing it face to face, not from behind apps and contracts of adhesion. Very different. Carry on.
- dominotw 8y agoI am not sure if providing benefits would offset the temptation to earn 3.5k extra income. Case in point, This guy is an army vet so presumably he already has health benefits. > treating all your citizens non citizen population need benefits too.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoGargac began driving for Uber, and occasionally Lyft, in early March. He was livestreaming all of his rides by the end of that month. That $3.5k in extra income is over the course of about 3.5 months or so. Call it an extra $1000/month. A quick google tells me that health insurance costs average around $321 or $558 per month for an individual and $833 per month for a family, plus there is a multi-thousand dollar annual deductible. [2] Sounds to me like, yes, universal basic health coverage absolutely could help someone resist the temptation for that amount of money. Edit: I will note the article indicates he is 32, so while he's a veteran, he's not a military retiree. He likely doesn't have military medical benefits. non citizen population need benefits too. I don't disagree with you.[2] I'm just shooting for the low hanging fruit first that hopefully more people will readily agree on. [1] https://gusto.com/framework/health-benefits/how-much-is-health-insurance/ https://gusto.com/framework/health-benefits/how-much-is-heal... [2] https://twitter.com/doreen_michele/status/1020750937931911168 https://twitter.com/doreen_michele/status/102075093793191116...
- setr 8y ago>Sounds to me like, yes, universal basic health coverage absolutely could help someone resist the temptation for that amount of money. ...if you give someone any amount of money, it will help resist the temptation for more money, unless they're already not interested in money in the first place. So, yes, universal health care would do the trick, as would a flat reimbursement, or lower prices on goods/services (effectively more money), as would any other manner of lessening the amount of money they need.
- dominotw 8y ago> Sounds to me like, yes, universal basic health coverage absolutely could help someone resist the temptation for that amount of money. Your thesis basically is that this could never happen in Canada or happens less frequently in canada. It could be true. But there seem to be lots of these in canada too https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ottawa/uber-scam-driver-police-1.4458321 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/ottawa/uber-scam-driver-polic...