10 ms·
Open plan offices don’t live up to the hype, finds Harvard Business School study
- smt88 8y agoI know companies that are switching to open offices this year. One is Fortune 500. Open offices will continue to be used as (bad, short-sighted) cost-saving measures while decision-makers continue to pretend they're fun and/or foster collaboration.
- iamdave 8y agodecision-makers continue to pretend they're fun and/or foster collaboration That's because 99 times out 100, those decision makers don't subject themselves to the open office. They always get their own quiet nook of the workspace with a door while the workforce gets the joy of learning how noise-cancelling headphones work (or, on the flip side: learn that their favorite brand of headphones aren't doing the job).
- maxxxxx 8y agoExactly. In my company the facilities department shrugs off any suggestions that the current layout is too loud and hard to work in. Obviously they themselves work in a nice quiet team office with 5 people and everybody has a nice window seat with plenty of space. It should be required that whoever makes these decisions should have to dogfood them.
- iamdave 8y agoI don't disagree but It should be required that whoever makes these decisions should have to dogfood them. By what mechanism would this occur? I've spent enough time in the military to know human ego will never allow this to happen, it's like asking the fox to put a lock on the hen house, and turn the keys over to the farmer. Outside of exceptional leaders like the ones where lykr0n works-that actually want to be and behave like leaders-very rarely will you see command subjecting themselves to the shit endured by the commanded.
- maxxxxx 8y agoIn the case of the open office it should be required that the people who make the decision also work in the same office layout. That's not difficult to do. Don't overthink it. Let's start with CEOs and VPs work elbow by elbow in an open layout and have to buy headphones.
- iamdave 8y agoDon't overthink it. This isn't asking antagonistically, it's a legitimate ask, so I hope you'll understand my tone isn't one of aggression: How am I over thinking it? The proposed idea is to require leaders sit with their constituents. Leaders are the ones choosing these horrible open office layouts. How do you make them do something that in many cases, as many folks are replying in this thread to the effect of-they do not want to do? Do you appeal to the board of directors? What does that look like? When one says "this should be required", my immediate thought is, okay how do you implement it, and how do you actually enforce it? And that's what I'm asking here. I don't think I'm overthinking it, but thinking exactly the question that will need to be answered if that suggestion is to take root anywhere. How do you require the leaders of your company to do something they might not want to do?
- alexhutcheson 8y agoCEOs and VPs (and even the layer of middle management below them at a big company) probably have a schedule that's almost 100% full of meetings, so the specifics of where their desk is normally don't even matter.
- thomasmeeks 8y agoI had this same realization. In this context it doesn't work as well, anyway, because senior leaders are in meetings so often that their desk is fairly meaningless. But to generalize at a higher level -- "by what mechanism do we force management to be decent?" -- the only one I've discovered is to be willing to leave jobs that have management practices that one doesn't agree with. Unfortunately that advice doesn't work in the general case -- mobility is relatively easy for developers but we don't make up a large part of the population. I feel like the right answer is some changes in our social structure or economy that makes job mobility much (much) easier. Like a BI/Negative Income Tax, or free education, etc.
- lykr0n 8y agoWhere I work, the Senior Leadership sits in various Hexes and are given no preferred treatment (except for having their own conference room that they don't have to share). There would be a lot of resentment if they closed themselves off into their own area like more of the old gaurd typically does.
- framebit 8y agoThe higher-ups in my open office technically have desks out here with us, but they spend so much time on the road or have meetings in conference rooms that it's a completely different experience. Same with sales folks who are on the road the road 70% of the time but come back to have loud phone calls for that 30%.
- technofiend 8y ago>...gets the joy of learning how noise-cancelling headphones work (or, on the flip side: learn that their favorite brand of headphones aren't doing the job). Or like me learn those chronic ear infections you suffered as a kid can be triggered as an adult by wearing in-ear headphones for a few hours. Open-back headphones like the AKG K7XX don't cause the issue for me, but then again if I crank them enough to drown out that one annoying coworker then everyone around me hears what I'm listening to and it can trigger my tinnitus. Damn. Maybe I need to apply for an office because I have a hearing-related disability. :-)
- breischl 8y agoThe execs at our company put themselves in the same open-plan... but then they each perma-booked a conference room for their own personal use. So they don't really live it, and they made the problem of scarce conference room space even worse. Win-win! /s
- organsnyder 8y agoToday is my last day at a job with an open plan office. It's one of the main reasons I'm leaving.
