7 ms·
Bill Clinton was very eager to get China into the WTO. Business and Industry and Clinton only saw gleeming $ signs. It blinded them to corruption, unfair prac
by mc32 8y ago
Bill Clinton was very eager to get China into the WTO. Business and Industry and Clinton only saw gleeming $ signs. It blinded them to corruption, unfair practices, etc. They all had been warned about it.
They all thought they knew better and could bring China in line.
After Clinton, GWB didn’t even try. He was too distracted by bin Laden. Obama was trying to make nice to the rest of the world during his first term, then got embroiled with the unrest he started in the ME. They had all forgotten about blue collar America. They all thought people would change jobs and these jobs would offer a good living to blue collar workers.
Surprise! It doesn’t work that way. Sure your ivy leaguers got nice cushy advisory jobs and consultancy jobs and got to talk about their adventures diring their two year China stint.
All the whole mill workers, garment workers, furniture workers, tools workers were forgotten and left behind.
Now, while inelegantly, someone is finally recognizing the grievance. It’s about time. It’s a shame it’s taken 20 years.
- vezycash 8y agoLet's not forget to blame the real culprit here, "Maximizing shareholder value." Afaik, without this constant need to cut a buck - everywhere, china would have nothing to steal because no one would go there in the first place. http://www.europeanfinancialreview.com/?p=883 http://www.europeanfinancialreview.com/?p=883
- pertsix 8y ago> They had all forgotten about blue collar America. They all thought people would change jobs and these jobs would offer a good living to blue collar workers. But.. people did change jobs? Unemployment is at an all-time low and goods and services are very cheap. Housing is not cheap, but that's a function of the wage rate (which could be argued is a function of housing costs). Just because there are more services industry jobs and less manufacturing does not mean that 'blue collar America' is forgotten -- it's just changed identities. Everyone benefits from global trade because the terms of trade should always benefit both parties.
- mc32 8y agoYes unemployment is low, but much of that is because many people have given up on finding jobs. U6 is something like 90 million. Also, most service sector jobs don’t afford you a mortgage and other lower middle class living. Most service sector workers struggle to get by, compared to your blue collar worker of yesteryear. Those people could afford a mortgage, raise three kids and send the off to state school. That ain’t happening no more.
- bjourne 8y agoThat's the same tried and tested argument that always comes up every time unemployment is discussed. See f.e https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17474163 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17474163 But it is completely false as this graph shows: https://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2018/u-3-unemployment-rate-was-4-1-percent-in-december-2017-u-6-was-8-1-percent.htm https://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2018/u-3-unemployment-rate-was-... Empirical data suggests that U6 is almost linearly dependent on U3, meaning that, indeed, the "real" unemployment in the US is record low. Yes, service jobs doesn't pay well. That is perhaps related to decades of union busting and resistance against raising minimum wages?
- late2part 8y agoI don't think unemployment is at an all time low. The media says this and the government reports say this, but the methodology for calculating this is subjective. These statistics suggest that unemployment is at 25%: http://www.shadowstats.com/alternate_data/unemployment-charts http://www.shadowstats.com/alternate_data/unemployment-chart... This article explains some concerns about the manner in which the rate is calculated: https://qz.com/877432/the-us-unemployment-rate-measure-is-deceptive-and-doesnt-need-to-be/ https://qz.com/877432/the-us-unemployment-rate-measure-is-de... "Yet to leave this group out significantly underestimates employment issues in the US. For example, the unemployment rate completely ignores the nearly 600,000 “discouraged workers” who say they are no longer looking because they don’t think they can find a job. It disregards the many students who would like a part-time job but have given up looking, and caretakers who would take a job if the compensation was high enough."
- 8y ago
- Nokinside 8y ago> All the whole milk workers, garment workers, furniture workers were forgotten and left behind. This is valid point but there is a catch. Economic growth and progress happens when countries are developing and moving up in the value chain. Developed economies are constantly moving towards high-tech and less labor incentive work. China is still industrial economy. US has moved into postindustrial economy. US manufacturing will decline despite trade wars. Manufacturing work will decline even more than GDP share of manufacturing. When low productivity work (milk, garment, furniture workers) moves to China it allows redirecting investments and resources to higher value added products. If these low productivity workers would be zombie/robots, companies would just write them off and recycle them into trash and compost - or sell them to China. But they are citizens and they vote. In other words, we have a political problem. Possible solutions: * Use tariffs to protect workers in low productivity work. This moves economic resources in the US to less competitive industries. Over decades, US falls behind other developed countries because it wants to protect industries that developing countries have. * Solve the actual political problem directly. US citizens not earning living wages with skills they have.
- cyberpunk0 8y agoThe economy is an abstract system. A better economy != a better world or quality of life for it's citizens.
- Nokinside 8y agoWhile it's not exact match with life quality, it's a good abstraction. When people start to flood from rich countries to poor countries to improve their quality of life, abstraction has served it's purpose. The difference between MRI machine and metal press is very concrete.
