4 ms·
So, this is actually a big deal, in the "centuries-long arc of science" sense. For hundreds of years, science has operated under the Copernican Principle [1], w
by jerf 8y ago
So, this is actually a big deal, in the "centuries-long arc of science" sense. For hundreds of years, science has operated under the Copernican Principle [1], which in a nutshell is that there is nothing particular special/unique about us. Our position on the planet is not special. Our planet is not special. Our solar system is not special. Our galaxy is not special, etc. It has been a scientifically-fruitful tool for a very long time. It has even embedded itself into the "default worldview" of the scientifically minded as a law of the universe.
But it was never more than a heuristic, and the data is increasingly coming in that the Copernican Principle breaks down at the solar system scale. In fact our Solar System is at least somewhat rare. It is certainly possible that the more we study the rarer it will become. (It can't really go the other direction at this point.)
It's going to take decades for this to properly percolate through the philosophy of science and its implications to be properly chewed on for a lot of the Big Questions.
(Note I'm not making any claims about the outcome of that process here; any such things you read into this are your own worldview poking out. I'm just saying, this is a really big event in the history of science. The sort of result that 23rd century textbooks are going to be calling out in the primary text as an important event.)
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copernican_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copernican_principle
- baq 8y agois 0.1% of a trillion special or not? :)
- jerf 8y agoFor you, that is a personal decision about the nature of "special". But I feel confident in saying, having watched the debate about the Great Questions for a couple of decades and seen at least the last ~150 years of it, and seen how firmly the default science position has entrenched itself on the hill that the Earth is completely not special [1], it's enough to falsify that position. And that's a big deal on its own. Is it possible the Earth is just a 1-in-10000 special case? Sure. But even that is enough to open the door to the question why that is, instead of the question just getting shouted down. [1]: For a modern day manifestation of this idea, consider how casually it is accepted in the "default scientific worldview" that it is very likely that we will find life in the Solar System, and virtually certain we will find it in the rest of the Universe. I'd submit that a rational look at the data gives you no reason to expect life in the rest of the Solar System at this point, with a lot of reasons to expect it won't happen, and I'll be generous and say that we simply have no data about other solar systems. (A less generous jerf would point out that to the extent we have data, it certainly seems negative for large-scale civilizations, which means all the data we have is negative, but I will concede that's somewhat weak for various reasons.) This confidence does not stem from evidence, or even any particularly well-backed scientific theories. It comes from the history of the debate over the Great Questions, and the general trend/desire to ensure that nothing is special about Earth, because the default science worldview would very much like to stuff the commonness of life and the non-specialness of humanity in the religious people's faces. You'll note I keep carefully referring to the "default science worldview", rather than simply saying "science", because I do not believe the two are the same. The default science worldview takes a number of steps that science qua science can not actually justify. Coming from me, this is merely an observation, not a criticism, since I believe any worldview has no choice but to step beyond science qua science, because "real science" underspecifies the universe by quite a bit.
- btilly 8y agoThat isn't quite right. The default assumption is that we are normal in all ways except what is required by the anthropic principle. The converse of that is that as we find ways in which we are special, we should immediately start thinking about why those things are necessary for us to be here. The classic example is that a large moon is necessary to keep our axial tilt from random flipping us too far every few tens of millions of years. Another good example is that Jupiter has played "comet sweeper", seriously reducing how many extinction level collisions we suffer. This new research just underscores the fact that these characteristics truly are essential for advanced life, and are rarer than we knew.
- kingbirdy 8y ago> It can't really go the other direction at this point What makes you say this? As I understand it, we've only detected a tiny fraction of the planets out there and it could be that there are plenty of systems out there similar to ours, we're just not capable of seeing them yet. Is there some reason to believe we're unlikely to ever see another system like ours, other than the fact that we haven't yet?
- dforrestwilson 8y agoI am always skeptical of these vast sweeping assumptions about a Universe which we have not even started to seriously explore. Based on the best available scientific tools at the time, we once thought that the solar system rotated around the earth. Based on the best scientific tools available today, we believe that our solar system and planet is extremely unique. I think we don’t know nearly enough to say with any real confidence what solar systems outside of ours look like at this point.
- jerf 8y agoThe sibling comment to yours is correct in its logic in inferring what I meant. It is true that we are ignorant of many things. It is not true that our ignorance is infinitely unbounded, and it is a denial of science and rationality, not an affirmation of it, to believe such. We have gathered enough data that we already know that our solar system is not perfectly pedestrian, and no amount of additional data short of the outright falsification of our current data (which, bear in mind, is a bigger ask than a falsification of a theory, which isn't much of an ask at all) can make it more pedestrian; it can only reveal more ways in which it is not normal.
- ta1234567890 8y ago> It is not true that our ignorance is infinitely unbounded Well, if you define our ignorance as information we don't yet have. Then if the Universe is infinite, it means our ignorance is unbounded. In fact, if any type of infinity exists, then it means in general our ignorance is unbounded, because we will never be able to have full knowledge of that infinity. For example, you can make as many assumptions as you want about the properties of the rational numbers in between two other numbers, but unless you are able to somehow "know" all of those numbers, then your ignorance about them is in part bounded by their quantity, and if it there's an infinite amount of them, your ignorance about them will be unbounded.
- credit_guy 8y agoThe way I read this article, it rather reinforces the Copernican principle. There are 3 facts in the article. 1. Planets in other systems tend to orbit faster, in a matter of weeks rather than years; therefore our system is special. Fine, this observation would go against the Copernican principle, but my guess is it's more likely to be an observation bias. Namely, if you have many transitions, before doing any math, you can't tell if it's one or several planets. If you have 10 planets, and you wrongly assume it's one, you get an perceived orbital speed that is 10 times higher (oversimplifying here a bit). If you do the math, and are able to tell apart some of the transitions, you may still think you only have 3 planets instead of 10. Identifying if transitions belong to the same planet is likely to have few false negatives but many false positives. We can follow this space, and see if future analyses confirm the current findings, or confirm my hunch. 2. Distribution of densities. Here the article mentions that for a given radius the density can vary by a factor of 10, but otherwise there is nothing special about the Earth. I would call this a plus for the Copernican principle 3. The distribution of planet sizes. This one is double peaked, and the size of the Earth is part of one peak, not of the valley. This is a big plus for the Copernican principle.
- jvanderbot 8y agoOn 1. 10 planets equally radially spaced dont cause a wobble like 1 going fast. Also 10 planets equally spaced are quickly not equally spaced due to differing orbit vel. 10 isn't the problem, assuming aliasing is the problem.