- lsiunsuex 8y agoAnd dress code. At least we have cubes; but until last month, we had to dress business casual. Now for $15 / month donation to a charity the company chooses, we can wear jeans all month. No big deal in the summer when it's 60-90F but wearing dress pants to work when it's 5F and 3 feet of snow is really crappy. If it didn't change soon, I was considering leaving; it did last month, so no real plans to move right now, lol... (I don't mind the $15 / month so long as it goes to a good cause and the vast majority of the employees (400+) are choosing to do it)
- loa-in-backup 8y agoWhat? I would forgo the donation, and wear jeans anyway. For me it smells of coercion to fund something.
- lsiunsuex 8y agoIt's usually cancer institutes; pet rescues, shelters, etc... The employees submit suggestions where to donate every month and the business chooses 1 every month. Not like it's going to a shell company or some other ridiculous movie story plot, lol...
- snoman 8y agoYou're probably right, but are you getting the tax deduction for donating, or is your employer? 400 * 15 * 12 = 72,000 / yr that your employer may be deducting from wages on the backs of their employees... voluntary or not. Then they get to advertise their generosity and optional dress code. I hate thinking pessimistically like this, but you get conned enough times... and it's not like they actually need a dress code, if they're comfortable with taking money for people not abiding by it.
- gdulli 8y agoWasn't the "hype" a lightweight misdirection from the fact that putting employees in the smallest/cheapest amount of square footage was always the goal?
- hotsauceror 8y agoOf course it was. It is surprising to see how often this kind of PR-driven messaging is accepted at face value by the business press, academics, etc. Nonetheless, it's not enough to dismiss a statement based on the ulterior motives behind its utterance; someone still has to collect the data to prove or disprove it.
- mlthoughts2018 8y agoMany companies already spend inefficiently (from a productivity point of view) on stupid lavish office features like gourmet coffee stations, video game rooms, roof decks, or things like booze-focused parties. I don’t get why anyone believes open-plan offices are chosen to save money. Maybe in the most spartan of bootstrapped startups, sure, but most of the time it’s for optics and status signalling, part of turning the office into a shrine to the executives. Companies have been studying, measuring and carefully quantifying knowledge worker productivity for a hundred years. The idea that “productivity lost to open spaces is hard to measure, but short term savings is an obvious win on paper” is silly. Companies are not that stupid. No, open plan offices are deliberately chosen for status and optics, and to some extent to make the environment routinize your fealty as a worker and ingrain into your mind the obvious fact that your productivity isn’t valued; that your economic worth in most of these companies is higher if you function like a decorative piece of furniture.
- ghaff 8y agoI expect most companies who do it genuinely believe it's what the cool kids are doing for all sorts of good reasons. But it doesn't hurt that it saves money into the bargain. If it increased facilities costs significantly, I expect there would be less enthusiasm. It's like eco initiatives at hotels. Looking green with respect to housekeeping would be less interesting if it cost them money rather than saved them. I don't really disagree with your status and optics argument though.
- drb91 8y agoThe hype of open offices is how many people you can cram in a room. I’m tired of pretending otherwise.
- greyfox 8y agoagreed. i work in a drafting company and theres no phone call privacy and others are being loud on the phone and all that ... its terrible.
- thomasmeeks 8y agoI think that is a large part of it, I strongly agree. However, I think there are two other factors that come into play that are very tough for people to vocalize when they are defending an open office. 1. Open offices are more appealing visually to a wider swath of people. Of course you can make either kind of office pretty, but there's something about humans that just really loves the wide open spaces. 2. Humans are social, we like to interact, even at the expense of productivity. Personally, I prefer an office-per-team approach, so sort of a middle ground that allows for fast collaboration but doesn't require negotiating with 100 other people on the same floor about noise level, etc.