- mrdodge 8y ago> This moves economic resources in the US to less competitive industries. Is this really true? Does having industries like furniture-making really make it so we don't have Google?
- te_chris 8y agoIf he's 'recognising the grievance', why does he spend so much time talking about immigrants and foreigners? He's a con artist swindling disadvantaged, desperate people by telling them that their problems are all the fault of other people in their class (immigrant workers, etc), rather than people like him.
- mc32 8y agoHe actually doesn’t talk bad about legal immigrants, he acknowledges the need and their contributions to the economy. He does badmouth _illegal_ immigrants, true. But we are one of the easiest countries to get in legally, compared to Mexico, Brazil, Canada, Australia, etc. Moreover, he’s the president of the American people, not the President Of The World. He and every president has a sacred responsibility to look after his/her citizens.
- dandersh 8y ago"He actually doesn’t talk bad about immigrants" "He does badmouth _illegal_ immigrants, true" So which is it? It really doesn't matter though, as the point is that he is putting the blame on others (immigrants, other countries and their trade practices, etc.). Whether the immigrants are "illegal" or not doesn't matter in this context: it's an out group that grievances can be directed towards. I'd be remiss if I didn't leave this here: “Allowing the immigration to take place in Europe is a shame,” Trump said. “I think it changed the fabric of Europe and, unless you act very quickly, it’s never going to be what it was and I don’t mean that in a positive way. “So I think allowing millions and millions of people to come into Europe is very, very sad,” he continued. “I think you are losing your culture. Look around. You go through certain areas that didn’t exist ten or 15 years ago.” https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/politics/wp/2018/07/13/trumps-comments-on-european-immigration-mirror-white-nationalist-rhetoric/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/politics/wp/2018/07/13/t...
- mc32 8y agoUntil it became a cause celebre for progressives, Feinstein, Obama, Clinton, gov Brown, all spoke against illegal immigration. It’s not anathema to the Dems, but suddenly it’s something some think will get them votes, but they are risking alienating inner city whites and inner city blacks as well as rural white poors. Few people would argue against legal immigration ala Canada, Australia, even Brazil or Mexico. They all have pretty reasonable requirements to becoming a legal resident.
- dandersh 8y agoBefore all of that you had Reagan Democrats, who were complicit in the decline of worker's power and rights while supporting economic and trade policies that undermined blue collar jobs. They were never "forgotten and left behind", they signaled to the elites that they were happy to vote against their economic interests for whatever the culture war issue of the day is.
- mc32 8y agoUnfortunately despite being a very nice guy, Carter was not a fighter. He just took it on the chin. People wanted someone who did something. Bringing inflation down from 20% or thereabouts and bringing price stability to fuel was important. So enter Reagan. But ultimately the demise began at the hands of GHWB and Clinton who took globalization full throttle.
- dandersh 8y agoSure, if you ignore the data around wage stagnation, income inequality, accumulated wealth, etc. When you actually look at the data it tracks with another development, one often ignored (as you yourself did here): the decline of union participation and activism. I distinctly remember a debate that occurred for a time under GWB around "values voters", with "the left" (broadly and generally speaking) asking why Americans voted against their economic interests in favor of "moral values" and "the right" (again broadly and generally speaking) arguing that for some "moral values" hold more weight than economic interests. I mention this because there is a deliberate attempt to remove responsibility of blue collar workers from their plight. All those guys you mentioned? Yea, they were elected. GHWB on the strength of being Reagan's VP, Clinton was re-elected after NAFTA and his VP Gore won the popular vote, GWB won in 2004 on the strength of "values voters", etc.
- GeekyBear 8y agoI think it's worthwhile for people to go back and read this 1996 news article from the time when we were opening up China and see who led the charge and why. >The power of the new China lobby was evident in Beijing last March 7, when more than 100 representatives of major U.S. firms held their annual conference under the auspices of the U.S.-China Business Council. Delivering his first major speech since taking office just weeks before, U.S. Ambassador James Sasser told them that the Clinton administration was counting on aggressive pressure from business to secure renewal of MFN status for China. >Of course, the Fortune 500 companies that comprise the U.S.-China Business Council—led by Boeing, Motorola, Caterpillar, AT&T, and the American International Group (AIG)—hardly needed Sasser's encouragement... >Industry's real interest in China is its direct investment there (more than $25 billion), and its revenue from exporting such Chinese-made goods as electrical machinery, clothing, textiles, shoes, and toys back to the states. These exports are highly profitable for the companies, but they undercut labor's bargaining hand—and frequently take away jobs—in the United States, even as they provide a cheap source of goods. http://prospect.org/article/new-china-lobby http://prospect.org/article/new-china-lobby I'm afraid that this has always been about rearranging our trade policy so that we enrich the few at the expense of the many inside our nation.