5 ms·
I think the following quote is the QED for academia ruining any chance at actual research: “What I had was an out-of-control intuition that these algebras were
by ianai 8y ago
I think the following quote is the QED for academia ruining any chance at actual research:
“What I had was an out-of-control intuition that these algebras were key to understanding particle physics, and I was willing to follow this intuition off a cliff if need be. Some might say I did.”
- _bxg1 8y agoIt's my understanding that most of Einstein's theory was the product of intuition, backed up after-the-fact with mathematics and experimentation. Intuition isn't a bad compass, as long as you can set it aside if reality measurably contradicts it. In fairness, Einstein never accepted quantum mechanics because they flew in the face of his intuition, but it still got him pretty far.
- madhadron 8y agoThis is very false. Einstein's reputation was built on explaining known phenomena such as the photoelectric effect and Brownian motion. Special relativity was heavily motivated by a pile of puzzling evidence and a bunch of existing mathematics.
- ianai 8y agoAnd he funded his studies, initially, as a hobby alongside a job. We’ve not progressed very far if ground breaking research almost requires a person to find a novel study path.
- btrettel 8y agoWhat do you mean by "novel study path" here? Funding yourself with money received from a job? On my first reading I took "novel study path" to mean new research techniques or something along those lines, which seems obvious and is not likely what you meant.
- ianai 8y agoEither applies really.
- raverbashing 8y agoIt's not false, w.r.t. general relativity And you still need a good amount of creativity to come up with special relativity and to a certain extent, with the photoelectric effect (though we could say that was the 'easy' one) But yes, the puzzling results and existing mathematics were part of it. But there is a reason we hear much more about Einstein than Lorenz or Michelson-Moreley
- iainmerrick 8y agoSpecial relativity was heavily motivated by a pile of puzzling evidence If you mean the Michelson–Morley experiment (apparent zero velocity of earth with respect to the ether), apparently Einstein himself claimed that wasn’t a motivation. I believe it was all about resolving the long-standing "action at a distance" question raised by Newtonian physics (Newton himself noted that this was philosophically disturbing but didn’t venture an answer). Intuition and philosophy, rather than experimental evidence and mathematics.
- dboreham 8y agoAt the beginning of his paper he cites the relativistic nature of Maxwell's equations, and "unsuccessful attempts to discover any motion of the earth relatively to the 'light medium' ". https://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/einstein/specrel/www/ https://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/einstein/specrel/www/
- nessus42 8y ago> This is very false. But didn't Einstein write the following in his own book? “I believe in intuition and inspiration. … At times I feel certain I am right while not knowing the reason. When the eclipse of 1919 confirmed my intuition, I was not in the least surprised. In fact I would have been astonished that it turned out otherwise. Imagination is more important than knowledge. For knowledge is limited, whereas imagination embraces the entire world, stimulating progress, giving birth to evolution. It is, strictly speaking, a real factor in scientific research.”
- arketyp 8y agoGödel was motivated by convictions about meta-mathematics, motivated by his Catholic fatih. Perhaps a purely mechanistic world view would have eventually generated the same result, e.g. Turing's halting problem, but who knows.
- gjm11 8y agoGödel's background was Lutheran, not Catholic, and I don't think he was particularly orthodox. (I have no idea how his religious convictions influenced his metamathematical ones; you might well be right about that.)
- arketyp 8y agoThanks for the correction. I'm sure I've heard biographers (Jessica Goldestein perhaps?) describe his faith as having had a strong influence, but I must have misconstrued it quite a bit as memory faded. You're right, he was raised Lutheran. But his father was Catholic.
- Cobord 8y agoGödel spacetimes to fuck with your intuitions.
- gowld 8y agoThought experiments, not intuition. Thought experiments are kind of theoretical physics: Making an assumption ("c is the universal speed limit"), and thinking about the implications ("addition of velocity cannot be linear"), even though available experimental tools are not powerful enough to demonstrate the implications in a way observable to the though-experimenter.
- nessus42 8y ago> Einstein never accepted quantum mechanics Wait? Since when did Einstein not accept Quantum Mechanics? He won the Nobel Prize for his work in discovering an important part of Quantum Mechanics. Einstein rejected the Copenhagen Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics. That's not the same thing as rejecting Quantum Mechanics. I've seen no claims that he would object to either the Everett or Bohm Interpretations of QM. (But then again, he died before they were invented.) Einstein, by the way, is far from the only critic of the Copenhagen Interpretation. Quite a few physicists are drawn to the Everett Interpretation instead, for instance.
- kgilpin 8y agoWell, he never accepted non-locality. And it turns out, quantum mechanics is indeed non-local.
- nessus42 8y agoIn the Everett interpretation, everything is local.
- codethief 8y agoThis is a common misconception. (The Copenhagen interpretation of) QM is a local theory, in the sense that there's no faster-than-light travel of information. Otherwise you'd have to take into account what's happening at the other end of the universe in order to successfully predict the outcome of experiments. (Which I hear is what the people working on Bohmian mechanics struggle with.)
- nessus42 8y agoIt's been a while since I studied this, and I know that some Copenhagenist try to wiggle their way out of this, but if you consider the probability waves in the Copenhagen interpretation to be "real" and "measurement" to cause their collapse, book-keeping information by the universe would seem to have to travel at faster than the speed of light, IIRC. On the other hand, it's certainly been proven that this cannot be used to transmit information that you might like to at faster than the speed of light. So causality is preserved in any case.
- btrettel 8y agoAs a current PhD student, I'd say the vast majority of researchers aren't anywhere near that enthusiastic about their research.
- ianai 8y agoMany marriages fail in the time it takes to complete a phd. If academia can’t find a way to fund people with actual interest then somethings wrong.
- mikec3010 8y agoYet they have no trouble raising tuition every year.
- SubiculumCode 8y agomany marriage fail while trying to get your PhD, imo
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 8y agoEh, there's a balance to be struck, and that's obvious to anyone that's seriously thought about this issue. There's no shortage of specious ideas. From outright quackery, the naive, or the simply misguided, there are countless ways to waste a lot of time and money on ideas that will lead nowhere. Especially when all you're guided by is intuition. That's not to say that intuition isn't valuable; rather, intuition shouldn't be the only guiding principle. If an idea is 'real' in the sense that it will produce substantive research findings, it's reasonable to expect some kind of evidence for this. Maybe you're trying to show that A -> D. Well, showing a bit about B or C can go a long way to convincing people it's worth looking at the link between A and D. The counter-argument is that it's possible there is not B or C, that a large and courageous leap is required to get to D. That's indeed possible, and arguably has been demonstrated with some famous results. But it doesn't follow that you simply must take everyone's giant leaps seriously and give them funding. Ultimately, we go by proxies. If A -> D is required, well, at least show us that you got from A to B in some other issue. Give us evidence, however imprecise, that you might be that 1 in a 1,000 (or 1,000,000?) leaper that lands somewhere successfully. So yes, there's an art to knowing when an idea is 'ripe' for a wider audience, and when it's time to stake your career on it. There's no reason you can't work on something in the background or during a sabbatical. The notion that 'academic incrementalism' is so destructive is a tenuous one, and certainly isn't being demonstrated here. To argue this is to say that Dixon would have been successful, if only he had gotten this or that position. Yet is appears that his approach was the issue, not financial or departmental support. I'd argue that the academic system correctly identified that his idea wasn't ready yet. Now that some demonstrable progress is being made, even if it falls far short of 'D', it's attracting attention and enthusiasm. Finally, the notion that academia produces no actual research is farcical.