- crankylinuxuser 8y ago> 2. Humans are social, we like to interact, even at the expense of productivity. Wrong. Extroverts like to interact. Not introverts. And the extroverts are usually who are put into positions of power, and think that everyone is like them. It is sheer hell to work in IT and yet another cattle-class open office.
- drb91 8y agoI disagree; I am introverted and I enjoy interacting. It's my inability to control when and for how long that poses an issue in an open office environment.
- Bartweiss 8y ago> 2. Humans are social, we like to interact, even at the expense of productivity. The one result I've found most surprising from these studies is that open-plan offices tend to reduce face-to-face interactions. Trading short-term productivity against satisfaction is perfectly reasonable, but I worry that in practice the lack of privacy and fear of distracting others mean that open offices aren't even good for socializing. What I've found very valuable for all the things open offices claim to do is having some shared open area that isn't a workspace. A centralized kitchen area or anything else that recreates the traditional 'watercooler' works for facilitating chance interactions and allowing easy socialization without all the hassle of talking behind coworkers' desks. Cynically, it looks a bit like the 90s-downsizing-era push for productive spaces killed off watercooler discussion, and open offices are a kludge to bring it back a the pretense of productivity because people are at their desks. In reality, I don't think the connection is so direct, but I'd still prefer we admit that chatting and working are both valuable neither is well-served by putting them in one space.
- crack-the-code 8y agoI'm curious to know I'll f there is a study that these open office plans to actually work.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- hashkb 8y agoIs there any research that shows open plan has any benefits other than cost? Why do we keep acting like this is surprising news?
- iamdave 8y agoThe only thing surprising that with so much evidence of how it hurts workers, the people making those decisions do not seem to care. And by that I mean not surprising at all. You know that one quote from Upton Sinclair? "It is difficult to get someone to understand something whose salary depends on them not understanding it"? Fits this issue like a glove.
- pravint 8y agoIt’s surprising to see how companies pay hundreds of thousands of dollars salary per annum to the employees but fail to provide work environment which enables them to maximize their productivity.
- toyg 8y agoI'm sure somebody would say that's precisely because they pay people so much, that they are constantly out to reduce costs elsewhere. In reality, managers are simply on the constant lookout to squeeze costs down, and worker salaries escape the cut only in some job markets because of very specific circumstances (like a period of history when the need to build software severely outstrips overall production capacity). There is no real master plan to maximize productivity.
- ben509 8y agoTheir performance numbers are sketchy as all hell, so even if they had some way of comparing performance with and without constant noise, would they be able to glean reliable information from it? So it's close to perfect information on rent vs. some vague and unquantifiable "I can't focus" complaints regarding the noise in a work environment.
- 1_800_UNICORN 8y agoI just want to remind folks that there are, in fact, organizations for whom the open plan actually works. I've spent the last few years practicing XP, on a collaborative team that includes PM, UX, QA, and devs, and we work in an open plan with no complaints. We find that it REALLY helps us minimize meetings and email/Slack since we can quickly turn to the person we need, ask our question, get an answer, and get back to work. As a developer it's hugely refreshing to be able to easily ask for advice or input from the rest of the dev team in a rapid way. The reason I mention this anecdote is not to dispute any of the studies... I understand the difference between anecdotal evidence and quantitative evidence. Just a counter-point to the inevitable echo chamber of complaints about open floor plans being inhumane, a money-grab, etc etc.
- ta2987 8y agoHow do you actually get any work done?
- nine_k 8y agoAnswering a question in person likely breaks your concentration for a few minutes. Having to wait for 5-10 minutes for an answer in Slack breaks the concentration of the person asking the question, _and_ your concentration because you still need to get distracted and answer the question. Async communication is great in many cases, likely most cases. Sync communication does have important uses, though.
- dvtrn 8y agoAnswering a question in person likely breaks your concentration for a few minutes. I'm going to argue that their concentration is already broken because there's a problem, needing remediation and help from a colleague on to the point of bothering to ask in the first place. And if you're sitting three feet away from me, I'm sorry but I'd much rather just flip around, ask if you have a minute, answer the question, and drive closer to the desired team outcome. Change my mind.
- 8y ago
- motohagiography 8y agoThis topic seems to appear quarterly here. I've commented on it before. If they are as bad as we think they are, there must be a "closed office," arbitrage play where you can beat other startups with more adult interior design.
