3 ms·
Not saying you’re wrong but do you have any evidence to say it’s “Generally found to be untrue”.
by bamboozled 8y ago
Not saying you’re wrong but do you have any evidence to say it’s “Generally found to be untrue”.
- notacoward 8y agoThe question is more whether the "barefoot is best" meme was ever more than theory/anecdote. https://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/06/05/is-barefoot-style-running-best-new-studies-cast-doubt/ https://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/06/05/is-barefoot-style-... As others have said, people are different. There might well be a subset of runners for whom a barefoot/minimal style is best, but AFAICT it's a minority at best, so "generally found to be untrue" is a pretty good summary.
- bamboozled 8y agoTo be honest that article just says that both techniques are similar in efficiency, which I think no one really disputed. There is also a claim which I’m not so familiar with which is that bare foot runners think their feet will become more “taught and spring like”, ,not really familiar with that idea. What I’m interested in, and the article doesn’t discuss is the injury rate between runners who run barefoot and without shoes. I haven’t any studies which say I’m more likely to be injured when going barefoot. I think the real reason more people wear shoes is that there is seems to be something taboo about going shoeless. As a bare foot runner I feel judged for taking off the shoes and going for a run. Edit: To the point about people who tried barefoot shoes and were injured, that’s probably because just running without shoes on with the same technique for 10 weeks isn’t an advisable way to run without shoes. It’s quite a different exercise.
- notacoward 8y ago> I haven’t any studies which say I’m more likely to be injured when going barefoot. Can you cite any studies at all on the subject, even showing the converse? It's not clear why the entire burden of proof should be on one side. > As a bare foot runner I feel judged for taking off the shoes and going for a run. I've only been running a bit over four years, and I've seen plenty of judging from both sides. Personally, I have something that works for me, even through New England winters when barefoot simply isn't an option. If somebody half my age and half my annual mileage wants to look down their nose at me because I wear pretty standard shoes, all I can do is laugh.
- 21 8y agoFor once, even if it's allowed no top athlete runs barefoot/minimal. And it's not because of ad dollars - you don't see them wearing hats or gloves just because some company would pay for that.
- eitally 8y agoI can't remember the source (or I'd paste a link here), but the current thinking is that, overall, the best way to choose shoes (for safety & performance) is to pick a pair that's comfortable. That might range from Tarahumara style sandals to Uber-cushioned Hokas to a super-stiff stability shoe. The important thing is to test a bunch and pick what works for you, and not to isolate in a specific sub-category (minimal, zero drop, cushioned, stability, neutral).