5 ms·
I was shocked to see the list of partners involved (which is why I assume their logos are big and bold and center). I'm glad to see them participating, but I w
by jedberg 8y ago
I was shocked to see the list of partners involved (which is why I assume their logos are big and bold and center).
I'm glad to see them participating, but I wonder what their motivation is? Is it truly genuine?
I know for example that when we made the reddit API people questioned our motives since "the data was everything" and "how can reddit be willing to make the data so accessible", but we knew that in reality "the community is everything".
So I really hope these companies are similarly motivated, knowing that it is the community and their platform that are their true assets.
- jsty 8y agoFor a possible motivation, the GDPR confers a right to data portability, and whilst there is guidance[1] that this "does not create an obligation for you to adopt or maintain processing systems which are technically compatible with those of other organisations", this is probably one of the easiest ways of demonstrating compliance. For the biggest and most widely used services, it definitely would respect the spirit of the regulation more closely than e.g. just giving a json dump, since that's fairly useless to your average user. [1] https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-the-general-data-protection-regulation-gdpr/individual-rights/right-to-data-portability/ https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/guide-to-the-general-da...
- jpalomaki 8y agoI believe this might be the next big thing in EU, crafting specific legislation which allows people to "own the data" stored in various services. The PSD2 directive is already doing this in the banking world. Banks are forced to provide APIs which allow 3rd parties to access customer account information (with permission from the customer) For companies, it makes sense to be pro-active with these things instead of waiting for the legislator to force them to do stuff. If they are active enough, it might be that no legislation is needed.
- ballenf 8y ago> shocked to see the list of partners involved Google and Microsoft? Think of these companies' retail successes: - Google has basically zero retail services that are not designed to support its ads business. Chromebook and Pixel devices are arguable exceptions, but as hardware devices irrelevant to this proposal anyway. - MS has Surface, Windows and Xbox. Google's moneymaker - Ads - wouldn't be affected by portability since it has no retail customers. MS's products are equally impervious. Facebook on the other hand would be existentially threatened by this achieving ubiquity. If social media becomes federated, their monopoly rates charged advertisers would fall to competitive levels. There is Microsoft's LinkedIn and it would be very interesting to be a fly on the wall of the discussions between its execs and the MS execs overseeing this data portability project. Either they don't take the project seriously or MS thinks they may gain more imports into LinkedIn than exports. Or at least enough to come out even.
- deanCommie 8y agoTheir motivation is they are far far behind #1 AWS and need to try wild and crazy things to win market share, including acting like they are the more developer-friendly platforms because they don't lock you in.