- toyg 8y agoFog Creek did it, and it seems to have paid off for them. The problem is that, for most businesses, cash is king. Hard-to-measure productivity improvements will invariably lose to immediate financial rewards.
- anildash 8y agoYeah, we've had a lot of success with this at Fog Creek, but the overall diagnosis is correct: most companies make false optimizations for short-term gain over long-term. Sometimes it's understandable because resources are constrained, but other times it's truly inexplicable.
- tfandango 8y agoI wonder if cubicles are considered open plan or not? I used to work in those and found them more private than the open plan I work in now. I imagine most companies are trying to avoid the corporate cube farm appearance in favor of the cool open plan startup vibe. Personally I try to work from home once in a while so I can concentrate.
- toyg 8y ago> I wonder if cubicles are considered open plan or not? Not.
- nine_k 8y agoI have two screens before me; they take ~90% of my field of view, the rest occupied by the desk. I look at the large windows sometimes, when I need to contemplate and refocus my eyes. I have good ear-on headphones that isolate me from the sounds of the office most of the day. I have a comfortable chair, and a large enough desk to never touch my colleagues who sit next to me. I have a pretty minimal amount of personal stuff on the desk: a mug, a phone charging stand; my backpack is under the desk. I'm pretty much insulated from the rest of the open office I'm sitting in, and have no idea what's happening around unless I choose to take a look. If you want to collaborate, well, come closer and wave your hand so that I noticed you and removed the headphones. Good thing you can notice if I'm sitting at my desk (or went for a coffee) from the other end of the open space. I did work in smaller, near personal offices. They used to have a somehow poorer window views, and did not offer a lot in the quietness department, because people talking next to you make the same noise in a small office and a large (open-space) office. Only a truly personal office helps here. OTOH a properly sound-insulated personal office would either feel claustrophobic to many people, or have to be rather large. With large, low-density personal offices, walking to someone becomes a lengthier process. Instead I think that an open(ish) office, a culture of keeping reasonably quiet, and a good set of meeting rooms and phone rooms gives you the best of both worlds: a private space when you need to talk at length, and close proximity when you don't.
- npongratz 8y ago> If you want to collaborate, well, come closer and wave your hand so that I noticed you and removed the headphones. Sure would be nice if people would merely wave their hand in front of me. Nope, instead, everyone [0] does one (or both) of two things: come up behind me and tap my shoulder, or come up behind me and shout. I don't blame them for wanting my attention, but the end result is the same: I physically jump, sometimes yelp, and it takes me many minutes to get back to the same level of productivity I was before the ambush. Is "ambush" too strong a word? Nope. To my reptile brain, it's exactly what happened: so now it's time to fight or flee. For me, open offices are evil. It's the place I go to get ambushed. [0] Even coworkers who know how I will respond. They've said so, apologize, and still do it.
- 8y ago
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- nimbius 8y agoas someone who works a blue-collar job, we tried this in one of our larger auto repair shops and it was a hillarious disaster. The layout is simple, the back of the shop handles repairs, maintenance, customer orders and such for things like oil changes, and the 'front office' handles your paperwork and such. our owner decided (after a TED talk and one too many martinis at the motel wet bar) we needed to be more open. We tore down dividers and pushed all the desks together and after six months, we'd made nearly everyone insane. invoice printers (impact style) drowned out most of our sales calls. accounts and finance often took their laptops into the garage bays for peace and quiet, which meant laptops littered all over our workbenches during their lunch break. Insurance cited us for having them in the work shop. Some customers...well most...mistook us frequently for a bank, or an adjacent business. our dock/shipping delivery clerk was now hammer-stamping bills of lading right next to one of our senior managers and had to hike back to the docks every 20 minutes (his fitbit tracked 10k steps in 4 hours one day.) The whole thing fell apart when a parts manager accidentally kicked over a waste urea tank fluid container and sent two gallons of rancid liquid into the waiting room carpet.
- syshum 8y agowas it accidentally or "accidentally"
- namibj 8y agoAt least you got out without anyone getting hurt...
