4 ms·
If you want to make them obsolete you need a rival technology that possesses all of the attributes that make people choose cars over mass transit, notably conve
by nostrademons 8y ago
If you want to make them obsolete you need a rival technology that possesses all of the attributes that make people choose cars over mass transit, notably convenience, scheduling & destination flexibility, privacy, and cargo capacity.
Failing that, self-driving cars as a service preserve all of these while also being significantly better for the environment. You don't need parking lots, because utilization is close to 100% and they go back to a depot when not required. It's easier to electrify the fleet, because the service knows exactly how far the trip will be and can bring the car back to a charging station while it has no passenger. You can share rides when multiple passengers have destinations that are close without them needing to go to the exact same place. You can have pods that dock with each other in motion (benefitting from better aerodynamics) but preserve privacy and split off to different destinations when needed.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> If you want to make them obsolete you need a rival technology that possesses all of the attributes that make people choose cars over mass transit, notably convenience, scheduling & destination flexibility, privacy, and cargo capacity. Actually, since the goal should be the preservation of the environment that is supporting our continued existence, what is needed is mass transit, which is the least damaging form of (mechanised) transport we know of; not a technology to replace it with privately-owned and operated vehicles. I mean, I understand that's never going to happen, but that's only because we are collectively incapable of making the right decision on this one.
- bumholio 8y ago> what is needed is mass transit, Why mass transit and not walking more or personal blimps shaped like giant Trump babies? To make them more than your opinion, you need to put some numbers on those statements. And the numbers work much worse than you think: between the low energy efficiency and low occupancy at non-rush hours, the massive infrastructure and the longer routes due to non-optimal layout, mass transit is better than American gas guzzlers but nothing to write home about. Here's some numbers put up by people who share your opinion - and that do not even take all these effects into account: https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2012/11/can-we-please-stop-pretending-cars-are-greener-transit/3960/ https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2012/11/can-we-please... So for in-city transport, mass transit is a hard sell on environment alone. (Intercity transport like trains are great though, and there is a strong convergence there, self driving cars pair well with fast trains, giving the best of both worlds: flexibility, speed and low footprint)
- nostrademons 8y agoExactly. It'll never happen, so why waste time and energy on a fantasy when there's a solution in front of you that isn't perfect but has a good chance of working and making things better?
- njarboe 8y agoWe could just ban all transportation with the exception of walking/running. Important people could get special passes from the government to use other transportation forms. If only 1% of people were allowed to move around with aided devices that would surely get us to the goal of preserving the environment much faster that just banning the car.
- bumholio 8y agoI think that driving pass would be so valuable that it could corrupt any and all social institutions. The people handing them out would be demigods, imune from all forms of authority in this world other than the Holly Eternal DMV itself. A more workable system for a free market society would be to shell out an equal endowment, say 20 driving hours a month, to all citizens. They will then chose if to sell them to the rich people or spend them to impress that special date. Before you know it, the poorer plebs will fight the richer ones to maintain the driving voucher system, for the sake of the revenue they earn out of it.
- airstrike 8y agoI think this guy was being sarcastic to prove a point
- rory096 8y ago>If only 1% of people were allowed to move around with aided devices A lot more than 1% of people would be unable to function in modern society if you took their car and told them to walk and run.
- scarmig 8y agoTechnologies like Waymo's make mass transit more practical, not less. Imagine a city-managed fleet of buses and shuttles that have a significantly decreased cost-to-operate, that dynamically respond to demand, aren't bound by work rules, and that customize their routes as needed. That's revolutionary.
- jogjayr 8y agoSelf-driving vehicles make mass transit more usable and economical, if you expand the definition of mass transit. Implement congestion taxes and dedicated lanes for high-occupancy vehicles (vehicle more than 50% occupied) and you have a fleet of highly adaptable, efficient, utilized, and available buses at a fraction of the current cost. You've eliminated some of the major problems of mass transit systems - last mile connectivity, financially marginal routes having to choose between poor service or losing money, lack of frequency at off-peak hours, relative lack of comfort, convenience, needing to know a timetable as a user.
- Alex3917 8y ago> while also being significantly better for the environment That's probably true on a per mile basis, but it's actually expected to be net worse for the environment because it will enable car access for a large percentage of the population who are currently homebound due to either being disabled or not being able to afford a car. That said, because they don't need street parking, in the long run it may enable more bike lanes and bike usage.
- ghaff 8y ago>it will enable car access for a large percentage of the population who are currently homebound due to either being disabled or not being able to afford a car. That sounds like a really horrible outcome. /s
- rrdharan 8y agoPersonally I think achieving utilization anywhere close to that level is a pipe dream. I just don't see any world in which the only reasonably efficient form of self-driving vehicles is basically a fleet of (dynamically scheduled, self-routing, autonomous) bus rapid transit - and I'm assuming these would only beat out trains in a realistic dynamic system mainly because of the additional flexibility/ease of re-routing.
- lostlogin 8y ago> You don't need parking lots, because utilization is close to 100% and they go back to a depot when not required. It’s just dawned on me how many cars you could fit in a carpark for self driving cars. They can park properly, park each other in and park close together. I wouldn’t be surprised if you could get 4x more cars in the same place.
- ghaff 8y agoNothing like 4x but there are robotic parking systems (and other types of stacking systems) in places like Manhattan where the additional expense and inconvenience make sense because of land costs. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automated_parking_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Automated_parking_system