5 ms·
No, atheism is the outright rejection of the idea of God. It is a religious belief in itself that requires a faith in the non-existence of any sort of God. It d
by ThomPete 16y ago
No, atheism is the outright rejection of the idea of God. It is a religious belief in itself that requires a faith in the non-existence of any sort of God. It does not ask for an explanation of God, for if it did it would have to accept the possibility of a God.
This is pure nonsense. Kindergarden logic.
I am an atheist because I don't have god in my life. I live without god. It's not a non-belief in god. It's simply that I don't believe in this thing that someone claim exist any more than I believe that we are living in the matrix or that advanced aliens created us.
If we are to follow your line of reasoning then all believers who are only allowed to have one god would be going against their belief by not believing in the thousands of other gods out there.
- itistoday 16y agoI am an atheist because I don't have god in my life. I live without god. It's not a non-belief in god. It's simply that I don't believe in this thing that someone claim exist any more than I believe that we are living in the matrix or that advanced aliens created us. You accuse me of spouting nonsense, yet you actually make two contradictory claims: 1) "It's not a non-belief in god." 2) "It's simply that I don't believe in this thing" (thing referring to "god") Statement #2 is clearly an admission that you hold a non-belief in god. I think part of the problem here is that you do have a belief in God. You believe "God" to refer to some specific thing, and it is that thing that you choose not to believe in. Whatever that is, I don't know, but if you assume that the word "God" has a clear and singular definition, well, then you don't know very much about religion, do you? :-) But that doesn't seem to be the case, it just sounds like you might be a little confused, as in your last sentence, you demonstrate an understanding that there are in fact multiple definitions for the word "god". So, what is atheism then, really? Wikipedia gives the following definition: Atheism, in a broad sense, is the rejection of belief in the existence of deities.[1] In a narrower sense, atheism is specifically the position that there are no deities.[2] Most inclusively, atheism is simply the absence of belief that any deities exist.[3] We must then investigate further, because this definition begs the question of what is meant by the word "deity". A click and we get this definition: A deity[1] is a postulated preternatural or supernatural immortal being, who may be thought of as holy, divine, or sacred, held in high regard, and respected by believers, often religiously referred to as a god. Here I think the relevant word is not "immortal", for there may in fact be something that is immortal (the universe is immortal), but rather "preternatural" and "supernatural". And that is were the crux is. For the mystics do not believe that God is supernatural or "preternatural". This is not the notion of God as understood in Hinduism or Buddhism, for example. In those religions, God is natural. God is nature. So, if you identify as an atheist, and by that you mean you disbelieve in a God that is outside of nature, then I think that is just fine (and fairly unremarkable), but if you disbelieve also in the second type of God, the one who is one with nature, then that is another thing entirely. You may in fact believe in God, but you just might not have known about the various meanings of that word.
- ThomPete 16y agoYou apparently forgot what your claim was: No, atheism is the outright rejection of the idea of God. It is a religious belief in itself that requires a faith in the non-existence of any sort of God. And you also forgot one definition. Namely that of religion: Religion is the belief in and worship of a god or gods, or a set of beliefs concerning the origin and purpose of the universe. Please explain what god or gods i believe by not believing in god? Please explain what atheists believe in? I am an atheist by definition. Not by belief.
- itistoday 16y agoYou apparently forgot what your claim was: No, atheism is the outright rejection of the idea of God. It is a religious belief in itself that requires a faith in the non-existence of any sort of God. Yes, you are right to point that out; after looking up the definition on wikipedia I saw the nuance regarding "supernatural" and expounded upon that above. And you also forgot one definition. Namely that of religion: How so? I generally tend to agree with that definition of religion. Notice how physics overlaps that (cosmology and TOEs specifically). Please explain what god or gods i believe by not believing in god? Please explain what atheists believe in? I already addressed this above. If you have a specific question let me know.
- ThomPete 16y agoNo you didn't address it. You argue as if you know what my belief is. So I ask you again. What is my belief? What is it that I believe in that makes me religious. Which god do I believe in?
- itistoday 16y agoYou said you were an atheist, and I went through what the commonly accepted definition of that was. I quoted it. That is what atheism is. If you call yourself an atheist, then that is what you believe, unless you call yourself an atheist yet hold beliefs that are different from what atheism is understood to be, in which case, you might want to choose another word.
- crpatino 16y agoPete. I would not call you an atheist, but an agnostic. You are not emotionally attached to the idea that there is not and cannot be any god... but you simply accept the fact that we don´t have evidence to tell there´s one for sure. I think this is the idea that Itistoday tried to say. That there is some subset of militant atheist who believe so strongly in science, that they do not accept any possibility that there is something that science cannot explain. Traditional religions being the forefront example of such beliefs, they develop an irrational hatred of anything related to that.