- HillaryBriss 8y agothank you for this entertaining and educational story! the spilled urea tank is a particularly interesting element. it seriously seems like this kind of disaster could be used to get other offices to move away from the open plan. hmmm. what might be the "spilled urea tank" moment in a software startup's office? maybe something related to the CEO's personal information being leaked.
- iamdave 8y agowhat might be the "spilled urea tank" moment in a software startup's office? maybe something related to the CEO's personal information being leaked. Yeah probably this. The number of people who I observe walking away from their machines without locking the desktop on a daily basis is terrifying from a security standpoint.
- outime 8y agoI’ve learned to appreciate open offices after a while - I really like having quick access to colleagues (after quickly asking through chat or when they’re obviously available). I believe that a good culture and library-like rules can make it work and provide some benefits. It also has some obvious drawbacks (more visual distractions, flu spreading, etc), but I believe the main culprit often is companies having open offices with no “rules” e.g. random people screaming or laughing histerically. People is then forced to isolate themselves with NC-headphones which obviously kills the benefits this layout has.
- pixelpp 8y agoI think this depends on personalities. I worked in an open office where there were people going crazy because there were a bunch of loud extroverts. I am extroverted and cubicles make me develop bad habits like watching YouTube all day, and such. I need constant interaction with people. Ideating with other designers gives me life, and expands my creativity.
- youdontknowtho 8y agoI hope whoever keeps submitting these stories finally gets their boss to notice and gets the cubicle walls that they want so much. Full disclaimer: I have some and they are awesome.
- athenot 8y agoI've been in open plan offices that worked great and others that were terrible. But I take issue with this part of the article: > Open plan offices have taken off because of a desire to increase interaction and collaboration among workers. This is the reason invoked after the fact. The real motivation is a financial one. You have X sqft of office space, Y people you'd like to fit in. Open plan offices are seen as the most efficicent way to cram a lot of people into a smaller space. Then more loftly reasons are invoked so that the company doesn't look cheap.
- ben509 8y agoI agree that's going to be a much bigger factor, and when you look at commercial office space, you'd be shocked at how much space walls or even dividers chew up, and how much it costs in rent. But I was on a team where the devs all wanted an open plan, so they weren't motivated by square footage. They specifically requested that all the dividers be taken out, and the Powers That Be didn't really want to because that wound up costing more as they were getting shafted by their contractors for absurdly simple jobs.
- gutnor 8y ago> The real motivation is a financial one. And the absolute hatred people on HN have for it is most likely due to the downgrade from personal office to shared space. In Europe, where personal offices never really happened outside management, Open Office are not working better, but they are the norm that people accept, not a anger inducing topic.
- mieseratte 8y agoI've never had a private office, accept for the time I tried holing up in an unused server closet, but I have had a semi-private cube and compared to it open offices are absolute shit. In terms of space, cubicles aren't much different than open-office but there is a cost reduction (cheap Ikea desks vs. desk and walls). I wonder how much is cost, how much is space, and how much is being able to directly see all your peons when managers make these decisions. Personally, If I weren't about to go remote I'd probably come in one weekend and setup a semi-permanent deer stand as my desk...
- tombert 8y agoI had a comment on this about a week ago where I was complaining about the world cup noise on a TV right behind me, and I stand by that. People yelling during a sporting event, or just generally horseplaying, ends up being very distracting to me. I'm aware headphones exist, but I typically work better in near-silence, which is borderline impossible with an open office plan. This is in combination with the fact that I'm pretty sure I've gotten at least one illness from a coworker in the past when he sneezed. It's possible I would have gotten it anyway, but I think it's a non-controversial thing to say that close contact to people can make disease spread more easily. I think these open offices are here to stay, since the rest of my coworkers (and indeed, a large percentage of the hacker workforce) seem to feel like they work better with them. Still, a guy can dream...or look for a remote job.
- bazooka_penguin 8y agoWhy not a compromise. Sit small teams together in separate cubes or offices? Once I was stuck with half my team in a conference room because of renovations in the office and while I can't speak for productivity it was a good environment for my sanity. Everyone was quiet enough and we were a tight knit group of young developers so it went smoothly enough. The other half of the team fared a little worse because of a few contentious individuals though
- evfanknitram 8y agoWhat's the benefit with cramming a team of say 8 people in the same room? Not sure I follow.
- ken 8y agoThe higher costs of a build out, combined with the increased noise of open floor plan, and no comment on productivity. This sounds like the worst kind of compromise: cut the baby in half.
- legitster 8y agoFrom data I have collected for our organization: - Random small interruptions were the biggest killers of productivity. - In a cube environment, productivity is already very high. If people need something, they have no problem taking a few steps and asking about it. - The bigger complaint was the lack of adequate meeting spaces. Managers never perceived this because they had offices to meet in, so they only cared about having a few, very big meeting spaces. - A space that doesn't have a shutting door is useless to collaborate/meet in. - Very few people actually care about the size of their cubicles. A lot of people care about the heights of their cubicles and the number of walls. I wish more organizations were honest about their decisions to move to open-office. If you actually work with and listen to your employees' needs you can actually find more ideal compromises. But if you just start ripping out cubes to save money and tell employees it's going to be great, it's incredibly hostile.
- sctb 8y agoPrevious discussions: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17448187 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17448187 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17513843 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17513843
- beefman 8y agoAnd the original source for this particular article: https://theconversation.com/a-new-study-should-be-the-final-nail-for-open-plan-offices-99756 https://theconversation.com/a-new-study-should-be-the-final-...
- scarejunba 8y agoThe actual study points out that on most of the measures, full open plan beat cubicles (high and low walled) and only barely lose to shared offices. I suppose a more interesting question is how much a seating plan contributes to revenue, operating margin, and growth. It is indeed interesting that people report higher ease of collaboration in full private offices. Perhaps the ability to have a conversation in an office means that you don't have to go somewhere to talk and so it works out. Anyway, given the measures in the study, full open plan with no restrictions come out looking pretty good.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tonygrue 8y agoafaict, this study looked at only two instances of fortune 500 companies who moved some people to open office plans and compared them to those who were not moved. Additionally, they measured 'interactions', which was a self defined metric that afaict has no grounding in anything. I'm not sure if one of two Fortune 500 companies, used to working in an office, generalizes to me. So, I'm not sure how much I personally weight the outcome of this study. I've worked in both offices and open office plans, and there were things I did and didn't like about both. Offices required more formal mind-melding but I had more concentration time during peak business hours. Pit allowed me to feel more camaraderie, but required me to work off hours to get concentrated work done. If it were up to be I'd do 3 days in an office and 2 days in a open pit.
- kabdib 8y agoI work in a largely open space environment, and it's fine. The thing that makes it fine is that our desks are on wheels, and we are free to relocate to any part of the company that we like, no permission needed. (Well, the other big components are (1) a fair amount of uncommitted or otherwise fluid space to move around in, and (2) a large degree of freedom and self-determination). Want to make a team? Find a room, move your desks in there and ->poof<- you have a team. Need to sit nearer the two people you're working closely with this week? Just move your desks together for a while, while staying in the same room as the project. Need your own office for a month or two? You can probably find one, or at least find an out-of-the-way corner that is quiet. I've worked in open-plan spaces where you had assigned seating, and it was fucking miserable. An open plan combined with autonomy and trust works pretty well.
- loco5niner 8y ago> Want to make a team? Find a room, move your desks in there and ->poof<- you have a team. Need to sit nearer the two people you're working closely with this week? Just move your desks together for a while, while staying in the same room as the project. Need your own office for a month or two? You can probably find one, or at least find an out-of-the-way corner that is quiet. Wow, sounds great.
- Pica_soO 8y agoDear god, imagine if they gunned down the open office space as a a concept. The efficiency dreams they will develop next and their slogans: "Working in a sleep (al)coffin, to always be well rested. Work like a borg, rest like a swede." "Working in several layers of hammock, to get the hang off it." "Working cuddled together in a transparent ballpit room, to grow as a social being." "Working from your own car, from the parking space. Cause the best office, is where you feel the drive." There is always a level of dystopia beneath the dystopia of today. The open office is driving the home office movement. The only thing preventing the home office from triumphing, is the failure to create external meetups - either at home or at another temporary location.